Neurobiology of resilience
A role for epigenetics in
linking psychological and biological aspects?
Bart P.F. Rutten, M.D. PhD., July 2nd, 2014
Maastricht University Medical Centre, Maastricht, the Netherlands
Content
• Resilience
• Genetic moderation of sensitivity to stress by
DNMT3a
• DNMT3a and neuroplasticity
• DNMT3a and (un)susceptibility to severe chronic
stress
• Conclusions
trauma
Well being
Psychopathology
time
trauma
Well being
Psychopathology
time
A
B
MODEL OF RESILIENCE
TRAJECTORIES OF RISK & RESILIENCE
Rutten et al. Acta Psych. Scan, 2014
Integrating Nurture and Nature
Van Os, Kenis, Rutten. Nature 2010
DNA
RNA
Protein
promoter exon 1 exon 2
SNP/mutation
quantity quality
Cell functions
gene
GTCATTAAACAGGT
GTCATTACACAGGT
Genes related to (un)susceptibility to stress
Wu, Feder, et al. Front Behav Neurosci 2013
Epigenetics & the environment
ENVIRONMENT
changes in phenotype and/or gene expression by
mechanisms other than changes in the DNA sequence
itself
Maternal care during early life has persistent influence on later-life behaviour
and molecules in the stress-system via the epigenetic mechanism of DNA methylation
(team of Michael Meaney and others)
I. blocks transcription factors
DNA Methylation ↓Gene Transcription
promoter exon 1 exon 2
quantity
gene
methyl
DNA methylation is performed by DNA
methyltransferases
promoter exon 1 exon 2
gene
methyl
DNMT1
DNMT3a
DNMT3b
We determined the genetic variability in these genes
29 genetic variant in genes of DNMT1, DNMT3a and DNMT3b
Pishva et al. PlosOne 2014
Stress sensitivity
= increases in
negative affect
after unpleasant
activities or events
Daily Life Stress Sensitivity
event
High stress sensitivity
Low stress sensitivity
eventeventevent
Pishva et al. PlosOne 2014
 10 times a day
 6 consecutive days
 at random moments
multiple assessments
real world, no lab
in the moment, not retrospective
Evaluation of the context
The Experience Sampling Method (ESM)
Stress sensitivity and DNMT3a genotype
a multistep replication study
Pishva et al. PlosOne 2014
Cohort 1 Cohort 2 Cohort 3
However, no influence of the genetic variants on reward experience,
i.e. the experience of positive affect after pleasant stimuli
Psychotic reactivity
= increases in
paranoid ideations
after socially
unpleasant events
High psychotic reactivity
Low psychotic reactivity
social
event
Pishva et al. PlosOne 2014
social
event
social
event
social
event
Gene SNP Sample I
(healthy)
Sample II
(twins)
Sample III
(Patients)
Sample IV
(Siblings)
Sample V
(Depress.)
Dnmt3a rs13401241 p=0.0000 p=0.0373 - p=0.0010 -
Expression of DNMT3a
in the mouse brain
1) subgranular zone dentate gyrus of the hippocampus
DNMT3a protein
Distinct cells are highly immunoreactive, these cells are found in:
2) subventricular zone
3) olfactory bulb
4) rostral migratory stream
Hammels et al. in review
GFAP DCX
Nestin, Ki-67 NeuN
DNMT3a involved in neurogenesis?
Establishment of methylation patterns?
High levels of DNMT3a
in newborn neurons
GFAP DCX
Nestin, Ki-67 NeuN
Dnmt3a DCXDnmt3a NeuNDnmt3a GFAP
** p<0.01; (*) p=0.05
control susceptible resilient
0
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
**
celldensity(cells/mm3)
(*)
Hammels et al. under review
(same genetic background in all mice)
Mice unsusceptible to severe stress
have more cells with high levels of DNMT3a
Conclusions
• Deep phenotyping with experience sampling
methodology allows for
– studying dynamics in positive and negative affect
– dissection of genetic influences on emotional reactivity in
daily life
• A gene involved in DNA methylation (i.e. DNMT3a)
moderates stress-sensitivity
• DNMT3a is highly expressed in newborn neurons in
the adult brain (at least in mice)
• Thus, DNA methylation seems to be relevant for
active adaptation to stressors
Many thanks for your attention
Acknowledgments

More Related Content

PDF
Varney_2015
PPTX
Seminario Biologia Molecular Pedro Sánchez
PPTX
"Bioluminescent Imaging of Histidyl-Transfer RNA Synthetase-Induced Myositis ...
PDF
Published copy~9740402
PPTX
A stop codon mutation in scn9a causes lack of pain sensation
PDF
HyperoxiaPaper
PPTX
Presentation1 (1)
PPTX
The Biology of Mental Illness
Varney_2015
Seminario Biologia Molecular Pedro Sánchez
"Bioluminescent Imaging of Histidyl-Transfer RNA Synthetase-Induced Myositis ...
Published copy~9740402
A stop codon mutation in scn9a causes lack of pain sensation
HyperoxiaPaper
Presentation1 (1)
The Biology of Mental Illness

Viewers also liked (7)

PDF
Meijer ps11
PDF
Knoop keynote 3 juli
PDF
Kibe is8
PDF
Rao s19
PDF
Rao ps24
PDF
Kibe ps20
PDF
Owad w3
Meijer ps11
Knoop keynote 3 juli
Kibe is8
Rao s19
Rao ps24
Kibe ps20
Owad w3
Ad

Similar to Rutten is3 (20)

PPTX
Schizophrenia~Ketamine~Pterostilbene
PPTX
Zwiegers Thesis Defense
PDF
Neuroscience Letters
PDF
Association study of the GSK-3B gene with tardive dyskinesia in European Cauc...
PPTX
UTSpeaks: Raising babies (1 - Professor Maralyn Foureur)
PDF
Psicolpgia experiemental, como ciencia..
PDF
Hoisington be and mh healthy buildings 2017
PDF
The central nervous system and the gut microbiome
PPTX
Biomol presentacion 1
PPTX
Postherpetic Neuralgia.pptx
PPTX
Copy of Cellular Morphology for biotech engineering
PPTX
Treatment Chronic Pain [Autosaved].pptx
PPTX
Translational Neuroscience Approach in psychiatry..pptx
PDF
cronier 2007
PPTX
New Developments in the Treatment of Mood Disorders
PDF
Mc intosh 2003
PDF
SLC6A4 COMT and Deregulation of the Prefrontal -10-6-15-36x30
PPT
Schizophrenia
PDF
HCSPHARMA Importance of microenvironment in cerebral in vitro models for phen...
PPTX
Morningstar_DOI_Poster
Schizophrenia~Ketamine~Pterostilbene
Zwiegers Thesis Defense
Neuroscience Letters
Association study of the GSK-3B gene with tardive dyskinesia in European Cauc...
UTSpeaks: Raising babies (1 - Professor Maralyn Foureur)
Psicolpgia experiemental, como ciencia..
Hoisington be and mh healthy buildings 2017
The central nervous system and the gut microbiome
Biomol presentacion 1
Postherpetic Neuralgia.pptx
Copy of Cellular Morphology for biotech engineering
Treatment Chronic Pain [Autosaved].pptx
Translational Neuroscience Approach in psychiatry..pptx
cronier 2007
New Developments in the Treatment of Mood Disorders
Mc intosh 2003
SLC6A4 COMT and Deregulation of the Prefrontal -10-6-15-36x30
Schizophrenia
HCSPHARMA Importance of microenvironment in cerebral in vitro models for phen...
Morningstar_DOI_Poster
Ad

More from ECPP2014 (20)

PDF
C lea conf pres s4
PDF
Weiting ng s8
PDF
Gruner PS17
PDF
Boerefijn w9
PDF
Donaldson s19
PDF
Alastair arnott w6
PDF
Rademacher w2
PDF
Rademacher w2 follow up
PDF
Bolier et al is1
PDF
Worth w10
PDF
Walker s28
PDF
Von richter ps8
PDF
Toepfer ps1
PDF
Stewart is2
PDF
Saccaggi ps25
PDF
Roos ps7
PDF
Rombs soroczan ps22
PDF
Roffey & palmer w22
PDF
PDF
Plavsic ps34
C lea conf pres s4
Weiting ng s8
Gruner PS17
Boerefijn w9
Donaldson s19
Alastair arnott w6
Rademacher w2
Rademacher w2 follow up
Bolier et al is1
Worth w10
Walker s28
Von richter ps8
Toepfer ps1
Stewart is2
Saccaggi ps25
Roos ps7
Rombs soroczan ps22
Roffey & palmer w22
Plavsic ps34

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
3RD-Q 2022_EMPLOYEE RELATION - Copy.pptx
PPTX
Lesson-7-Gas. -Exchange_074636.pptx
PPTX
Phylogeny and disease transmission of Dipteran Fly (ppt).pptx
PPTX
CASEWORK Power Point Presentation - pointers
PDF
5_tips_to_become_a_Presentation_Jedi_@itseugenec.pdf
PPTX
HOW TO HANDLE THE STAGE FOR ACADEMIA AND OTHERS.pptx
PPTX
Research Process - Research Methods course
PPTX
2025-08-17 Joseph 03 (shared slides).pptx
PPTX
INDIGENOUS-LANGUAGES-AND-LITERATURE.pptx
PPT
Lessons from Presentation Zen_ how to craft your story visually
PDF
_Nature and dynamics of communities and community development .pdf
PDF
Microsoft-365-Administrator-s-Guide_.pdf
PPTX
CAPE CARIBBEAN STUDIES- Integration-1.pptx
PDF
6.-propertise of noble gases, uses and isolation in noble gases
PPTX
Copy- of-Lesson-6-Digestive-System.pptx
PDF
Yusen Logistics Group Sustainability Report 2024.pdf
PPTX
power point presentation ofDracena species.pptx
PPTX
Knowledge Knockout ( General Knowledge Quiz )
PDF
MODULE 3 BASIC SECURITY DUTIES AND ROLES.pdf
PDF
Module 7 guard mounting of security pers
3RD-Q 2022_EMPLOYEE RELATION - Copy.pptx
Lesson-7-Gas. -Exchange_074636.pptx
Phylogeny and disease transmission of Dipteran Fly (ppt).pptx
CASEWORK Power Point Presentation - pointers
5_tips_to_become_a_Presentation_Jedi_@itseugenec.pdf
HOW TO HANDLE THE STAGE FOR ACADEMIA AND OTHERS.pptx
Research Process - Research Methods course
2025-08-17 Joseph 03 (shared slides).pptx
INDIGENOUS-LANGUAGES-AND-LITERATURE.pptx
Lessons from Presentation Zen_ how to craft your story visually
_Nature and dynamics of communities and community development .pdf
Microsoft-365-Administrator-s-Guide_.pdf
CAPE CARIBBEAN STUDIES- Integration-1.pptx
6.-propertise of noble gases, uses and isolation in noble gases
Copy- of-Lesson-6-Digestive-System.pptx
Yusen Logistics Group Sustainability Report 2024.pdf
power point presentation ofDracena species.pptx
Knowledge Knockout ( General Knowledge Quiz )
MODULE 3 BASIC SECURITY DUTIES AND ROLES.pdf
Module 7 guard mounting of security pers

Rutten is3

  • 1. Neurobiology of resilience A role for epigenetics in linking psychological and biological aspects? Bart P.F. Rutten, M.D. PhD., July 2nd, 2014 Maastricht University Medical Centre, Maastricht, the Netherlands
  • 2. Content • Resilience • Genetic moderation of sensitivity to stress by DNMT3a • DNMT3a and neuroplasticity • DNMT3a and (un)susceptibility to severe chronic stress • Conclusions
  • 3. trauma Well being Psychopathology time trauma Well being Psychopathology time A B MODEL OF RESILIENCE TRAJECTORIES OF RISK & RESILIENCE Rutten et al. Acta Psych. Scan, 2014
  • 4. Integrating Nurture and Nature Van Os, Kenis, Rutten. Nature 2010
  • 5. DNA RNA Protein promoter exon 1 exon 2 SNP/mutation quantity quality Cell functions gene GTCATTAAACAGGT GTCATTACACAGGT
  • 6. Genes related to (un)susceptibility to stress Wu, Feder, et al. Front Behav Neurosci 2013
  • 7. Epigenetics & the environment ENVIRONMENT changes in phenotype and/or gene expression by mechanisms other than changes in the DNA sequence itself Maternal care during early life has persistent influence on later-life behaviour and molecules in the stress-system via the epigenetic mechanism of DNA methylation (team of Michael Meaney and others)
  • 8. I. blocks transcription factors DNA Methylation ↓Gene Transcription promoter exon 1 exon 2 quantity gene methyl
  • 9. DNA methylation is performed by DNA methyltransferases promoter exon 1 exon 2 gene methyl DNMT1 DNMT3a DNMT3b We determined the genetic variability in these genes 29 genetic variant in genes of DNMT1, DNMT3a and DNMT3b Pishva et al. PlosOne 2014
  • 10. Stress sensitivity = increases in negative affect after unpleasant activities or events Daily Life Stress Sensitivity event High stress sensitivity Low stress sensitivity eventeventevent Pishva et al. PlosOne 2014  10 times a day  6 consecutive days  at random moments multiple assessments real world, no lab in the moment, not retrospective Evaluation of the context The Experience Sampling Method (ESM)
  • 11. Stress sensitivity and DNMT3a genotype a multistep replication study Pishva et al. PlosOne 2014 Cohort 1 Cohort 2 Cohort 3 However, no influence of the genetic variants on reward experience, i.e. the experience of positive affect after pleasant stimuli
  • 12. Psychotic reactivity = increases in paranoid ideations after socially unpleasant events High psychotic reactivity Low psychotic reactivity social event Pishva et al. PlosOne 2014 social event social event social event Gene SNP Sample I (healthy) Sample II (twins) Sample III (Patients) Sample IV (Siblings) Sample V (Depress.) Dnmt3a rs13401241 p=0.0000 p=0.0373 - p=0.0010 -
  • 13. Expression of DNMT3a in the mouse brain 1) subgranular zone dentate gyrus of the hippocampus DNMT3a protein Distinct cells are highly immunoreactive, these cells are found in: 2) subventricular zone 3) olfactory bulb 4) rostral migratory stream Hammels et al. in review
  • 14. GFAP DCX Nestin, Ki-67 NeuN DNMT3a involved in neurogenesis? Establishment of methylation patterns?
  • 15. High levels of DNMT3a in newborn neurons GFAP DCX Nestin, Ki-67 NeuN Dnmt3a DCXDnmt3a NeuNDnmt3a GFAP
  • 16. ** p<0.01; (*) p=0.05 control susceptible resilient 0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 ** celldensity(cells/mm3) (*) Hammels et al. under review (same genetic background in all mice) Mice unsusceptible to severe stress have more cells with high levels of DNMT3a
  • 17. Conclusions • Deep phenotyping with experience sampling methodology allows for – studying dynamics in positive and negative affect – dissection of genetic influences on emotional reactivity in daily life • A gene involved in DNA methylation (i.e. DNMT3a) moderates stress-sensitivity • DNMT3a is highly expressed in newborn neurons in the adult brain (at least in mice) • Thus, DNA methylation seems to be relevant for active adaptation to stressors
  • 18. Many thanks for your attention