Usability analysis of sms alert system for immunization

IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology eISSN: 2319-1163 | pISSN: 2321-7308
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Volume: 02 Issue: 11 | Nov-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 300
USABILITY ANALYSIS OF SMS ALERT SYSTEM FOR IMMUNIZATION
IN THE CONTEXT OF BANGLADESH
Touhid Bhuiyan1
, Imran Mahmud2
, Banassri Alam3
1
Associate Professor, 2
Senior Lecturer, Department of Software Engineering, Daffodil International University, Dhaka,
Bangladesh, t.bhuiyan@daffodilvarsity.edu.bd, imranmahmud@daffodilvarsity.edu.bd
3
Research Student, Department of Computer Science and Engineering, East West University, Dhaka, Bangladesh,
Abstract
Both the market and academia strongly encourage the development of usable systems, and they do so by relying on a number of
standards, guide-lines, research and good practice streams. Unfortunately, in the health sector, whilst being the owner of standards
under many purposes and topics, seems still falling and running behind as the conceptual issues and practical implications of
usability are concerned. In this study, it was found that rapid growth of mobile applications through SMS increases in a significant
way in developing countries particularly in Bangladesh. Public satisfaction was highly shown in mobile health services through SMS.
In our paper, usability has been analytically investigated throughout a simulated health oriented action setting and against a
prototype of SMS based health services in Bangladesh, and several provoking conclusions in terms of “rethinking usability” applied
to academic actions and decision making have been derived. Various health institutes can be influenced by this study to challenge
existing difficulties against usability potential.
Keywords: ICT, mHealth, Mobile applications, SMS, Usability
----------------------------------------------------------------------***------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. INTRODUCTION
No individual or organization, no matter which sector or field
they operate, would ever consider managing any relevant
amount of information without relying on some sort of
Information Technology (IT) and Information Management
System (IMS), today; and not so just in order to support more
or less “demanding” (computationally speaking) tasks, but
also and mainly for simpler reasons, from retrieving to sharing
accurate information for example, especially when such jobs
involve or occur within distributed environments. This is
obviously even truer when large-scale, real-time complex
systems are considered: and the larger and more complex the
IMS, the more important its usability.
Mobile phone is one of the most innovative technological
tools in the past decade. It is rapidly growing all over the
world. Millions of first telephone owners made text messages
as a part of their lives. Nowadays several ways of usage have
been made to provide various educational, banking and health
services using mobile phone. These services take various
forms like SMS based grade checking, information fetching,
mobile learning etc.
There is significant potential for the use of mobile telephony
to improve health service outcomes and data management.
Opportunities include: serving as a less costly substitute for
existing interventions; providing interactive functions that
multiply the power of existing interventions; and serving
entirely new functions. The use of mobile technology in health
services (mHealth) has the potential to create more than 5
billion points of contact between consumers, healthcare
workers, health system administrators and firms in supply
chains for health commodities. Since its first appearance and
within its ongoing meaning definition process, usability has
been thoroughly investigated and pursued, mainly under a
“Health care” perspective, by both administration and
academia.
This paper aims at highlighting a set of “affordances”
(arguments, hypotheses, suggestions, issues and provocations)
to let usability become a primary factor to this health care
organization from both government and NGOs.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
Existing technologies like the Internet can be used to help
doctors working in isolated rural villages to access up-to-date
medical information and communicate with colleagues, and
even to diagnose illnesses and treat patients. But in developing
countries these health workers who care for 80 to 90% of the
populations live in rural areas that are at times impassible and
have no meaningful access to the Internet [1]. The rapid
growth and widespread use of wireless technologies provides
the best opportunity to reach these isolated health workers.
The term mHealth has been described extensively by several
authors [2, 3]. Generally the term refers to the use of mobile

__________________________________________________________________________________________
telecommunications in provisioning healthcare. Preliminary
research has already shown that the application of mobile
devices within the health sector is promising. Literature
presents the use of mobile devices in health [4,5,6,7] though
those that seems to have drawn keen interest especially for use
in developing countries are those that implement text
messaging [8,9,10,11,12,13] a feature of mobile phones,
commonly known as SMS. Text messaging seems to have
been successful for various reasons. Aside from being cheap
and having low bandwidth requirements, it is also easy to use
and is supported by all cellular phones; both feature and high-
end. The minimal usage of mobile devices mainly the Personal
Digital Assistant (PDA) in health in Kenya has been
evidenced in the areas of data gathering, disease surveillance
and epidemic tracking [14] yet the use of the mobile phones as
shown in existing literature to have been useful in delivering
healthcare services elsewhere has been left largely unexplored.
The status of the communication infrastructure and the
capabilities of mobile phones in this region provide a good
basis for the use of SMS for health care delivery. Such phones
also present inherent limitations in terms of display size and
computational power and battery life [6, 7, 12, 15] and hence,
these would be key design requirements to be considered in
developing mHealth applications.
3. REQUIREMENT GATHERING
Before any development of the system began, a consultative
phase was initiated to investigate the knowledge sharing
problem with the several health service organizations and
some new parents. Meeting with 40 parents and three
endocrinologists were held. From the session, the following
conclusion was drawn.
• As there is no source which consistently provides the
info of child health care and vaccination, parents
have to go to hospital or clinic to get the necessary
info. This is quite tiresome and is not always an
effective method. After the birth of baby, some extra
chore develops. As a result visit to hospital become
even more difficult for people.
• Most of the people forgets to take the later doses of
the vaccination in due time so first doses became
useless.
• In fact many parents don’t register their child birth
just because the process of registering is tiresome. So
it would many parents as well as the government if
they can register the child birth through a single &
simple SMS.
We visited Icddr,b for child vaccination schedule. Icddr,b
(International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research,
Bangladesh) is one of the most renowned health service
organizations in Bangladesh. They guided us by giving some
information about child diet and vaccination. The child
vaccination schedule is given below.
Table -1: Vaccine Schedule
Age Vaccine
Birth
BCG, Oral Polio (first dose), Hepatitis B
(first dose)
6 weeks
DPT (first dose), Oral Polio (second dose),
Hepatitis B (second dose)
10 weeks DPT (second dose), Oral Polio (third dose)
14 weeks
DPT (third dose), Oral Polio (fourth dose),
Hib (first dose)
20 weeks Hib(2nd)
4. SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE
Stage 1: People will register with hospital database through
SMS (e.g. child name, dob to 1616)
Stage 2: After registration, child’s parent will receive sms
about 1st dose of vaccine.
Stage 3: In every 6 months or later, parents will automatically
receive sms from server about different vaccine according to
child’s age
Fig -1: Data flow diagram
Fig -2: Sample SMS

__________________________________________________________________________________________
5. RESEARCH QUESTION
How SMS technology based “Virtual Health Care Service”
could be a successful tool to aid people?
To answer the research question researchers break down with
the following specified objectives:
• Identify the limitations with current technologies
• Identify availability of mobile phones in Bangladesh
• Identify users satisfaction and usability level
The purpose of this report is to develop a usability testing on
SMS based health care support system in the developing
countries.
5.1 Research Method
Both primary and secondary data were collected for this
research. Both qualitative and quantitative research methods
were applied to develop this research. This research is mainly
divided into two areas. One is for the people who are going to
using “Virtual Health Care” system and the other is health
care related authorities who will upload the updated notice and
materials to deliver people. The methodology used in this
paper is based upon an investigation of current mobile based
health care support applications in a variety of countries and
then comparing those applications in order to suggest
improvements.
A framework has been developed for usability testing which
identifies the efficiency and effectiveness of SMS based health
care system.
There are six Hypotheses to analysis the result with Z test a
survey on 57 sample size with structured questionnaire of
simple random sampling.
5.2 Hypothesis
Table -2: list of hypothesis
No Hypothesis
H1
Accomplish the task is done quickly by using this
service)
H2 I am satisfied with number of steps included
H3 It is easy to understand what is needed
H4 It is easy to learn this system
H5
SMS based information satisfactory rather than
previous manual system of exchange or delivery of
information
6. USABILITY FRAMEWORK
As the ISO definition suggests, usability is a multi-
dimensional concept. There are often compromises to be
made, trading off different goals to achieve a usable product.
It was said that efficiency, effectiveness and satisfaction are
independent qualities of the system [16].
To test usability of SMS based system a framework has been
developed
6.1System Centered Approach
Availability: Despite of the difficult business environment,
the mobile communications sector is growing rapidly and is
cited as the fastest growing industry in Bangladesh. According
to a report by Telenor ASA(2008) The mobile
communications sector began in Bangladesh with the licensing
of a single company, Pacific Bangladesh Telecom Ltd (PTBL)
in 1991. In 1996, three national GSM (Global System for
mobile communication) licenses were granted and this opened
upon the mobile communications sector to a wider subscriber
base. Currently, six mobile network operators are currently
licensed to operate in Bangladesh. The total number of Mobile
Phone Active Subscribers has reached 101.205 million at the
middle of June 2012.From [17]; it was found the number of
mobile phone subscriber in Bangladesh at the moment.
Table -3: Active mobile phone user
Operator
Active
subscriber
Grameen Phone Limited(GP) 42.372
Orascom Telecom Bangladesh
Ltd(Banglalink)
26.309
RobiAxiata Limited(Robi) 21.697
Airtel Bangladesh Limited( Airtel) 7.557
Pacific Bangladesh Telecom Limited
(Citycell)
1.425
Teletalk Bangladesh Limited(Teletalk) 1.8
Total 101.205Millions
It means mobile devices are becoming a part of daily life for
Bangladeshi people. People are not only using mobile phone
for communication but also as a tool to transfer information.

__________________________________________________________________________________________
Localizability: SMS can be used in any kind of environment
or area. Students, who are out of campus on vacation time,
will easily get information of the university through SMS.
Supportability: SMS supports in any kind of mobile device.
Reliability: SMS service is available 24/7; as a result, it is very
reliable.
Security: SMS is very secured technology. Every SMS can be
tracked. Only registered students will get specific SMS
through mobile. Only admission and university information
modules are open to general people outside the university.
Technical Feasibility: SMS based virtual campus was
developed using PHP and MySQL. Both are open source
software and free. Whole project was developed by following
OOP method. As it is developed by PHP, as a result it can
handle 80 users that means per second 80 SMS. Since, it is
totally object oriented, so it can be extended based on
requirement.
6.2 Human Centered Approach
Knowledge of use:
A survey was conducted to find out knowledge of mobile
phone users about SMS service where sample size was 57.
Findings of the survey questionnaire on the knowledge of use
are given in the table below
Table -4: User response
General category Response
Availability of device 90%
Available to family 83%
Frequency of use 95%
Readability 75%
Training 23%
Receive notification from
government or other organization
25%
Usability is a qualitative attribute that assesses how easy user
interfaces are to use. The word "usability" also refers to
methods for improving ease-of-use during the design process.
Usability consultant Jakob Nielsen (and computer science
professor Ben Shneiderman has written (separately) about a
framework of system acceptability, where usability is a part of
"usefulness"[18, 19] and is composed of:
Learnability: How easy is it for users to accomplish basic
tasks the first time they encounter the design?
Efficiency: Once users have learned the design, how quickly
can they perform tasks?
Memorability: When users return to the design after a period
of not using it, how easily can they reestablish proficiency?
Errors: How many errors do users make, how severe are
these errors, and how easily can they recover from the errors?
Satisfaction: How pleasant is it to use the design?
7. DATA COLLECTION AND RESULTS
From the collected data, we have found that, 42 % respondents
strongly agreed about their effective use of mobile phones,
50% respondents satisfied with number of steps included in
our system, 21 % believed system is very easy, 51% of
respondents prefer SMS based system rather than manual
system.
Since, in every single hypothesis Z cal > Z tab, so Value the
null hypothesis is rejected at 5% significance level, it can be
said that people rate the concept behind SMS based health
alert system is an effective tool for government and health
NGOs. Learn ability, reliability and satisfaction rate is higher
in this system.
Table -5: hypothesis analysis
H1 H2 H3 H4 HH5
A)Strongly Disagree(1) 2 0 5 0 0
B) Disagree(2) 5 3 4 2 1
C)Neither Agree nor Disagree(3) 14 7 20 11 15
D)Agree(4) 24 28 16 15 21
E)Strongly agree(5) 12 19 12 29 20
Total 57 57 57 57 57
Average 3.333 3.714 3.127 3.841 3.667
Standard Deviation 1.071 0.899 1.202 0.972 0.912
Z-test 5.877 10.196 3.939 10.415 9.659
Alternative Hypothesis Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted
Result (Zcal>Ztab)

__________________________________________________________________________________________
CONCLUSIONS
The popularity of the application of mobile devices in health
sector is gaining attention more and more with the tremendous
growth of the mobile phone itself. In this paper, the usability
has been analytically investigated throughout a simulated
health oriented action selling and a model of a SMS based
health service proposed. This small scale research study is not
enough to commend on the efficacy and efficiency of this
SMS based immunization system. However, the study
suggests that it is possible to develop SMS based virtual health
services in Bangladesh. By focusing on new devices and
technologies to be adopted by and within the health sector, we
have addressed several issues. This improved information
transmission will save time and energy at different layers of
health administration thereby reducing the unnecessary work-
load and paper work in relevant functionaries of health
institutions.
REFERENCES
[1] F. Bukachi, N. Pakenham-Walsh. Information
technology for health in developing countries. Chest.
2007, 132 (5): 1624-1630.
[2] R. Istepanian, E. Jovanov, T. Zhang. Introduction to
the special section on M-Health: beyond seamless
mobility and global wireless health-care connectivity.
IEEE Transactions on Information Technology in
Biomedicine. 2004, 405-413.
[3] R. Istepanian, J. Lacal. Emerging mobile
communication technologies for health: some
imperative notes on m-Health. Engineering in
Medicine and Biology Society. Proceedings of the
25th Annual International Conference of the IEEE.
2003: 1414 – 1416.
[4] Farmer, O. Gibson, P. Hayton, K. Bryden, C. Dudley,
A. Neil, L. Tarassenko, L. A real-time mobile phone-
based telemedicine system to support young adults
with type 1 diabetes.Informatics in Primary
Care.2005,13(3): 171-178.
[5] B.C. Grasso, R. Genest, K. Yung, C. Arnold, C.
Reducing errors in discharge medication lists by using
personal digital assistants. Psychiatr Serv. 2002, 53:
1325 - 1326.
[6] M.F.T. Peterson. The right information at the point of
care library delivery via hand-held computers. Paper
presented at the EAHIL Conference of Health and
Medical Libraries. Cologne, 2002.
[7] S. Fischer, T.E. Stewart, S. Mehta, R. Wax, S.E.
Lapinsky. Handheld computing in medicine. Journal
of the American Medical Information Association.
2003, 10(2): 139-149.
[8] 8.K.C. Leong, W.S. Chen, K.W. Leong, I. Mastura, O.
Mimi, M.A. Sheikh, A.H. Zailinawatig, C.J. Ng, K.L.
Phua, C.L. Teng. The use of text messaging to
improve attendance in primary care: a randomized
controlled trial. Family Practice.2006, 23(6): 699-705.
[9] M.S. Lim, J.S. Hocking, M.E. Hellard, C.K. Aitken.
SMS STI: a review of the uses of mobile phone text
messaging in sexual health. International Journal of
STD & AIDS. 2008,19(5): 287–290.
[10] O. Ferrer-Roca, A. Ca ́rdenas, A. Diaz-Cardama, P.
Pulido. Mobile phone text messaging in the
management of diabetes. Journal of Telemedicine and
Telecare. 2004, 10(5): 282-285.
[11] S.B. Gerber, M.R. Stolley, A.L. Thompson, L.K.
Sharp, M.L. Fitzgibbon. Mobile phone text messaging
to promote healthy behaviors and weight loss
maintenance: A feasibility study. Health Informatics.
2009, 15(1): 15-25.
[12] S.R. Downer, J.G. Meara, A.C. Da Costa. Use of SMS
text messaging to improve outpatient attendance.
Medical Journal of Australia.2005,183 (7): 366-368.
[13] Vital Wave Consulting. mHealth for Development:
The Opportunity of Mobile Technology for Healthcare
in the Developing World. Washington, D.C. and
Berkshire, UK: UN Foundation-Vodafone Foundation
Partnership, 2009.
[14] K. Sowon. A mobile health architecture to provide
home-based care using text messaging (unpublished
master’s thesis, Strathmore University, 2010)
[15] P. Yu, M.X. Wu, H. Yu, G.Q. Xiao. The challenges
for the adoption of mHealth. IEEE International
Conference on Service Operations, Logistics and
Informatics. Shanghai, China. 2006: 181 – 186
[16] Frokjaer, E., Hertzum, M., Hornbaek, K., (2000).
Measuring usability: are effectiveness, efficiency and
satisfaction really correlated? CHI Letters 2 (1), 345–
352
[17] The official website of Bangladesh
Telecommunication Regulatory Commission (2013),
Visited on 12 June, 2013
[18] Ben Shneiderman(1980): Software Psychology, ISBN
0-87626-816-5
[19] Jakob Nielsen(1994),Usability Engineering, Morgan
Kaufmann Publishers, ISBN0-12-518406-9
BIOGRAPHIES
Dr. Touhid Bhuiyan is working as an
Associate Professor at the Department of
Software Engineering, Daffodil International
University (DIU). His research interests are
in intelligent recommendations, social
network, trust management, database
management and e-Learning in general.
Before joining at DIU, he was employed by several renowned
organizations including the Queensland University of
Technology, University of Western Australia, University of
Western Sydney and Central College Sydney. He has more
than 16 years experience in teaching, research and working at

__________________________________________________________________________________________
the IT industry in Australia, Singapore and Bangladesh.
Previously he also served the East West University and the
People's University of Bangladesh.
Imran Mahmud is currently working at
Daffodil International University as a senior
lecturer in the Department of Software
Engineering. Previously he worked two
years at International University of Business
Agriculture and Technology (IUBAT) as a
faculty of Computer Science and
Engineering. He has finished MSc. in Software Engineering
from University of Hertfordshire (www.herts.ac.uk), UK in
2009. Before his masters he has spent three years in industry,
working in IT and project management, business application
development, software design and consultancy. Again, He is
also working as part time IT consultant in Civil Service
College Dhaka (www.csc.edu.bd) and a software company
called jhoroTEK (www.jhorotek.com ).
Ms. Banassri Alam is working as a research
student of Department of Computer Science
and Engineering at East West University,
Bangladesh. Apart from being a student, she
is also working as manager at
Grameenphone Ltd, the largest telecom
company in Bangladesh. During her study
period, she worked with mobile phone based technology like
SMS, J2ME, jQuery mobile apps etc. Ms. Banassri had her
internship on “Analysis Capacity Planning & Design of Telco
Contact Center”. She achieved 85% during her master’s
degree.

Usability analysis of sms alert system for immunization

More Related Content

What's hot (19)

Viewers also liked (20)

Similar to Usability analysis of sms alert system for immunization (20)

More from eSAT Publishing House (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

Usability analysis of sms alert system for immunization