SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The Spatial Analysis of Health Data   Health Disparities and the Development of High Priority Target Areas   September 10, 2009 Virginia Health Equity Conference Virginia Department of Health Office of Minority Health and Public Health Policy Ken Studer, PhD Rexford Anson-Dwamena, MPH
Types of  Spatial   Analysis Space as Variables Exploratory Spatial Data Analysis Spatial Data Models Space Process Models Each of these has different inferential/predictive abilities, and requires different amounts of data and knowledge of the spatial system itself.  (see, Geoffrey  M Jacquez, 2004)
Surrounded by Clusters! 'Tobler's first law of geography'  "everything is related to everything else, but near things are more related than distant things"
Double Jeopardy describes children (under 18 years old) that live in poor families and in poor neighborhoods. Poor neighborhoods  are defined as census tracts (CTs) with greater than 20.0% poverty. The racial categories include persons of Hispanic and non-Hispanic  origin; 'Other' includes American Indian, Alaska Native, Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander, some other race alone, and two or more races. **Total number of children living below the federal poverty level reflects the sum of the four racial categories since Hispanic ethnicity could not be determined for each race.  Source: Census 2000, SF3, P159. Where is the Map?
Abraham Verghese: Urbs in Rure Verghese, A., S. Berk, and F. Sarubbi. 1989.  Urbs in Rure:  HIV infections in rural Tennessee.  Journal of Infectious Diseases 160(6): 1051-1055.
Spatial Analysis of Prostate Cancer    Incidence in Virginia* * Oliver, MN, E Smith, M Siadaty, FR Hauck, LW Pickle, Spatial Analysis of Prostate Cancer Incidence and Race in Virginia, 1990–1999. Am J Prev Med 2006;30(2S):S67–S76. Census Tract Level Analysis County Level Analysis
Source: United States Department of Agriculture: Economic Research Service, 2004 County Typologies; Census 2000, SF3-PCT25. County/Census Tract Low Education in Virginia Census Tract Level County Level
County/Census Tract SMR
Mortality Ratio by Census Tract
Things Change but…. …systems remain highly sensitive to initial conditions
Persistence of Poverty
31
 
50% Infant Mortality in Richmond    Block Groups: 1990-2005
Percentage (yellow) of Richmond Homicides  by Census Tract, 2007 Richmond, Virginia Infant Deaths by Census Block Group, 1990-2005 Thematic Map (Choropleth Map)
Infant Mortality Clustering
NOVA Infant Deaths per Census Block Group Source: VDH Vital Statistics, 1990-2005.
Predictive Kriging Analysis Infant Deaths by Block Group Source: VDH Vital Statistics, 1990-2005. Kernel Density Analysis Low Birth-weight Infants  based on Census Tract Data with Optimum Locations for Clinics Source: VDH Vital Statistics, 1996-2005.
The Pareto Principle   Personal: 20% of our clothes we wear 80% of the time 80% of our time is spent with 20% of our acquaintances   Business: 80% of sales come from 20% of clients 20% of customers take up 80% of one's time GIS 20% of the time is required to create a map  40% of the time is required to understand the data 40% to understand the spatial analysis 80% of the time only 20% of an audience understands what is being discussed  (Maybe overly optimistic)
Health Disparity
Kernel Density Smoothed Surface
SaTScan Cluster Analysis
Cluster #1 Filter Decomposition
Rural Cluster #2
Breast Cancer Residual Analysis
Combined Kernel Density and Kriging   Analysis—State Standard
Combined Kernel Density and Kriging   Analysis—NOVA Standard
Combined Kernel Density and Kriging Analysis— Potentially Underreported Incidence
GeoDa Cluster Analysis
White Breast Cancer Rates
Black Breast Cancer Rates
Black/White Breast Cancer Disparities
Black/White Breast Cancer Disparities
Levels of Clustering Techniques Thematic Maps Hotspot Analysis Kernel Density Kriging GeoDa SaTScan Spatial Regression GWR, Logistic, Poisson GeoSurveillance Space as a Variable Exploratory Spatial Data Analysis  Spatial Data Modeling Spatial Process Modeling Spatial Clustering Algorithms Level of Spatial Analysis B L U E* *best linear unbiased estimators
Contact Information: Ken Studer, PhD [email_address] Rexford Anson-Dwamena, MPH rexford.dwamena @vdh.virginia.gov

More Related Content

PPTX
Epatients on the Front Lines: Precision Medicine, the FDA, and Me
PPT
Cancer Disparities
PPTX
Cataracts in America
PDF
Rawlings Provider Specialty and Payer Trends HIVTW and R4P 2016 poster
PDF
Coburn has recurrence of prostate cancer
PDF
09 June Health Status Update: Cancer Staging in Utah
PPT
Spatial clusters hiv texas
PDF
Food deserts icsc fl conf 8.31.15
Epatients on the Front Lines: Precision Medicine, the FDA, and Me
Cancer Disparities
Cataracts in America
Rawlings Provider Specialty and Payer Trends HIVTW and R4P 2016 poster
Coburn has recurrence of prostate cancer
09 June Health Status Update: Cancer Staging in Utah
Spatial clusters hiv texas
Food deserts icsc fl conf 8.31.15

Viewers also liked (9)

PPT
Marek - Spatial analyses of health data: From points to models
PPTX
Big Data in Ecology: Volume, Variety, and Velocity in Environmental Data
PPT
Spatial and temporal patterns of Rift Valley fever outbreaks in Tanzania: 193...
PPT
Health Management Information System in Ethiopia: Who Owns the HMIS
PPTX
Data Mining Spatial
PPTX
Introduction to SaTScan, seasonality and time series analysis
PDF
Human mobility,urban structure analysis,and spatial community detection from ...
PPTX
Spatial analysis and modeling
PPTX
Network analysis in gis
Marek - Spatial analyses of health data: From points to models
Big Data in Ecology: Volume, Variety, and Velocity in Environmental Data
Spatial and temporal patterns of Rift Valley fever outbreaks in Tanzania: 193...
Health Management Information System in Ethiopia: Who Owns the HMIS
Data Mining Spatial
Introduction to SaTScan, seasonality and time series analysis
Human mobility,urban structure analysis,and spatial community detection from ...
Spatial analysis and modeling
Network analysis in gis
Ad

Similar to The Spatial Analysis of Health Data: Health Disparities and the Development of High Priority Target Areas (20)

PPTX
Carlos Pellegrini: From Success to Significance
PPT
conferences.jbsinternational.com
PPTX
Prevention of HPV Diseases in Indigenous Populations: Examples of promising ...
PPTX
Strengthening Partnerships for Community Impact
PPTX
Strengthening Partnerships for Community Impact (Updated 2018)
PPTX
An Introduction to CVD Racial Disparities
PPTX
Health disparities in_dementia
 
PDF
Bitsie, K. (2015). Cancer Risk and Cancer Screening in a Pacific Northwest Tribe
PPTX
Looking Up the River: The Impact of Race & Ethnicity on Health
PPT
Improving Breast Cancer outcomes in Communities of Color Steps Towards Equity
PDF
When reducing cancer risk in our population, let’s not exacerbate disparities
PPTX
Understanding American Mortality and Lifestyle
PDF
Cancer Incidence and Survival By Major Ethnic Group
PDF
Addressing standardization challenges through integrated approaches in biomed...
PPTX
Measuring Ethnic and Sexual Identities: Lessons from Two Studies in Central A...
PDF
Spatial Inequities and Health Disparities among American Indians and Alaska N...
PPTX
Cancer in Our Community
PPTX
Latino Rates in Pennsylvania’s Uninsured
Carlos Pellegrini: From Success to Significance
conferences.jbsinternational.com
Prevention of HPV Diseases in Indigenous Populations: Examples of promising ...
Strengthening Partnerships for Community Impact
Strengthening Partnerships for Community Impact (Updated 2018)
An Introduction to CVD Racial Disparities
Health disparities in_dementia
 
Bitsie, K. (2015). Cancer Risk and Cancer Screening in a Pacific Northwest Tribe
Looking Up the River: The Impact of Race & Ethnicity on Health
Improving Breast Cancer outcomes in Communities of Color Steps Towards Equity
When reducing cancer risk in our population, let’s not exacerbate disparities
Understanding American Mortality and Lifestyle
Cancer Incidence and Survival By Major Ethnic Group
Addressing standardization challenges through integrated approaches in biomed...
Measuring Ethnic and Sexual Identities: Lessons from Two Studies in Central A...
Spatial Inequities and Health Disparities among American Indians and Alaska N...
Cancer in Our Community
Latino Rates in Pennsylvania’s Uninsured
Ad

More from VDH, Office of Minority Health and Public Health Policy (20)

PPT
Health Equity Considerations For Virginia's African American Children
PPT
Community Connections for Health: VCU’s Center on Health Disparities Communit...
PDF
Civic Entrepreneurship: Revenue Generating Strategies Government and Nonprofi...
PPT
Putting Social Determinants in Perspective for Policymakers
PPT
Health Impact Assessments to Promote Healthy Neighborhoods
PPT
Achieving Health Equity Will Require More than Equity in Health Care
PPT
Show Me the Money: Strategies for Identifying Potential Funders and Writing S...
PPT
Health, Equity and the Built Environment: What do Healthy Communities Look Like?
PPT
Social Determinants of Health and Equity: The Impacts of Racism on Health
PPT
PPT
Community-Based Participatory Approaches: Coalition Building in Real Communities
PPT
Mobilizing for Action through Planning and Partnerships (MAPP)
PPT
Greater Prince William Community Health Center: Advocacy Techniques, Success ...
PPT
Moving Beyond the Map: Geospatial Analysis applied to Public Health and the C...
PPT
Community Health Centers and National Advocacy
PPT
Building Stronger Communities for Better Health: Moving from Science to Polic...
Health Equity Considerations For Virginia's African American Children
Community Connections for Health: VCU’s Center on Health Disparities Communit...
Civic Entrepreneurship: Revenue Generating Strategies Government and Nonprofi...
Putting Social Determinants in Perspective for Policymakers
Health Impact Assessments to Promote Healthy Neighborhoods
Achieving Health Equity Will Require More than Equity in Health Care
Show Me the Money: Strategies for Identifying Potential Funders and Writing S...
Health, Equity and the Built Environment: What do Healthy Communities Look Like?
Social Determinants of Health and Equity: The Impacts of Racism on Health
Community-Based Participatory Approaches: Coalition Building in Real Communities
Mobilizing for Action through Planning and Partnerships (MAPP)
Greater Prince William Community Health Center: Advocacy Techniques, Success ...
Moving Beyond the Map: Geospatial Analysis applied to Public Health and the C...
Community Health Centers and National Advocacy
Building Stronger Communities for Better Health: Moving from Science to Polic...

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Approach to chest pain, SOB, palpitation and prolonged fever
PPTX
Human Reproduction: Anatomy, Physiology & Clinical Insights.pptx
PPTX
Electrolyte Disturbance in Paediatric - Nitthi.pptx
PPT
nephrology MRCP - Member of Royal College of Physicians ppt
PPTX
thio and propofol mechanism and uses.pptx
PPTX
CARDIOVASCULAR AND RENAL DRUGS.pptx for health study
PPTX
y4d nutrition and diet in pregnancy and postpartum
PDF
MNEMONICS MNEMONICS MNEMONICS MNEMONICS s
PPTX
Neonate anatomy and physiology presentation
PPTX
NRP and care of Newborn.pptx- APPT presentation about neonatal resuscitation ...
PPTX
Introduction to Medical Microbiology for 400L Medical Students
PDF
OSCE SERIES - Set 7 ( Questions & Answers ).pdf
PDF
The_EHRA_Book_of_Interventional Electrophysiology.pdf
PDF
Comparison of Swim-Up and Microfluidic Sperm Sorting.pdf
DOCX
PEADIATRICS NOTES.docx lecture notes for medical students
PPTX
Hearthhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
PDF
AGE(Acute Gastroenteritis)pdf. Specific.
PDF
Lecture 8- Cornea and Sclera .pdf 5tg year
PPTX
IMAGING EQUIPMENiiiiìiiiiiTpptxeiuueueur
PDF
focused on the development and application of glycoHILIC, pepHILIC, and comm...
Approach to chest pain, SOB, palpitation and prolonged fever
Human Reproduction: Anatomy, Physiology & Clinical Insights.pptx
Electrolyte Disturbance in Paediatric - Nitthi.pptx
nephrology MRCP - Member of Royal College of Physicians ppt
thio and propofol mechanism and uses.pptx
CARDIOVASCULAR AND RENAL DRUGS.pptx for health study
y4d nutrition and diet in pregnancy and postpartum
MNEMONICS MNEMONICS MNEMONICS MNEMONICS s
Neonate anatomy and physiology presentation
NRP and care of Newborn.pptx- APPT presentation about neonatal resuscitation ...
Introduction to Medical Microbiology for 400L Medical Students
OSCE SERIES - Set 7 ( Questions & Answers ).pdf
The_EHRA_Book_of_Interventional Electrophysiology.pdf
Comparison of Swim-Up and Microfluidic Sperm Sorting.pdf
PEADIATRICS NOTES.docx lecture notes for medical students
Hearthhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
AGE(Acute Gastroenteritis)pdf. Specific.
Lecture 8- Cornea and Sclera .pdf 5tg year
IMAGING EQUIPMENiiiiìiiiiiTpptxeiuueueur
focused on the development and application of glycoHILIC, pepHILIC, and comm...

The Spatial Analysis of Health Data: Health Disparities and the Development of High Priority Target Areas

  • 1. The Spatial Analysis of Health Data Health Disparities and the Development of High Priority Target Areas September 10, 2009 Virginia Health Equity Conference Virginia Department of Health Office of Minority Health and Public Health Policy Ken Studer, PhD Rexford Anson-Dwamena, MPH
  • 2. Types of Spatial Analysis Space as Variables Exploratory Spatial Data Analysis Spatial Data Models Space Process Models Each of these has different inferential/predictive abilities, and requires different amounts of data and knowledge of the spatial system itself. (see, Geoffrey M Jacquez, 2004)
  • 3. Surrounded by Clusters! 'Tobler's first law of geography' "everything is related to everything else, but near things are more related than distant things"
  • 4. Double Jeopardy describes children (under 18 years old) that live in poor families and in poor neighborhoods. Poor neighborhoods are defined as census tracts (CTs) with greater than 20.0% poverty. The racial categories include persons of Hispanic and non-Hispanic origin; 'Other' includes American Indian, Alaska Native, Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander, some other race alone, and two or more races. **Total number of children living below the federal poverty level reflects the sum of the four racial categories since Hispanic ethnicity could not be determined for each race. Source: Census 2000, SF3, P159. Where is the Map?
  • 5. Abraham Verghese: Urbs in Rure Verghese, A., S. Berk, and F. Sarubbi. 1989. Urbs in Rure: HIV infections in rural Tennessee. Journal of Infectious Diseases 160(6): 1051-1055.
  • 6. Spatial Analysis of Prostate Cancer Incidence in Virginia* * Oliver, MN, E Smith, M Siadaty, FR Hauck, LW Pickle, Spatial Analysis of Prostate Cancer Incidence and Race in Virginia, 1990–1999. Am J Prev Med 2006;30(2S):S67–S76. Census Tract Level Analysis County Level Analysis
  • 7. Source: United States Department of Agriculture: Economic Research Service, 2004 County Typologies; Census 2000, SF3-PCT25. County/Census Tract Low Education in Virginia Census Tract Level County Level
  • 9. Mortality Ratio by Census Tract
  • 10. Things Change but…. …systems remain highly sensitive to initial conditions
  • 12. 31
  • 13.  
  • 14. 50% Infant Mortality in Richmond Block Groups: 1990-2005
  • 15. Percentage (yellow) of Richmond Homicides by Census Tract, 2007 Richmond, Virginia Infant Deaths by Census Block Group, 1990-2005 Thematic Map (Choropleth Map)
  • 17. NOVA Infant Deaths per Census Block Group Source: VDH Vital Statistics, 1990-2005.
  • 18. Predictive Kriging Analysis Infant Deaths by Block Group Source: VDH Vital Statistics, 1990-2005. Kernel Density Analysis Low Birth-weight Infants based on Census Tract Data with Optimum Locations for Clinics Source: VDH Vital Statistics, 1996-2005.
  • 19. The Pareto Principle Personal: 20% of our clothes we wear 80% of the time 80% of our time is spent with 20% of our acquaintances Business: 80% of sales come from 20% of clients 20% of customers take up 80% of one's time GIS 20% of the time is required to create a map 40% of the time is required to understand the data 40% to understand the spatial analysis 80% of the time only 20% of an audience understands what is being discussed (Maybe overly optimistic)
  • 23. Cluster #1 Filter Decomposition
  • 26. Combined Kernel Density and Kriging Analysis—State Standard
  • 27. Combined Kernel Density and Kriging Analysis—NOVA Standard
  • 28. Combined Kernel Density and Kriging Analysis— Potentially Underreported Incidence
  • 34. Levels of Clustering Techniques Thematic Maps Hotspot Analysis Kernel Density Kriging GeoDa SaTScan Spatial Regression GWR, Logistic, Poisson GeoSurveillance Space as a Variable Exploratory Spatial Data Analysis Spatial Data Modeling Spatial Process Modeling Spatial Clustering Algorithms Level of Spatial Analysis B L U E* *best linear unbiased estimators
  • 35. Contact Information: Ken Studer, PhD [email_address] Rexford Anson-Dwamena, MPH rexford.dwamena @vdh.virginia.gov