Abstract image of a woman sitting on books and studying on a laptop

Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac complaint pdf

L
Lyn Goering

This complaint was filed by Bellwether, Inc. against Playfish, Inc. for Playfish's unauthorized use of the phrase "FarmVille" in connection with an online game accessible on its website. Bellwether alleges that Playfish's use is likely to cause confusion regarding the affiliation or sponsorship between Bellwether and Playfish and unjustly enrich Playfish. Bellwether asserts claims of trademark infringement, unfair competition, and dilution under the Lanham Act and related Illinois state laws. The complaint seeks injunctive and monetary relief for the alleged injuries.

TechnologyBusiness
1 of 12
Download to read offline
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 1 of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
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 2 of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
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 3 of 12 2 >(#$1!%-!$!^*.7;%$!1.7:.7$'%.&!?%'B!%'-!:7%&1%:$#!:#$1*!.(!QD-%&*--!%&!8.#D9QD-/!^*.7;%$2!! 0>77E=9D9C:FD!1,&!',"F#!G",H!0)+G!58AI! !W2 )*##+,%-%.&!17*$'*-!$&=!=*,*#.:-!.7%;%&$#!%&'*7$1'%,*!$&=!&.&"%&'*7$1'%,*!*_:*7%*&1*-2! G&*!.(!)*##+,%-%.&C-!1.7*!:7.=D1'-!%-!$!;$9*!'B$'!%'!-*##-!D&=*7!'B*!9$7N!FGH!<GICA!JIGK! )>8J2!AB*!;$9*/!(%7-'!7*#*$-*=!%&!!O/!*&'$%#-!:#$+*7-!$&-?*7%&;!BD9.7.D-!9D#'%:#*"1B.%1*! `D*-'%.&-2! !!2 )*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*!B$-!*&S.+*=!*&.79.D-!1.99*71%$#!$&=! 17%'%1$#!-D11*--2!AB*!;$9*!1$&!Q*!:#$+*=!.&!1.9:D'*7-/!%&!*%'B*7!8<"aGb!.7!.&#%&*!(.79$'/!$-! ?*##!$-!.&!'B*!M.&+!"#$+M'$'%.&!-+-'*92!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*!B$-!?.&! 9.7*!'B$&!OW!$?$7=-!(7.9!'B*!%&'*7$1'%,*!%&=D-'7+2!M%&1*!!O/!.,*7!O!9%##%.&!D&%'-!.(!FGH! <GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*-!B$,*!Q**&!-.#=2!0&!'B*!-D99*7!.(!PWW!/!'B*!>c8!'*#*,%-%.&!&*'?.7N! :7*9%*7*=!$!:7%9*"'%9*!'*#*,%-%.&!-B.?!,*7-%.&!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J/!D&=*7!#%1*&-*!(7.9! )*##+,%-%.&2! !P2 AB*!:B7$-*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!%-!D-*=!%&!'B*!;$9*!%'-*#(/!.&!'B*!:$1N$;%&;!.(!'B*! ;$9*/!$&=!%&!$=,*7'%-*9*&'-!(.7!'B*!;$9*2!M%&1*!'B*!%&1*:'%.&!.(!'B*!:7.=D1'!#%&*/!'B*!FGH! <GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!B$-!1.&-%-'*&'#+!'$N*&!'B*!,%-D$#!(.79!.(!'B*!?.7=-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK! -%''%&;!.&!'.:!.(!'B*!?.7N!)>8J/!?B%1B!%-!'?.!'.!'B7**!'%9*-!$-!'$##/!$&=!*`D$##+!$-!?%=*/!$-!FGH! <GICA!JIGKd!'BD-@! ! R!
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 4 of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
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 5 of 12 !O2 AB7.D;B!%'-!*_:*&=%'D7*!.(!-DQ-'$&'%$#!'%9*/!7*-.D71*-/!$&=!*((.7'!%&!1.&'%&D.D-#+!D-%&;! $&=!:7.9.'%&;!'B*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!;$9*-/!)*##+,%-%.&!B$-! 17*$'*=!-DQ-'$&'%$#!7*1.;&%'%.&/!;..=?%##/!$&=!-*1.&=$7+!9*$&%&;/!$&=!B$-!$1`D%7*=!-%;&%(%1$&'! %&'*##*1'D$#!:7.:*7'+!7%;B'-/!%&!%'-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!$-!D-*=!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B! ;$9*-2! !X2 AB*!HM!"$'*&'!$&=!A7$=*9$7N!G((%1*!B$-!$?$7=*=!'.!)*##+,%-%.&!HM!A7$=*9$7N! a*;%-'7$'%.&!I.2!P/WPZ/RPR!(.7!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!(.7!D-*!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!1.9:D'*7! ;$9*!:7.;7$9-!7*1.7=*=!.&!8<"aGbM!3#!!!e_B%Q%'!>62! !Z2 AB*!a*;%-'7$'%.&!%-!%&1.&'*-'$Q#*!:D7-D$&'!'.!M*1'%.&!!O!.(!'B*!U$&B$9!>1'!3!O!H2M282! V!WXO62!>-!$!7*-D#'/!'B*!9$7N!%-!,$#%=/!'B*!a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`D$1N21.92!AB*!B.9*!:$;*!.(!'B$'!-%'*!-B.?-!'B*!(.##.?%&;@! O!
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 6 of 12 ! 3AB*!-$9*!-17**&!-B.?-!D:!$'!$&.'B*7!>(#$1!-%'*/!???2;*'`D$1N21.926!]7.9!'B*7*/!.&*!%-! :7*-*&'*=!?%'B!$!-*7%*-!.(!'B7**!`D*-'%.&-!?%'B!9D#'%:#*!1B.%1*!7*-:.&-*-!$,$%#$Q#*!'.!'B*! :#$+*7!.(!'B*!;$9*2! !2 >(#$1C-!:7.9.'%.&!.(!%'-!;$9*!%-!$#-.!$11*--%Q#*!'B7.D;B!'B%7=!:$7'%*-C!?*Q!-%'*-/! %&1#D=%&;!3$9.&;!.'B*7-6!-D1B!B*$,%#+"'7$((%1N*=!-%'*-!$-!'B.-*!.:*7$'*=!Q+!'B*!I*?!F.7N!A%9*-! $&=!8II2!>!-17**&!-B.'!(7.9!'B*!I*?!F.7N!A%9*-C!B.9*!:$;*/!$-!$11*--*=!.&!)$&D$7+!!W/!PW!W/! %-!$''$1B*=!$'!e_B%Q%'!c2! PW2 AB*!?.7=-!D-*=!Q+!>(#$1!=%((*7!(7.9!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!.&#+!Q+! 'B*!-DQ-'%'D'%.&!.(!'B*!#*''*7!4`5!(.7!'B*!#*''*7-!4S$52!AB*!-DQ-'%'D'%.&!:7.=D1*-!'B*!?.7=! 4`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
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 7 of 12 PR2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(/!$&=!$''*9:'!'.!7*;%-'*7/!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!(.7!$! ;$9*!$7*!?%##(D#!$&=!%&'*&'%.&$#!$1'-!$&=!$7*!%&'*&=*=!'.!'7$=*!.&!'B*!7*:D'$'%.&!$&=!;..=?%##! .(!)*##+,%-%.&/!'.!1.&(D-*!$&=!=*1*%,*!1.&-D9*7-/!$&=!'.!D&($%7#+!1.9:*'*!?%'B!)*##+,%-%.&2! PT2 !G&!%&(.79$'%.&!$&=!Q*#%*(/!Q*(.7*!>(#$1!Q*;$&!D-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!>(#$1! B$=!$1'D$#!N&.?#*=;*!.(!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!$&=f.7!a*;%-'7$'%.&2! PO2 M%&1*!>(#$1!Q*;$&!D-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!QD'!Q*(.7*!)$&D$7+!P!/!PW!W/!>(#$1! B$=!$1'D$#!N&.?#*=;*!.(!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!$&=f.7!a*;%-'7$'%.&2! PX2 c*(.7*!>(#$1!Q*;$&!D-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!>(#$1!B$=!1.&-'7D1'%,*!&.'%1*!.(! )*##+,%-%.&C-!1#$%9!.(!.?&*7-B%:!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!(.7!1.9:D'*7!;$9*!:7.;7$9-! 7*1.7=*=!.&!8<"aGb-/!:D7-D$&'!'.!!O!H2M282!V!WZP2!! PZ2 G&!%&(.79$'%.&!$&=!Q*#%*(/!>(#$1!%-!=*#%Q*7$'*#+!$&=!?%##(D##+!D-%&;/!%&!%&'*7-'$'*! 1.99*71*/!'B*!9$7N!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!$!;$9*!%&!$&!$''*9:'!'.! '7$=*!.&!'B*!;..=?%##/!7*:D'$'%.&/!$&=!9$7N*'%&;!:.?*7!17*$'*=!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&!D&=*7!%'-!FGH! <GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N2! PY2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!=*:7%,*-!)*##+,%-%.&!.(!'B*!$Q%#%'+! '.!1.&'7.#!1.&-D9*7!:*71*:'%.&!.(!'B*!`D$#%'+!.(!;..=-!.((*7*=!D&=*7!9$7N-!'B$'!$7*!%=*&'%1$#! .7!1.&(D-%&;#+!-%9%#$7!'.!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N2!AB%-!:#$1*-!)*##+,%-%.&C-! ,$#D$Q#*!7*:D'$'%.&!$&=!;..=?%##!%&!'B*!B$&=-!.(!>(#$1/!.,*7!?B.9!)*##+,%-%.&!B$-!&.!1.&'7.#2!! P2 )*##+,%-%.&!B$-!Q**&/!%-!&.?/!$&=!?%##!Q*!%77*:$7$Q#+!B$79*=!Q+!>(#$1C-!$(.7*9*&'%.&*=! $1'-!$&=/!D&#*--!*&S.%&*=!Q+!'B*!8.D7'/!>(#$1!?%##!1.&'%&D*!'.!*&;$;*!%&!%'-!D&#$?(D#!$1'-2!AB*7*! %-!&.!$=*`D$'*!7*9*=+!$'!#$?!(.7!'B*!B$79!1$D-*=!Q+!>(#$1C-!D&#$?(D#!$1'-!$##*;*=!B*7*%&2! Z!
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 8 of 12 +,&"#!!! #A8?>M8AI!!:<A9:N>M>:;!9:!/9C78;9C:!C<! (>B;9C:!OPQR4!C<!;J>!.8:J8M!)B;2!RS!&3(3+3!TRRRUQR4! RW2 )*##+,%-%.&!%&1.7:.7$'*-!Q+!7*(*7*&1*!"$7$;7$:B-!!!'B7.D;B!P/!$Q.,*/!$-!'B.D;B!(D##+!-*'! (.7'B!B*7*%&2!! R!2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(!FGH!<GIgA!JIGK!LH>8J!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!$!;$9*!%-! #%N*#+!'.!1$D-*!1.&(D-%.&/!9%-'$N*/!$&=f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
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 9 of 12 +,&"#!!!!! /9C78;9C:!C<!;J>!!779:C9D!&:9<CAM! '>B>V;9=>!#A8?>!6A8B;9B>D!)B;2!WRS!!.+(!SRXYR"Z! RO2 )*##+,%-%.&!%&1.7:.7$'*-!Q+!7*(*7*&1*!"$7$;7$:B-!!!'B7.D;B!RT/!$Q.,*/!$-!'B.D;B!(D##+!-*'! (.7'B!B*7*%&2! RX2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!%-!#%N*#+!'.!1$D-*!1.&(D-%.&!.7! 9%-D&=*7-'$&=%&;!$-!'.!'B*!-.D71*/!-:.&-.7-B%:/!$::7.,$#/!.7!1*7'%(%1$'%.&!.(!>(#$1C-!;$9*/! $&=f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
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 10 of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f.7!%-!-:.&-.7*=!Q+/!1.&&*1'*=!?%'B/!.7!7*#$'*=!'.! )*##+,%-%.&2! ! Kheae]Gae/!)*##+,%-%.&!:7$+-@! >2! AB$'!>(#$1/!%'-!.((%1*7-/!$;*&'-/!-*7,$&'-/!*9:#.+**-!$&=!$''.7&*+-/!$&=!$##!'B.-*! %&!$1'%,*!1.&1*7'!.7!:$7'%1%:$'%.&!?%'B!'B*9!3B*7*%&$('*7!1.##*1'%,*#+!4>(#$156/!Q*! :7*#%9%&$7%#+!$&=!:*79$&*&'#+!*&S.%&*=!$&=!7*-'7$%&*=!(7.9@! !2! H-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!$-/!.7!$-!:$7'!.(/!$&+!9$7N!%&!1.&&*1'%.&! ?%'B!$!;$9*d!! ! P2! H-%&;!$&+!.'B*7!'*79!.7!:B7$-*!$-/!.7!$-!:$7'!.(/!$!9$7N!%&!1.&&*1'%.&! ?%'B!$!;$9*/!?B*7*!-D1B!D-*!%-!#%N*#+!'.!7*-D#'!%&!'B*!9%-'$N*&!Q*#%*(!'B$'! >(#$1!.7!%'-!;$9*!%-!%&!$&+!?$+!$((%#%$'*=/!1.&&*1'*=!.7!$--.1%$'*=!?%'B! )*##+,%-%.&!.7!%'-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*d!$&=! ! R2! G'B*7?%-*!D&($%7#+!1.9:*'%&;!?%'B!)*##+,%-%.&!%&!$&+!9$&&*7!?B$'-.*,*72! ! !W!
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 11 of 12 c2! AB$'!>(#$1!Q*!7*`D%7*=!'.!*_:7*--#+!$Q$&=.&!%'-!(*=*7$#!'7$=*9$7N!$::#%1$'%.&!(.7! FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!M*7%$#!I.2!ZZYWOY!/!:D7-D$&'!'.!RZ!82]2a2!VP2XY2! 82! AB$'!>(#$1!Q*!7*`D%7*=!'.!$--%;&!'.!)*##+,%-%.&!$##!.(!>(#$1C-!7%;B'/!'%'#*/!$&=!%&'*7*-'! %&!$&=!'.!'B*!=.9$%&!&$9*!???2+.D=.&'N&.?`D$1N21.92!! <2! AB$'/!:D7-D$&'!'.!!O!H2M282!V!!!Y/!>(#$1!Q*!7*`D%7*=!'.!=*#%,*7!'.!'B*!8.D7'!.7!'.! )*##+,%-%.&!(.7!=*-'7D1'%.&!$##!#$Q*#-/!:$1N$;*-/!Q7.1BD7*-/!?7$::*7-/! $=,*7'%-*9*&'-/!:7.9.'%.&-/!#*''*7B*$=/!$&=!$##!.'B*7!:B+-%1$#!9$'*7%$#-!%&!'B*! 1D-'.=+!.7!D&=*7!'B*!1.&'7.#!.(!>(#$1!Q*$7%&;!'B*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J! 9$7N/!$-!D-*=!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!$!;$9*2!AB%-!%&1#D=*-!'B*!=*#*'%.&!.(!$&+!$&=! $##!*#*1'7.&%1!=$'$/!%&(.79$'%.&/!$&=f.7!1.9:D'*7!(%#*-!Q*$7%&;!$&+!(.79!.(!'B*! FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!9$7N!%&!$&+!9$&&*7/!%&1#D=%&;!$&+!-D1B!(%#*-!.&! ?*Q-%'*-/!1.9:D'*7-/!B$7=!=7%,*-/!.7!.'B*7!-'.7$;*!9*=%$!'B$'!$7*!.:*7$'*=!Q+/! .7!D&=*7!'B*!1.&'7.#!.(/!>(#$1!$&=!%'-!$;*&'-!$&=!1.&'7$1'.7-2! e2! AB$'/!:D7-D$&'!'.!!O!H2M282!V!!!X/!>(#$1!Q*!=%7*1'*=!'.!(%#*!?%'B!'B*!8.D7'!$&=! -*7,*!D:.&!)*##+,%-%.&!?%'B%&!'B%7'+!3RW6!=$+-!$('*7!%--D$&1*!.(!$&!%&SD&1'%.&!'B$'! %&1.7:.7$'*-!'B*!$(.7*9*&'%.&*=!7*#%*(!3$-!?*##!$-!$&+!.'B*7!%&SD&1'%,*!7*#%*(6!$! 7*:.7'!%&!?7%'%&;!$&=!D&=*7!.$'B!-*''%&;!(.7'B!%&!=*'$%#!'B*!9$&&*7!$&=!(.79!%&! ?B%1B!>(#$1!B$-!1.9:#%*=!?%'B!'B*!%&SD&1'%.&2! !!!
Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 12 of 12 ! ]2! AB$'!)*##+,%-%.&!Q*!$?$7=*=!9.&*'$7+!7*#%*(!%&!$&!$9.D&'!'.!Q*!(%_*=!Q+!'B*! 8.D7'!%&!%'-!=%-17*'%.&/!%&1#D=%&;!3QD'!&.'!#%9%'*=!'.6@! !2! >##!:7.(%'-!7*1*%,*=!Q+!>(#$1!$-!$!7*-D#'!.(!%'-!D&#$?(D#!$1'%.&-/!-$%=! $9.D&'!'.!Q*!'7*Q#*=!=D*!'.!>(#$1C-!?%##(D#!9%-1.&=D1'd!$&=! ! P2! >##!=$9$;*-!-D-'$%&*=!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&!$-!$!7*-D#'!.(!>(#$1C-!D&#$?(D#!$1'-/! -$%=!$9.D&'!'.!Q*!'7*Q#*=!=D*!'.!>(#$1C-!?%##(D#!$1'%.&-d!$&=f.7! ! R2! "D&%'%,*!=$9$;*-2! ! ^2! AB$'!'B*!8.D7'!$?$7=!'.!)*##+,%-%.&!$##!7*$-.&$Q#*!$''.7&*+-C!(**-/!1.-'-!$&=! =%-QD7-*9*&'-!%&1D77*=!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&!$-!$!7*-D#'!.(!'B%-!$1'%.&2! h2! AB$'!'B*!8.D7'!7*`D%7*!>(#$1!'.!:$+!:7*SD=;9*&'!%&'*7*-'!.&!$&+!$&=!$##! 9.&*'$7+!$?$7=-!3%&!?B$'*,*7!(.796!'.!?B%1B!)*##+,%-%.&!%-!*&'%'#*=2! 02! AB$'!'B*!8.D7'!.7=*7!$##!.'B*7!$&=!(D7'B*7!7*#%*(!'B$'!%'!=**9-!:7.:*7!$&=!SD-'2! )*##+,%-%.&!=*9$&=-!$!'7%$#!Q+!SD7+!.&!$##!%--D*-!-.!'7%$Q#*2! ! <>Ae<@!!i)$&D$7+!P!/!PW!Wiiiiiii! a*-:*1'(D##+!-DQ9%''*=/! ! ! ! 0%..1/!(!,"2!!"+32!;JAC@NJ!9;D!);;CA:>ED! ! ! ! ! ! if-f!).-BD$!M2!]7%1Niiiiiiiiii! ! JD7'!)2!h%7-1B!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!XPZXPYR6! ).B&!A2!^$Q7%*#%=*-!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!X!YRPR6! )*##+,%-%.&/!0&12! "B%#%:!>2!).&*-!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!XP!ZP!R6! YTY!K!e$-'9$&!M'7**'/!MD%'*!!WT! ).-BD$!M2!]7%1N!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!XPPYTR6! 8B%1$;./!0U!XWXPP! c7%&N-!h.(*7!^%#-.&!j!U%.&*! 3R!P6!PXX"WXWX! TOO!I2!8%'+(7.&'!"#$E$!<7%,*/!MD%'*!RXWW! ! 8B%1$;./!0U!XWX!!! 3R!P6!RP!"TPWW! ! ! !P!

More Related Content

PDF
Treball espai familiar
Patrícia Rodríguez
 
PDF
Apps Market Research
Michael Fenech
 
PDF
Zegeye Junior I.S.
mitikayalew
 
PDF
FPC Seven to Save 2009
Montage Marketing
 
PDF
Intergrating OER in Educational Practice: Practitioner Stories
Shironica Karunanayaka
 
PDF
Group 5 Revised Country Profile
Sarah Iskander
 
PDF
Coaching protocols
barriedonohue
 
PDF
Pep program 04122011-1
Andrew Cannon
 
Treball espai familiar
Patrícia Rodríguez
 
Apps Market Research
Michael Fenech
 
Zegeye Junior I.S.
mitikayalew
 
FPC Seven to Save 2009
Montage Marketing
 
Intergrating OER in Educational Practice: Practitioner Stories
Shironica Karunanayaka
 
Group 5 Revised Country Profile
Sarah Iskander
 
Coaching protocols
barriedonohue
 
Pep program 04122011-1
Andrew Cannon
 

What's hot (16)

PDF
Machine Shop Flyer
P.J. Naughton
 
PDF
Articulo 416 LeCrim. La dispensa de la Obligación de Declarar.
owaj
 
PDF
Paras Holidays Europe USA Group Tours 2015 Brochure
Paras Holidays Pvt Ltd
 
PDF
Sample SEO Best Practice Guide
Noa Marcos
 
PDF
Panthers
guest430af78
 
PDF
Management Toolkit
Bernard JOUVEL
 
PDF
CompTIA - Cloud Study - Full Report
Assespro Nacional
 
PDF
Contadiniperscelta ceriani
Alberto Fatticcioni
 
PDF
Monitoring system sample thesis
MauMeow11
 
PDF
Self Optimizing transactional data grids for elastic cloud environments
EuroCloud
 
PDF
Motherloss
Mirah Riben
 
PDF
Guia de desbloqueo xperia x10
Abraham Larrondo
 
PDF
CAPSTONE FINAL PDF
Perri A. Pyle
 
PDF
אומנות הלחימה גדעון אונה
Lior Medan
 
PDF
Apostila baixo
ewsanttos
 
PDF
EDUTEC-e: "Innovando en la Educación para la empleabilidad y el desarrollo de...
Alba Santa
 
Machine Shop Flyer
P.J. Naughton
 
Articulo 416 LeCrim. La dispensa de la Obligación de Declarar.
owaj
 
Paras Holidays Europe USA Group Tours 2015 Brochure
Paras Holidays Pvt Ltd
 
Sample SEO Best Practice Guide
Noa Marcos
 
Panthers
guest430af78
 
Management Toolkit
Bernard JOUVEL
 
CompTIA - Cloud Study - Full Report
Assespro Nacional
 
Contadiniperscelta ceriani
Alberto Fatticcioni
 
Monitoring system sample thesis
MauMeow11
 
Self Optimizing transactional data grids for elastic cloud environments
EuroCloud
 
Motherloss
Mirah Riben
 
Guia de desbloqueo xperia x10
Abraham Larrondo
 
CAPSTONE FINAL PDF
Perri A. Pyle
 
אומנות הלחימה גדעון אונה
Lior Medan
 
Apostila baixo
ewsanttos
 
EDUTEC-e: "Innovando en la Educación para la empleabilidad y el desarrollo de...
Alba Santa
 
Ad

Similar to Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac complaint pdf (20)

PDF
Revista fracking
Frackingezaraba
 
PDF
NRI Report
Obama White House
 
PDF
Architecting your Splunk deployment
Splunk
 
PDF
Radio 2.0 paris conference
CreaTECH540º
 
PDF
Radio 2.0 paris conference
Elisa Escobedo
 
PDF
Informe skoool
Maria Tobon
 
PPTX
Flipped
Liz Fogarty
 
PDF
Nhd 2010-10
Pelopincho Malasanya
 
PDF
USD 1.49 billion invested in Silicon Valley mobile companies in 2008
MOMO BUENOSAIRES
 
PDF
ปัจจัยที่ทำให้ระบบโรงเรียนประสบความสำเร็จ
kunkrooyim
 
PDF
SBC Group R&D Tax Credit
sbcgroup
 
PDF
CITIA08 - Ready For Change? - Presentation
David Walker
 
KEY
Young Lions Media 2011 / SPYL509
Vane Marín
 
PDF
Investment in the Silicon Valley Mobile Industry
kateimbach
 
PDF
A combined reading of equitable and reasonable utilisation, and ecosystem ser...
IHP-HELP Centre for Water Law, Policy and Science under the auspices of UNESCO, University of Dundee
 
PDF
South Amboy to Govern Clothing Bins (The Suburban)
Jacqueline Durett
 
PDF
Lesson 7 world_history_medieval_period_new_
Anna Romana
 
PDF
Landscaping - a technique to aid understanding
STAG Software Private Limited
 
PDF
Civil beat info request
Honolulu Civil Beat
 
PDF
Portfolio
Carol A. Tiernan
 
Revista fracking
Frackingezaraba
 
NRI Report
Obama White House
 
Architecting your Splunk deployment
Splunk
 
Radio 2.0 paris conference
CreaTECH540º
 
Radio 2.0 paris conference
Elisa Escobedo
 
Informe skoool
Maria Tobon
 
Flipped
Liz Fogarty
 
Nhd 2010-10
Pelopincho Malasanya
 
USD 1.49 billion invested in Silicon Valley mobile companies in 2008
MOMO BUENOSAIRES
 
ปัจจัยที่ทำให้ระบบโรงเรียนประสบความสำเร็จ
kunkrooyim
 
SBC Group R&D Tax Credit
sbcgroup
 
CITIA08 - Ready For Change? - Presentation
David Walker
 
Young Lions Media 2011 / SPYL509
Vane Marín
 
Investment in the Silicon Valley Mobile Industry
kateimbach
 
A combined reading of equitable and reasonable utilisation, and ecosystem ser...
IHP-HELP Centre for Water Law, Policy and Science under the auspices of UNESCO, University of Dundee
 
South Amboy to Govern Clothing Bins (The Suburban)
Jacqueline Durett
 
Lesson 7 world_history_medieval_period_new_
Anna Romana
 
Landscaping - a technique to aid understanding
STAG Software Private Limited
 
Civil beat info request
Honolulu Civil Beat
 
Portfolio
Carol A. Tiernan
 
Ad

More from Lyn Goering (20)

DOC
Spring 2009 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. apollo energies (defendants)
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2009 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. apollo energies (prosecution)
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac lanham act trademar...
Lyn Goering
 
DOCX
Spring 2010 closed memo jellyvision v. aflac trademark infringement researc...
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac lanham act trademar...
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2007 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. belfast (prosecution)
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2007 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. belfast (public defender's off...
Lyn Goering
 
DOCX
Spring 2010 closed memo jellyvision v. aflac trademark infringement researc...
Lyn Goering
 
PDF
Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac complaint pdf
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac lanham act trademar...
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2007 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. belfast (public defender's off...
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2007 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. belfast (prosecutor)
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2007 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. belfast (prosecution)
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2006 appellate brief assignment west v. mercy hospital (defendant)
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2006 appellate brief assignment west v. mercy hospital (plaintiff)
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2006 appellate brief assignment west v. mercy hospital - timeline of...
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Spring 2006 appellate brief assignment west v. mercy hospital - appendix
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Fall 2006 closed memo assignment workers' comp. horseplay rule a z doc
Lyn Goering
 
DOCX
Fall 2011 closed memo no. 2 assignment cooper v. stockett appropriation of ...
Lyn Goering
 
DOC
Case brief assignment costanza v seinfeld
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2009 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. apollo energies (defendants)
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2009 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. apollo energies (prosecution)
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac lanham act trademar...
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2010 closed memo jellyvision v. aflac trademark infringement researc...
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac lanham act trademar...
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2007 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. belfast (prosecution)
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2007 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. belfast (public defender's off...
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2010 closed memo jellyvision v. aflac trademark infringement researc...
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac complaint pdf
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac lanham act trademar...
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2007 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. belfast (public defender's off...
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2007 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. belfast (prosecutor)
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2007 appellate brief assignment u.s. v. belfast (prosecution)
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2006 appellate brief assignment west v. mercy hospital (defendant)
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2006 appellate brief assignment west v. mercy hospital (plaintiff)
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2006 appellate brief assignment west v. mercy hospital - timeline of...
Lyn Goering
 
Spring 2006 appellate brief assignment west v. mercy hospital - appendix
Lyn Goering
 
Fall 2006 closed memo assignment workers' comp. horseplay rule a z doc
Lyn Goering
 
Fall 2011 closed memo no. 2 assignment cooper v. stockett appropriation of ...
Lyn Goering
 
Case brief assignment costanza v seinfeld
Lyn Goering
 

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
DASA ADMISSION 2024_FirstRound_FirstRank_LastRank.pdf
rameswartudu05
 
PPTX
Benefits of Physical activity for teenagers.pptx
Nokwanda Thabethe
 
PDF
Hybrid horned lizard optimization algorithm-aquila optimizer for DC motor
IAESIJAI
 
PDF
Univ-Connecticut-ChatGPT-Presentaion.pdf
ry7r52mzb4
 
PDF
How ambidextrous entrepreneurial leaders react to the artificial intelligence...
IAESIJAI
 
PPTX
MicrosoftCybserSecurityReferenceArchitecture-April-2025.pptx
SilvioHayashi
 
PPTX
The various Industrial Revolutions .pptx
bandileshozi3
 
PDF
Getting Started with Data Integration: FME Form 101
Safe Software
 
PPTX
Group 1 Presentation -Planning and Decision Making .pptx
MatthewLewis227954
 
PDF
sustainability-14-14877-v2.pddhzftheheeeee
VenkateshGovindaraja9
 
PDF
Transform Your ITIL® 4 & ITSM Strategy with AI in 2025.pdf
PDCA Consulting
 
PDF
August Patch Tuesday
Ivanti
 
PDF
ENT215_Completing-a-large-scale-migration-and-modernization-with-AWS.pdf
ssuser28425f
 
PPT
What is a Computer? Input Devices /output devices
GulJan8
 
PPTX
Tartificialntelligence_presentation.pptx
ry7r52mzb4
 
PPT
Module 1.ppt Iot fundamentals and Architecture
nanditha7766
 
PPTX
observCloud-Native Containerability and monitoring.pptx
anupsingh76937
 
PDF
Getting started with AI Agents and Multi-Agent Systems
Maxim Salnikov
 
PDF
1 - Historical Antecedents, Social Consideration.pdf
tuazon2030627
 
PDF
CloudStack 4.21: First Look Webinar slides
ShapeBlue
 
DASA ADMISSION 2024_FirstRound_FirstRank_LastRank.pdf
rameswartudu05
 
Benefits of Physical activity for teenagers.pptx
Nokwanda Thabethe
 
Hybrid horned lizard optimization algorithm-aquila optimizer for DC motor
IAESIJAI
 
Univ-Connecticut-ChatGPT-Presentaion.pdf
ry7r52mzb4
 
How ambidextrous entrepreneurial leaders react to the artificial intelligence...
IAESIJAI
 
MicrosoftCybserSecurityReferenceArchitecture-April-2025.pptx
SilvioHayashi
 
The various Industrial Revolutions .pptx
bandileshozi3
 
Getting Started with Data Integration: FME Form 101
Safe Software
 
Group 1 Presentation -Planning and Decision Making .pptx
MatthewLewis227954
 
sustainability-14-14877-v2.pddhzftheheeeee
VenkateshGovindaraja9
 
Transform Your ITIL® 4 & ITSM Strategy with AI in 2025.pdf
PDCA Consulting
 
August Patch Tuesday
Ivanti
 
ENT215_Completing-a-large-scale-migration-and-modernization-with-AWS.pdf
ssuser28425f
 
What is a Computer? Input Devices /output devices
GulJan8
 
Tartificialntelligence_presentation.pptx
ry7r52mzb4
 
Module 1.ppt Iot fundamentals and Architecture
nanditha7766
 
observCloud-Native Containerability and monitoring.pptx
anupsingh76937
 
Getting started with AI Agents and Multi-Agent Systems
Maxim Salnikov
 
1 - Historical Antecedents, Social Consideration.pdf
tuazon2030627
 
CloudStack 4.21: First Look Webinar slides
ShapeBlue
 

Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac complaint pdf

  • 1. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 1 of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
  • 2. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 2 of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
  • 3. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 3 of 12 2 >(#$1!%-!$!^*.7;%$!1.7:.7$'%.&!?%'B!%'-!:7%&1%:$#!:#$1*!.(!QD-%&*--!%&!8.#D9QD-/!^*.7;%$2!! 0>77E=9D9C:FD!1,&!',"F#!G",H!0)+G!58AI! !W2 )*##+,%-%.&!17*$'*-!$&=!=*,*#.:-!.7%;%&$#!%&'*7$1'%,*!$&=!&.&"%&'*7$1'%,*!*_:*7%*&1*-2! G&*!.(!)*##+,%-%.&C-!1.7*!:7.=D1'-!%-!$!;$9*!'B$'!%'!-*##-!D&=*7!'B*!9$7N!FGH!<GICA!JIGK! )>8J2!AB*!;$9*/!(%7-'!7*#*$-*=!%&!!O/!*&'$%#-!:#$+*7-!$&-?*7%&;!BD9.7.D-!9D#'%:#*"1B.%1*! `D*-'%.&-2! !!2 )*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*!B$-!*&S.+*=!*&.79.D-!1.99*71%$#!$&=! 17%'%1$#!-D11*--2!AB*!;$9*!1$&!Q*!:#$+*=!.&!1.9:D'*7-/!%&!*%'B*7!8<"aGb!.7!.&#%&*!(.79$'/!$-! ?*##!$-!.&!'B*!M.&+!"#$+M'$'%.&!-+-'*92!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*!B$-!?.&! 9.7*!'B$&!OW!$?$7=-!(7.9!'B*!%&'*7$1'%,*!%&=D-'7+2!M%&1*!!O/!.,*7!O!9%##%.&!D&%'-!.(!FGH! <GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*-!B$,*!Q**&!-.#=2!0&!'B*!-D99*7!.(!PWW!/!'B*!>c8!'*#*,%-%.&!&*'?.7N! :7*9%*7*=!$!:7%9*"'%9*!'*#*,%-%.&!-B.?!,*7-%.&!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J/!D&=*7!#%1*&-*!(7.9! )*##+,%-%.&2! !P2 AB*!:B7$-*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!%-!D-*=!%&!'B*!;$9*!%'-*#(/!.&!'B*!:$1N$;%&;!.(!'B*! ;$9*/!$&=!%&!$=,*7'%-*9*&'-!(.7!'B*!;$9*2!M%&1*!'B*!%&1*:'%.&!.(!'B*!:7.=D1'!#%&*/!'B*!FGH! <GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!B$-!1.&-%-'*&'#+!'$N*&!'B*!,%-D$#!(.79!.(!'B*!?.7=-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK! -%''%&;!.&!'.:!.(!'B*!?.7N!)>8J/!?B%1B!%-!'?.!'.!'B7**!'%9*-!$-!'$##/!$&=!*`D$##+!$-!?%=*/!$-!FGH! <GICA!JIGKd!'BD-@! ! R!
  • 4. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 4 of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
  • 5. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 5 of 12 !O2 AB7.D;B!%'-!*_:*&=%'D7*!.(!-DQ-'$&'%$#!'%9*/!7*-.D71*-/!$&=!*((.7'!%&!1.&'%&D.D-#+!D-%&;! $&=!:7.9.'%&;!'B*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!;$9*-/!)*##+,%-%.&!B$-! 17*$'*=!-DQ-'$&'%$#!7*1.;&%'%.&/!;..=?%##/!$&=!-*1.&=$7+!9*$&%&;/!$&=!B$-!$1`D%7*=!-%;&%(%1$&'! %&'*##*1'D$#!:7.:*7'+!7%;B'-/!%&!%'-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!$-!D-*=!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B! ;$9*-2! !X2 AB*!HM!"$'*&'!$&=!A7$=*9$7N!G((%1*!B$-!$?$7=*=!'.!)*##+,%-%.&!HM!A7$=*9$7N! a*;%-'7$'%.&!I.2!P/WPZ/RPR!(.7!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!(.7!D-*!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!1.9:D'*7! ;$9*!:7.;7$9-!7*1.7=*=!.&!8<"aGbM!3#!!!e_B%Q%'!>62! !Z2 AB*!a*;%-'7$'%.&!%-!%&1.&'*-'$Q#*!:D7-D$&'!'.!M*1'%.&!!O!.(!'B*!U$&B$9!>1'!3!O!H2M282! V!WXO62!>-!$!7*-D#'/!'B*!9$7N!%-!,$#%=/!'B*!a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`D$1N21.92!AB*!B.9*!:$;*!.(!'B$'!-%'*!-B.?-!'B*!(.##.?%&;@! O!
  • 6. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 6 of 12 ! 3AB*!-$9*!-17**&!-B.?-!D:!$'!$&.'B*7!>(#$1!-%'*/!???2;*'`D$1N21.926!]7.9!'B*7*/!.&*!%-! :7*-*&'*=!?%'B!$!-*7%*-!.(!'B7**!`D*-'%.&-!?%'B!9D#'%:#*!1B.%1*!7*-:.&-*-!$,$%#$Q#*!'.!'B*! :#$+*7!.(!'B*!;$9*2! !2 >(#$1C-!:7.9.'%.&!.(!%'-!;$9*!%-!$#-.!$11*--%Q#*!'B7.D;B!'B%7=!:$7'%*-C!?*Q!-%'*-/! %&1#D=%&;!3$9.&;!.'B*7-6!-D1B!B*$,%#+"'7$((%1N*=!-%'*-!$-!'B.-*!.:*7$'*=!Q+!'B*!I*?!F.7N!A%9*-! $&=!8II2!>!-17**&!-B.'!(7.9!'B*!I*?!F.7N!A%9*-C!B.9*!:$;*/!$-!$11*--*=!.&!)$&D$7+!!W/!PW!W/! %-!$''$1B*=!$'!e_B%Q%'!c2! PW2 AB*!?.7=-!D-*=!Q+!>(#$1!=%((*7!(7.9!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!.&#+!Q+! 'B*!-DQ-'%'D'%.&!.(!'B*!#*''*7!4`5!(.7!'B*!#*''*7-!4S$52!AB*!-DQ-'%'D'%.&!:7.=D1*-!'B*!?.7=! 4`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
  • 7. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 7 of 12 PR2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(/!$&=!$''*9:'!'.!7*;%-'*7/!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!(.7!$! ;$9*!$7*!?%##(D#!$&=!%&'*&'%.&$#!$1'-!$&=!$7*!%&'*&=*=!'.!'7$=*!.&!'B*!7*:D'$'%.&!$&=!;..=?%##! .(!)*##+,%-%.&/!'.!1.&(D-*!$&=!=*1*%,*!1.&-D9*7-/!$&=!'.!D&($%7#+!1.9:*'*!?%'B!)*##+,%-%.&2! PT2 !G&!%&(.79$'%.&!$&=!Q*#%*(/!Q*(.7*!>(#$1!Q*;$&!D-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!>(#$1! B$=!$1'D$#!N&.?#*=;*!.(!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!$&=f.7!a*;%-'7$'%.&2! PO2 M%&1*!>(#$1!Q*;$&!D-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!QD'!Q*(.7*!)$&D$7+!P!/!PW!W/!>(#$1! B$=!$1'D$#!N&.?#*=;*!.(!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!$&=f.7!a*;%-'7$'%.&2! PX2 c*(.7*!>(#$1!Q*;$&!D-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!>(#$1!B$=!1.&-'7D1'%,*!&.'%1*!.(! )*##+,%-%.&C-!1#$%9!.(!.?&*7-B%:!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!(.7!1.9:D'*7!;$9*!:7.;7$9-! 7*1.7=*=!.&!8<"aGb-/!:D7-D$&'!'.!!O!H2M282!V!WZP2!! PZ2 G&!%&(.79$'%.&!$&=!Q*#%*(/!>(#$1!%-!=*#%Q*7$'*#+!$&=!?%##(D##+!D-%&;/!%&!%&'*7-'$'*! 1.99*71*/!'B*!9$7N!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!$!;$9*!%&!$&!$''*9:'!'.! '7$=*!.&!'B*!;..=?%##/!7*:D'$'%.&/!$&=!9$7N*'%&;!:.?*7!17*$'*=!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&!D&=*7!%'-!FGH! <GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N2! PY2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!=*:7%,*-!)*##+,%-%.&!.(!'B*!$Q%#%'+! '.!1.&'7.#!1.&-D9*7!:*71*:'%.&!.(!'B*!`D$#%'+!.(!;..=-!.((*7*=!D&=*7!9$7N-!'B$'!$7*!%=*&'%1$#! .7!1.&(D-%&;#+!-%9%#$7!'.!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N2!AB%-!:#$1*-!)*##+,%-%.&C-! ,$#D$Q#*!7*:D'$'%.&!$&=!;..=?%##!%&!'B*!B$&=-!.(!>(#$1/!.,*7!?B.9!)*##+,%-%.&!B$-!&.!1.&'7.#2!! P2 )*##+,%-%.&!B$-!Q**&/!%-!&.?/!$&=!?%##!Q*!%77*:$7$Q#+!B$79*=!Q+!>(#$1C-!$(.7*9*&'%.&*=! $1'-!$&=/!D&#*--!*&S.%&*=!Q+!'B*!8.D7'/!>(#$1!?%##!1.&'%&D*!'.!*&;$;*!%&!%'-!D&#$?(D#!$1'-2!AB*7*! %-!&.!$=*`D$'*!7*9*=+!$'!#$?!(.7!'B*!B$79!1$D-*=!Q+!>(#$1C-!D&#$?(D#!$1'-!$##*;*=!B*7*%&2! Z!
  • 8. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 8 of 12 +,&"#!!! #A8?>M8AI!!:<A9:N>M>:;!9:!/9C78;9C:!C<! (>B;9C:!OPQR4!C<!;J>!.8:J8M!)B;2!RS!&3(3+3!TRRRUQR4! RW2 )*##+,%-%.&!%&1.7:.7$'*-!Q+!7*(*7*&1*!"$7$;7$:B-!!!'B7.D;B!P/!$Q.,*/!$-!'B.D;B!(D##+!-*'! (.7'B!B*7*%&2!! R!2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(!FGH!<GIgA!JIGK!LH>8J!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!$!;$9*!%-! #%N*#+!'.!1$D-*!1.&(D-%.&/!9%-'$N*/!$&=f.7!=*1*:'%.&2!! RP2 AB*!$(.7*9*&'%.&*=!$1'-!.(!>(#$1!1.&-'%'D'*!%&(7%&;*9*&'!.(!$!(*=*7$##+!7*;%-'*7*=!9$7N/! %&!,%.#$'%.&!.(!!O!H2M282!V!!!T2!! +,&"#!!!! &:<89A!+CMV>;9;9C:!9:!/9C78;9C:!C<! (>B;9C:!UOQ84!C<!;J>!.8:J8M!)B;2!RS!&3(3+3!TRRPSQ84! RR2 )*##+,%-%.&!%&1.7:.7$'*-!Q+!7*(*7*&1*!"$7$;7$:B-!!!'B7.D;B!RP/!$Q.,*/!$-!'B.D;B!(D##+!-*'! (.7'B!B*7*%&2! RT2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!%&!1.99*71*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!1.&-'%'D'*-!$!($#-*! =*-%;&$'%.&!.(!.7%;%&!'B$'!%-!#%N*#+!'.!1$D-*!1.&(D-%.&/!9%-'$N*/!.7!=*1*:'%.&!$-!'.!'B*!$((%#%$'%.&/! 1.&&*1'%.&/!.7!$--.1%$'%.&!Q*'?**&!>(#$1!$&=!)*##+,%-%.&/!.7!$-!'.!'B*!.7%;%&/!-:.&-.7-B%:/!.7! $::7.,$#!.(!>(#$1C-!;$9*!.7!1.99*71%$#!$1'%,%'%*-!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&/!%&!,%.#$'%.&!.(!M*1'%.&!TR3$6!.(! 'B*!U$&B$9!>1'/!!O!H2M282!V!!PO3$62! Y!
  • 9. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 9 of 12 +,&"#!!!!! /9C78;9C:!C<!;J>!!779:C9D!&:9<CAM! '>B>V;9=>!#A8?>!6A8B;9B>D!)B;2!WRS!!.+(!SRXYR"Z! RO2 )*##+,%-%.&!%&1.7:.7$'*-!Q+!7*(*7*&1*!"$7$;7$:B-!!!'B7.D;B!RT/!$Q.,*/!$-!'B.D;B!(D##+!-*'! (.7'B!B*7*%&2! RX2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!%-!#%N*#+!'.!1$D-*!1.&(D-%.&!.7! 9%-D&=*7-'$&=%&;!$-!'.!'B*!-.D71*/!-:.&-.7-B%:/!$::7.,$#/!.7!1*7'%(%1$'%.&!.(!>(#$1C-!;$9*/! $&=f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
  • 10. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 10 of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f.7!%-!-:.&-.7*=!Q+/!1.&&*1'*=!?%'B/!.7!7*#$'*=!'.! )*##+,%-%.&2! ! Kheae]Gae/!)*##+,%-%.&!:7$+-@! >2! AB$'!>(#$1/!%'-!.((%1*7-/!$;*&'-/!-*7,$&'-/!*9:#.+**-!$&=!$''.7&*+-/!$&=!$##!'B.-*! %&!$1'%,*!1.&1*7'!.7!:$7'%1%:$'%.&!?%'B!'B*9!3B*7*%&$('*7!1.##*1'%,*#+!4>(#$156/!Q*! :7*#%9%&$7%#+!$&=!:*79$&*&'#+!*&S.%&*=!$&=!7*-'7$%&*=!(7.9@! !2! H-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!$-/!.7!$-!:$7'!.(/!$&+!9$7N!%&!1.&&*1'%.&! ?%'B!$!;$9*d!! ! P2! H-%&;!$&+!.'B*7!'*79!.7!:B7$-*!$-/!.7!$-!:$7'!.(/!$!9$7N!%&!1.&&*1'%.&! ?%'B!$!;$9*/!?B*7*!-D1B!D-*!%-!#%N*#+!'.!7*-D#'!%&!'B*!9%-'$N*&!Q*#%*(!'B$'! >(#$1!.7!%'-!;$9*!%-!%&!$&+!?$+!$((%#%$'*=/!1.&&*1'*=!.7!$--.1%$'*=!?%'B! )*##+,%-%.&!.7!%'-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*d!$&=! ! R2! G'B*7?%-*!D&($%7#+!1.9:*'%&;!?%'B!)*##+,%-%.&!%&!$&+!9$&&*7!?B$'-.*,*72! ! !W!
  • 11. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 11 of 12 c2! AB$'!>(#$1!Q*!7*`D%7*=!'.!*_:7*--#+!$Q$&=.&!%'-!(*=*7$#!'7$=*9$7N!$::#%1$'%.&!(.7! FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!M*7%$#!I.2!ZZYWOY!/!:D7-D$&'!'.!RZ!82]2a2!VP2XY2! 82! AB$'!>(#$1!Q*!7*`D%7*=!'.!$--%;&!'.!)*##+,%-%.&!$##!.(!>(#$1C-!7%;B'/!'%'#*/!$&=!%&'*7*-'! %&!$&=!'.!'B*!=.9$%&!&$9*!???2+.D=.&'N&.?`D$1N21.92!! <2! AB$'/!:D7-D$&'!'.!!O!H2M282!V!!!Y/!>(#$1!Q*!7*`D%7*=!'.!=*#%,*7!'.!'B*!8.D7'!.7!'.! )*##+,%-%.&!(.7!=*-'7D1'%.&!$##!#$Q*#-/!:$1N$;*-/!Q7.1BD7*-/!?7$::*7-/! $=,*7'%-*9*&'-/!:7.9.'%.&-/!#*''*7B*$=/!$&=!$##!.'B*7!:B+-%1$#!9$'*7%$#-!%&!'B*! 1D-'.=+!.7!D&=*7!'B*!1.&'7.#!.(!>(#$1!Q*$7%&;!'B*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J! 9$7N/!$-!D-*=!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!$!;$9*2!AB%-!%&1#D=*-!'B*!=*#*'%.&!.(!$&+!$&=! $##!*#*1'7.&%1!=$'$/!%&(.79$'%.&/!$&=f.7!1.9:D'*7!(%#*-!Q*$7%&;!$&+!(.79!.(!'B*! FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!9$7N!%&!$&+!9$&&*7/!%&1#D=%&;!$&+!-D1B!(%#*-!.&! ?*Q-%'*-/!1.9:D'*7-/!B$7=!=7%,*-/!.7!.'B*7!-'.7$;*!9*=%$!'B$'!$7*!.:*7$'*=!Q+/! .7!D&=*7!'B*!1.&'7.#!.(/!>(#$1!$&=!%'-!$;*&'-!$&=!1.&'7$1'.7-2! e2! AB$'/!:D7-D$&'!'.!!O!H2M282!V!!!X/!>(#$1!Q*!=%7*1'*=!'.!(%#*!?%'B!'B*!8.D7'!$&=! -*7,*!D:.&!)*##+,%-%.&!?%'B%&!'B%7'+!3RW6!=$+-!$('*7!%--D$&1*!.(!$&!%&SD&1'%.&!'B$'! %&1.7:.7$'*-!'B*!$(.7*9*&'%.&*=!7*#%*(!3$-!?*##!$-!$&+!.'B*7!%&SD&1'%,*!7*#%*(6!$! 7*:.7'!%&!?7%'%&;!$&=!D&=*7!.$'B!-*''%&;!(.7'B!%&!=*'$%#!'B*!9$&&*7!$&=!(.79!%&! ?B%1B!>(#$1!B$-!1.9:#%*=!?%'B!'B*!%&SD&1'%.&2! !!!
  • 12. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 12 of 12 ! ]2! AB$'!)*##+,%-%.&!Q*!$?$7=*=!9.&*'$7+!7*#%*(!%&!$&!$9.D&'!'.!Q*!(%_*=!Q+!'B*! 8.D7'!%&!%'-!=%-17*'%.&/!%&1#D=%&;!3QD'!&.'!#%9%'*=!'.6@! !2! >##!:7.(%'-!7*1*%,*=!Q+!>(#$1!$-!$!7*-D#'!.(!%'-!D&#$?(D#!$1'%.&-/!-$%=! $9.D&'!'.!Q*!'7*Q#*=!=D*!'.!>(#$1C-!?%##(D#!9%-1.&=D1'd!$&=! ! P2! >##!=$9$;*-!-D-'$%&*=!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&!$-!$!7*-D#'!.(!>(#$1C-!D&#$?(D#!$1'-/! -$%=!$9.D&'!'.!Q*!'7*Q#*=!=D*!'.!>(#$1C-!?%##(D#!$1'%.&-d!$&=f.7! ! R2! "D&%'%,*!=$9$;*-2! ! ^2! AB$'!'B*!8.D7'!$?$7=!'.!)*##+,%-%.&!$##!7*$-.&$Q#*!$''.7&*+-C!(**-/!1.-'-!$&=! =%-QD7-*9*&'-!%&1D77*=!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&!$-!$!7*-D#'!.(!'B%-!$1'%.&2! h2! AB$'!'B*!8.D7'!7*`D%7*!>(#$1!'.!:$+!:7*SD=;9*&'!%&'*7*-'!.&!$&+!$&=!$##! 9.&*'$7+!$?$7=-!3%&!?B$'*,*7!(.796!'.!?B%1B!)*##+,%-%.&!%-!*&'%'#*=2! 02! AB$'!'B*!8.D7'!.7=*7!$##!.'B*7!$&=!(D7'B*7!7*#%*(!'B$'!%'!=**9-!:7.:*7!$&=!SD-'2! )*##+,%-%.&!=*9$&=-!$!'7%$#!Q+!SD7+!.&!$##!%--D*-!-.!'7%$Q#*2! ! <>Ae<@!!i)$&D$7+!P!/!PW!Wiiiiiii! a*-:*1'(D##+!-DQ9%''*=/! ! ! ! 0%..1/!(!,"2!!"+32!;JAC@NJ!9;D!);;CA:>ED! ! ! ! ! ! if-f!).-BD$!M2!]7%1Niiiiiiiiii! ! JD7'!)2!h%7-1B!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!XPZXPYR6! ).B&!A2!^$Q7%*#%=*-!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!X!YRPR6! )*##+,%-%.&/!0&12! "B%#%:!>2!).&*-!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!XP!ZP!R6! YTY!K!e$-'9$&!M'7**'/!MD%'*!!WT! ).-BD$!M2!]7%1N!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!XPPYTR6! 8B%1$;./!0U!XWXPP! c7%&N-!h.(*7!^%#-.&!j!U%.&*! 3R!P6!PXX"WXWX! TOO!I2!8%'+(7.&'!"#$E$!<7%,*/!MD%'*!RXWW! ! 8B%1$;./!0U!XWX!!! 3R!P6!RP!"TPWW! ! ! !P!