SharePoint Folders vs. Metadata

sharepointmaven.com @gregoryzelfond
SHAREPOINT
FOLDERS vs. METADATA
GREGORY ZELFOND

sharepointmaven.com @gregoryzelfondsharepointmaven.com @gregoryzelfond
About Me
 Gregory Zelfond
 10+ years of experience with SharePoint
 SharePoint advocate, blogger
 Love to solve business problems using code-free, out of
the box SharePoint configurations
 Owner of SharePoint Maven (sharepointmaven.com)

About SharePoint Maven
I HELP ORGANIZATIONS TO UNLOCK
THE POWER OF SHAREPOINT
MIGRATION CONSULTING TRAINING

What’s wrong with folders?
1. Usability (finding files)
2. URL Length limitation
3. File URL & Sharing
4. Security
5. File duplication
6. 1 lonely view
7. No filtering/sorting/grouping
8. Change is hard
9. Lost documents
10. No breadcrumb
11. 5,000 item limit threshold
12. Cost
13. Empty folders
14. Data Integrity

Reason # 1: Usability
 Can you (easily) make sense of
this folder structure?
 Would you be able to find the
document easily?
 Every person has their own
“mental” map on how to
organize files & documents

Reason # 2: URL Length limitation
https://company.sharepoint.com/SharedDocuments/
Clients/Projects/Year/Agenda.docx
Folder Folder Folder File
The total length of URL (server name +
list name + all folders + file name)
cannot exceed 256 characters!
Server List

Reason # 3: File URL
 Moving file from one folder to another means
change of file URL!
 Example:
OLD: https://company.sharepoint.com/SharedDocuments/Clients/Projects/Year/Agenda.docx
NEW: https://company.sharepoint.com/SharedDocuments/Clients/Projects/Agenda.docx
 Did you share the file with someone by
sending URL to the file?
– When you move file from one folder to another, “old”
URL is no longer relevant…

Reason # 4: Security
 Managing security at a folder level is an
administrative nightmare!
 20 folders in a library = 20 different security
configurations!!!
 Also, each time you break the security
inheritance from site/document library, your
SharePoint performance is impacted!

Reason # 5: File Duplication
 Each folder can contain 1
“unique” file name
 That means same file can be in
multiple folders in same
document library
 Which one is the right
document?
 No single source of truth…

Reason # 6: 1 lonely view
With folders, not much choice
for viewing files…

Reason # 7: No filtering, sorting or grouping
…In contrast to metadata, where
you can group, sort & filter

Reason # 8: Change is hard!
 Changing set folder structures is hard
 They just become deeper and wider with time
 “Restructuring” folders is a challenge and is
rarely done anyway
 Metadata allows for quick and easy change

Reason # 9: Lost documents
 With folders, documents
can easily become “lost” in
nested folder hierarchy
 This leads to frustration for
users and unnecessary file
duplication

Reason # 10: No breadcrumb
 Can you tell which
library or folder I am
in?
 There is no way for
users to know current
folder hierarchy
 Limited breadcrumb
for navigation (does
not show full path)

Reason # 11: 5000 item limit threshold
 View cannot contain more than 5,000 items (folders + files)
 Displaying a folder with > 5,000 files will cause issues
 Metadata and indexing resolve the issue
 To learn more, read this blog post: http://sharepointmaven.com/how-
to-overcome-sharepoint-5000-item-limit-threshold/

Reason # 12: Cost
 If you use folders in SharePoint, you
essentially converted SharePoint into an
expensive file share or DropBox
– “We have always done it this way” mentality
– You might be better off going back to file share

Reason # 13: Empty Folders
 Can you tell which folders contain files and
which are empty? With folders, you can’t
 Metadata allows you to see how many files
belong to certain metadata property (in
parenthesis, when you group)
 Better user experience!

Reason # 14: Data Integrity
 What’s the difference between 2 folders?
– Client A
– Client A, Inc.?
 If you rely on folder name to carry important
piece of information (i.e. company name), you
are prone to data integrity issues
 Possible issues
– Folder names can be misspelled
– No single naming convention
– You have to recreate same names somewhere else

Should I never use folders in SharePoint?
 Folders are great for:
– Small teams
– Informal file organization
– Short projects
 Metadata is great for:
– Larger teams
– When documents need to be shared with lots of people
– When there are a lot of content contributors (users who
generate/upload files) and consumers (users who
find/access files)
– Any time you need to easily find documents

Need help with SharePoint?
 SharePoint Site Configuration and Customization
 Document Migration to SharePoint
 SharePoint Implementation Strategy
 SharePoint Training
 SharePoint User Adoption
 SharePoint Governance
 SharePoint Project Management

THANK YOU!
Visit: sharepointmaven.com
Email: greg@sharepointmaven.com
Follow: @gregoryzelfond
Connect: linkedin.com/company/sharepoint-maven
View: www.slideshare.net/gzelfond
Get in touch if you have questions

SharePoint Folders vs. Metadata

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Similar to SharePoint Folders vs. Metadata (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

SharePoint Folders vs. Metadata