SlideShare a Scribd company logo
REDUNDANCYPRINCIPLES
We can see manymultimedia-learningscenarioshave simultaneoustextandaudioinourlives.The
redundancyprinciplestatesthatlearnerscanlearnbetterjustwithanimationandnarration.The
visual textinformation,whichis presentedsimultaneouslytothe verbal information,becomesa
redundantmaterial.Eliminatingredundantmaterial,avoidingnarrationand"identical"textwillbe a
goodway to letlearnerslearnwell.The basicreasonispeople can'tfocuswhentheybothhearand
see the same verbal message duringapresentation(Hoffman,2006).
Potential ProblemswithAddingRedundantOn-ScreenText
The common beliefthatusesspokenandprintedformsduringthe presentationsshouldalwaysbe
betterforlearners.Learnerscanchoose the formatdependedontheirlearningpreferences.Butthis
learningstyleshypothesisnormallyisnotestablished.ClarkandMayer(2011) describedseveral
potential problems.
Learnersmay attract by printedwordsandmaypay lessattentiontothe accompanyinggraphics.
Learnersmay experiencecognitive overloadinthe visual channel duringafastpace multimedia
presentationwhichhasredundanton-screentext.
Learnersmay tryto compare the differentformats.
Special Situationsforthe RedundancyPrinciple
There are a fewspecial situationswhereusingredundanttextisacceptable andevensuggested.
There isa complete absence of anyonscreenpictorial information.
There has enoughtime toprocessthe pictorial presentation.
The relatedaudiomightbe difficultforthe learnertounderstand--aswithforeignlanguagelearning
or certainauditorylearningdisabilities.The visual textwill be helpful forlearnerstounderstand.
StudiesthatSupportthe RedundancyPrinciple
A varietyof studiessupportthe redundancyprinciple.Kalyuga,Chandler&Sweller(2004) suggested
that a workingmemoryloadwill be generatedif learnersare requiredtocoordinate redundant
materials.SoonFook,&Aldalalah(2010) investigatedthe effectsof instructional the redundancy
principlesonthe learningof musictheoryamongprimarypupils.AnAI(audioandimage) mode is
more effectivelythanthe TI (textwithimage) andAIT(audiowithimage andtext) modes.
Critique of the RedundancyPrinciple
The redundancytheorymayworkfor certaincases,but itmay not applytoall.More researchis
neededtodetermine the situationsinwhichthe redundancyprinciple doesnothold(Clark&Mayer,
2011). Sorden(2005) discussedthatdependingonthe learners’experiences,peoplemayfeel
differentaboutredundantinformationvaries.A diagramwithtextmaybe helpbeginnerto
understand.Atthe same time,the same strategymightbecome redundantfora more experienced
learner.
References
Hoffman,B.(2006). The Encyclopediaof Educational Technology.SanDiego,CA:MontezumaPress
Clark,R. C.,& Mayer,R. E. (2011). E-Learningandthe Science of Instruction:ProvenGuidelinesfor
ConsumersandDesignersof MultimediaLearning(3rded.).SanFrancisco,CA:JohnWiley& Sons.
Kalyuga,S.,Chandler,P.,&Sweller,J.(2004).WhenRedundantOn-ScreenTextinMultimedia
Technical InstructionCanInterfere WithLearning.HumanFactors,46(3), 567-581.
SoonFook,F., & Aldalalah,O.(2010).Effectsof Computer-basedInstructionalDesignsamong
Internals-Externals:A Cognitive LoadPerspective.EuropeanJournal of Social Science,14(12),164-
182.
SordenS.D. (2005). A cognitive approachtoinstructional designformultimedialearning.
InformationScience Journal, 8(1), 263-279.

More Related Content

PPTX
Underpinning Principles of Presentation
PPTX
Principles of Multimedia
PPTX
The 14 principles of multimedia learning
PPTX
Principles Of Multimedia
PPTX
Redundancy Principle
PPT
Multimedia Learning
PPTX
el control presupuestario
DOCX
Underpinning Principles of Presentation
Principles of Multimedia
The 14 principles of multimedia learning
Principles Of Multimedia
Redundancy Principle
Multimedia Learning
el control presupuestario

Viewers also liked (15)

DOC
Curriculum vitae
PDF
Journey to the cloud in banking and finance webinar
DOCX
Eyeplug
PDF
SCIENCE and EDUCATION a NEW DIMENSION NATURAL and TECHNICAL SCIENCE Issue 83
DOCX
aquaculture research work
PDF
C21 Logo
PPTX
Reciclaje anexo 2
PDF
Why learn jenkins via nomad_ci (nomad/consul/docker/jenkins) 
PDF
07k4114 bai tapso1
PDF
Junho 2016 - Testes de Carga com Locust
PPTX
The 3 Rs - Redundancy, Restructure and Reorganisation
PDF
Continuous Delivery Pipeline with Docker and Jenkins
PDF
Context Driven School of testing w prostych przykładach
PPTX
Tiempo de degradación de residuos sólidos
PDF
Finnish lessons summary
Curriculum vitae
Journey to the cloud in banking and finance webinar
Eyeplug
SCIENCE and EDUCATION a NEW DIMENSION NATURAL and TECHNICAL SCIENCE Issue 83
aquaculture research work
C21 Logo
Reciclaje anexo 2
Why learn jenkins via nomad_ci (nomad/consul/docker/jenkins) 
07k4114 bai tapso1
Junho 2016 - Testes de Carga com Locust
The 3 Rs - Redundancy, Restructure and Reorganisation
Continuous Delivery Pipeline with Docker and Jenkins
Context Driven School of testing w prostych przykładach
Tiempo de degradación de residuos sólidos
Finnish lessons summary
Ad

Similar to Redundancy principles (20)

PPT
Modality2
PDF
Key Principles in Using Multimedia - IECTA Jan 22.pptx.pdf
PPTX
Chw webinar session
PPTX
Clark ch 5 and 6
PPTX
Presentation1 for imtic
PPTX
ELN 102 Revised Presentation
PPTX
Presentation1 for imtic
PPTX
Portfolio 1 the modality principle in multimedia learning 520
PPTX
The modality principle in multimedia learning edlt 520
PPTX
Presentation1 for imtic
PPTX
U3 wiki 2 marie smith
PPTX
Mayer's theory of multimendia learning
PPTX
mutlimedia development process: 12 principles
PPTX
The Redundancy Principle
PDF
Creating Digital Resources using Instructional Design Principles
PPT
Learning Design for the Brain - Multimedia Principles
PPTX
Pretraining project
PPTX
Module 1 assignment 2 (adanna britto)
PPTX
12 Principles of Multimedia Design.pptx
Modality2
Key Principles in Using Multimedia - IECTA Jan 22.pptx.pdf
Chw webinar session
Clark ch 5 and 6
Presentation1 for imtic
ELN 102 Revised Presentation
Presentation1 for imtic
Portfolio 1 the modality principle in multimedia learning 520
The modality principle in multimedia learning edlt 520
Presentation1 for imtic
U3 wiki 2 marie smith
Mayer's theory of multimendia learning
mutlimedia development process: 12 principles
The Redundancy Principle
Creating Digital Resources using Instructional Design Principles
Learning Design for the Brain - Multimedia Principles
Pretraining project
Module 1 assignment 2 (adanna britto)
12 Principles of Multimedia Design.pptx
Ad

Redundancy principles

  • 1. REDUNDANCYPRINCIPLES We can see manymultimedia-learningscenarioshave simultaneoustextandaudioinourlives.The redundancyprinciplestatesthatlearnerscanlearnbetterjustwithanimationandnarration.The visual textinformation,whichis presentedsimultaneouslytothe verbal information,becomesa redundantmaterial.Eliminatingredundantmaterial,avoidingnarrationand"identical"textwillbe a goodway to letlearnerslearnwell.The basicreasonispeople can'tfocuswhentheybothhearand see the same verbal message duringapresentation(Hoffman,2006). Potential ProblemswithAddingRedundantOn-ScreenText The common beliefthatusesspokenandprintedformsduringthe presentationsshouldalwaysbe betterforlearners.Learnerscanchoose the formatdependedontheirlearningpreferences.Butthis learningstyleshypothesisnormallyisnotestablished.ClarkandMayer(2011) describedseveral potential problems. Learnersmay attract by printedwordsandmaypay lessattentiontothe accompanyinggraphics. Learnersmay experiencecognitive overloadinthe visual channel duringafastpace multimedia presentationwhichhasredundanton-screentext. Learnersmay tryto compare the differentformats. Special Situationsforthe RedundancyPrinciple There are a fewspecial situationswhereusingredundanttextisacceptable andevensuggested. There isa complete absence of anyonscreenpictorial information. There has enoughtime toprocessthe pictorial presentation. The relatedaudiomightbe difficultforthe learnertounderstand--aswithforeignlanguagelearning or certainauditorylearningdisabilities.The visual textwill be helpful forlearnerstounderstand. StudiesthatSupportthe RedundancyPrinciple A varietyof studiessupportthe redundancyprinciple.Kalyuga,Chandler&Sweller(2004) suggested that a workingmemoryloadwill be generatedif learnersare requiredtocoordinate redundant materials.SoonFook,&Aldalalah(2010) investigatedthe effectsof instructional the redundancy principlesonthe learningof musictheoryamongprimarypupils.AnAI(audioandimage) mode is more effectivelythanthe TI (textwithimage) andAIT(audiowithimage andtext) modes. Critique of the RedundancyPrinciple
  • 2. The redundancytheorymayworkfor certaincases,but itmay not applytoall.More researchis neededtodetermine the situationsinwhichthe redundancyprinciple doesnothold(Clark&Mayer, 2011). Sorden(2005) discussedthatdependingonthe learners’experiences,peoplemayfeel differentaboutredundantinformationvaries.A diagramwithtextmaybe helpbeginnerto understand.Atthe same time,the same strategymightbecome redundantfora more experienced learner. References Hoffman,B.(2006). The Encyclopediaof Educational Technology.SanDiego,CA:MontezumaPress Clark,R. C.,& Mayer,R. E. (2011). E-Learningandthe Science of Instruction:ProvenGuidelinesfor ConsumersandDesignersof MultimediaLearning(3rded.).SanFrancisco,CA:JohnWiley& Sons. Kalyuga,S.,Chandler,P.,&Sweller,J.(2004).WhenRedundantOn-ScreenTextinMultimedia Technical InstructionCanInterfere WithLearning.HumanFactors,46(3), 567-581. SoonFook,F., & Aldalalah,O.(2010).Effectsof Computer-basedInstructionalDesignsamong Internals-Externals:A Cognitive LoadPerspective.EuropeanJournal of Social Science,14(12),164- 182. SordenS.D. (2005). A cognitive approachtoinstructional designformultimedialearning. InformationScience Journal, 8(1), 263-279.