COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
Why the
“new keyword = new page”
approach to SEO
is .
@epiphanysearch
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
The Problem
@epiphanysearch
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
The Old Approach
“vintage bike insurance”
“classic bike insurance”
Two keywords, two sets
of content, two URLs
If it’s an important term, let’s make a page for it!
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
But Google Thinks They’re the Same …
We searched for vintage bike insurance …
We got back results for classic bike insurance
Google thinks they’re the same thing – even though
they’re actually slightly different
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
Keyword cannibalisation
+ catch-all pages for similar, smaller terms
Many terms which were targeted with individual
landing pages were semantically very similar –
however separate pages were necessary as
the policies differed.
When dealing with many variations of similar
terms with low search volume – a page
targeting the umbrella term can often work as a
“catch-all” page.
classic bike insurance
vintage bike insurance
scooter insurance
moped insurance
offroad bike insurance
mx bike insurance
Motocross insurance
pit bike insurance
trials bike insurance
@epiphanysearch
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
The Options
<meta name="robots" content="noindex, follow" />
<link href="http:/www.example.com/canonical-version-of-page/" rel=canonical" />
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
What Did We Choose?
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
Results
Within 3 weeks of implementing the fix terms moved for the first time onto page 1, where they have
remained since, and now share the same higher ranking with the same ranking page – no more flip-
flopping
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
1st Jan 5th Jan 8th Jan 12th Jan 14th Jan 21st Jan 28th Jan 2nd Feb Current
scooter insurance moped insurance
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
Is All My Content Really
Necessary?
@epiphanysearch
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
And that doesn’t even cover …
2015
2016
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
How do I increase my search
relevance now?
@epiphanysearch
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
Know Your Audience
@epiphanysearch
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
How Do I Find Out About My Audience?
Internal
site
searches
Focus
groups
Analytics
information
Sales
people &
call centres
@epiphanysearch
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
No site should be limited to a finite set of “money
keywords”. Growing relevance for more terms lessens the
dependency on a small set of keywords.
We want to be visible at every possible organic
touch-point as a potential customer starts their discovery
journey, narrows it, compares and chooses.
Content
Strategy Aim:
Broaden your organic visibility
Purchase
Decision
Research
problem
Research
solutions
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
Content & UX
• Who is the best answer to
the query I’m attempting
to answer?
• How do I become the best
answer?
• How can I appear at all
stages of a customer’s
potential journey through
searching?
• Will my content do what I
need it to?
Stage Step Example Search Phrases Goals
Informational
Researching ways to
cover costs
How can I tell when I need a new car
battery
Replacing a car battery
Fitting a car battery
What does a car battery look like? Sessions
Guide / information
downloads
SignupsHigh level browsing
Which car battery do I need?
Car battery for Mazda
Seeking opinions
Best car batteries
Quality car batteries
Transactional Gathered the specifics
Exide car battery
Lion car battery
Buy car battery
Cheap car battery
Purchases
Post-sale Managing
Car battery working correctly
Car battery guarantee
Sessions
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
Long Tail = More Accessible SERP
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
Search is a journey
We need to ensure our content
covers multiple touch points while
serving the needs of the user at
every stage.
It often takes multiple visits to
convert, individual channels all
contribute
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
Implementation
@epiphanysearch
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
Is Your Blog Still Valuable?
• What are you posting?
• How often are you posting it?
• Who is responsible for it?
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
Where Can You Host Content?
How connected is it to your main content?
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
Can It Lead to Conversion?
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
Can You Make Your Content Work Harder?
Find that
content’s
audience and
work to gain
coverage for it
Can you be a
resource for
another site?
Can you attach a
survey or
valuable data to
gain headlines?
Think about
how many
purposes your
content can
serve before
you write it
@epiphanysearch
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
Impacting the Future
@epiphanysearch
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
20%
Of Google searches now have
voice intent
@epiphanysearch
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
Conversational Queries are the Future
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
Digital Assistants
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
@epiphanysearch
Instant Answers
COPYRIGHTJAYWINGPLC2015
Key Points
Check Your
Keyword Targeting Consider the
journey
Become a useful
resource
@epiphanysearch

More Related Content

PDF
Best practice is not enough #brightonSEO @Linkdex #SEOnow stage
PDF
Conversion Rate Optimisation (CRO) Seminar - Vorian Agency
PDF
Avoiding a website migration disaster
PPTX
How Agile Technical SEO Can Add Value To Your SEO Campaign, by Adam Gent
PDF
SEO: Getting Personal
PPTX
The Art & Science of Building Links By Debra Mastaler
PPTX
Large Site SEO Architecture - #BrightonSEO 2015
PPTX
Omi sido-beyond-the-basics-of-website-migration.pptx
Best practice is not enough #brightonSEO @Linkdex #SEOnow stage
Conversion Rate Optimisation (CRO) Seminar - Vorian Agency
Avoiding a website migration disaster
How Agile Technical SEO Can Add Value To Your SEO Campaign, by Adam Gent
SEO: Getting Personal
The Art & Science of Building Links By Debra Mastaler
Large Site SEO Architecture - #BrightonSEO 2015
Omi sido-beyond-the-basics-of-website-migration.pptx

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Analytics Horror Stories - BrightonSEO 2016
PDF
Driving *Meaningful* Clicks with Enriched SERPs - BrightonSEO 2019
PDF
Google Discover Optimisation with Google Web Stories
PPTX
What is your link building gameplan
PDF
SEO for journalists
PPTX
How to Not Go Viral and Grow by 500,000+ Monthly Visits #StateOfSearch
PPTX
Experimentation: A Superior Framework+Offering for SEO by Cyrus Shepard
PPTX
BrightonSEO 2018 - How to Tighten up Your SEO on Large Websites
PDF
Intro to SEO
PPTX
Paywall SEO: Digital First Print Second, From 0 to 35k subscribers in a year
PPTX
Link Building Strategies That Increase Monthly Revenue by $240,740 #EngagePDX
PPTX
10 Ways to Build a Link in 20 Minutes Flat + Bonus Content
PDF
Traffic vs conversions how seo & cro can work together
PPTX
35 Ways to get Links in 35 Minutes - Paddy Moogan at MozCon 2012
PDF
BrightonSEO 2021 - Stakeholder Salad: Communication Skills For SEOs - Talk Yo...
PPTX
[500DISTRO] Cracking the SEO Code: Tricks & Tactics To Magnify Search Visibility
PDF
Avoiding Google Penalties by Appearing Squeaky Clean by Dean Chew
PDF
Wine & Web: How to do a content audit
PDF
SERP Analysis for Content Strategy #SEERFest
PPTX
BrightonSEO Sept
Analytics Horror Stories - BrightonSEO 2016
Driving *Meaningful* Clicks with Enriched SERPs - BrightonSEO 2019
Google Discover Optimisation with Google Web Stories
What is your link building gameplan
SEO for journalists
How to Not Go Viral and Grow by 500,000+ Monthly Visits #StateOfSearch
Experimentation: A Superior Framework+Offering for SEO by Cyrus Shepard
BrightonSEO 2018 - How to Tighten up Your SEO on Large Websites
Intro to SEO
Paywall SEO: Digital First Print Second, From 0 to 35k subscribers in a year
Link Building Strategies That Increase Monthly Revenue by $240,740 #EngagePDX
10 Ways to Build a Link in 20 Minutes Flat + Bonus Content
Traffic vs conversions how seo & cro can work together
35 Ways to get Links in 35 Minutes - Paddy Moogan at MozCon 2012
BrightonSEO 2021 - Stakeholder Salad: Communication Skills For SEOs - Talk Yo...
[500DISTRO] Cracking the SEO Code: Tricks & Tactics To Magnify Search Visibility
Avoiding Google Penalties by Appearing Squeaky Clean by Dean Chew
Wine & Web: How to do a content audit
SERP Analysis for Content Strategy #SEERFest
BrightonSEO Sept
Ad

Similar to Why the "New Keyword = New Page" Approach is Bonkers (20)

PPTX
Semantic search and the 'new' seo
PDF
Get More Sales Through Better Search Engine Optimization (SEO) and Social Eng...
PDF
The In-depth Guide to Website On-page Optimization
PPTX
Google helpful content and shift away from traditional SEO - Daniel Foley Car...
PPTX
SEO presentation for marketing summit 2017
PPTX
Andreas Dzumla — Google's Hogging Half Your Traffic: How to Get it Back
PPTX
Surprising Facts about Google and 2017 SEO
PPTX
Dominating the Long Tail | Digital Horizons Oct 2016
PDF
SEO Code-Breaking: How Smarter Content Leads to Better Search Rankings
PPTX
SEO Tactics to Love vs. Leave
PPTX
Helping customers find you online - Rand Fishkin at Business of Software Conf...
PDF
Theres no quick fix to your seo
PPTX
Paid Search 2019 A5 Advertising
PPT
The Web Wonder In 40 Minutes
PDF
Google, SEO and Personalized Search
PPTX
The Reason Behind Semantic SEO: Why does Google Avoid the Word PageRank?
PPTX
Rider University SEO Presentation by Michael Fleischner
PDF
Optimizing For Google’s New Landscape And The Future Of Search
PPTX
Sept. 28, 2011 webcast become an expert google searcher in an hour stephan ...
PDF
SearchCon 2016 | High Velocity Presentations
Semantic search and the 'new' seo
Get More Sales Through Better Search Engine Optimization (SEO) and Social Eng...
The In-depth Guide to Website On-page Optimization
Google helpful content and shift away from traditional SEO - Daniel Foley Car...
SEO presentation for marketing summit 2017
Andreas Dzumla — Google's Hogging Half Your Traffic: How to Get it Back
Surprising Facts about Google and 2017 SEO
Dominating the Long Tail | Digital Horizons Oct 2016
SEO Code-Breaking: How Smarter Content Leads to Better Search Rankings
SEO Tactics to Love vs. Leave
Helping customers find you online - Rand Fishkin at Business of Software Conf...
Theres no quick fix to your seo
Paid Search 2019 A5 Advertising
The Web Wonder In 40 Minutes
Google, SEO and Personalized Search
The Reason Behind Semantic SEO: Why does Google Avoid the Word PageRank?
Rider University SEO Presentation by Michael Fleischner
Optimizing For Google’s New Landscape And The Future Of Search
Sept. 28, 2011 webcast become an expert google searcher in an hour stephan ...
SearchCon 2016 | High Velocity Presentations
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
It Takes a Village Campaign Plan Book; Sidra Medicine
PPT
Introduction to consumer behavior(1).PPT
PDF
Deloitte contemporary marketing-trends-2025.pdf
DOCX
FCL vs. LCL Freight Forwarding An Ultimate Handbook for Logistics Experts.docx
PDF
CAP 9.- Building the Price Foundation.pdf
PPTX
APA Examples Reference Examples Style and
PPTX
Events Management Overview of Events Management
PDF
DigiBrandX: Crafting Identities That Resonate
PDF
Top-Rated Marketplaces to Buy Verified Cash App Accounts Safely.pdf
PDF
EX Kathmandu _Kailash Mansarovar Yatra 2025 by Nagarjuna Travels.pdf
PDF
Social Media Optimization Basic Introduction
PPTX
FINAL PPT strategic management lessons.pptx
PDF
Plastic Products-price poster holder pricing board-Loripos.pdf
PDF
Chapter 8,9.pdfVGGGCFDRGFDXCRFTGDSEDSFCTGHNHGBVHG
DOCX
IREV Platform: Future of Affiliate Marketing
PDF
Retaining SEO Rankings During Website Redesign.pdf
PPTX
1 percent Clicks, percent Traffic Loss-Your SEO Stack Isn’t Built for AI
PDF
Biography of Brady Beitlich
PPT
Market Segmentation and Positioning(3).ppt
PPTX
Mastering in Website Competitor Analysis
It Takes a Village Campaign Plan Book; Sidra Medicine
Introduction to consumer behavior(1).PPT
Deloitte contemporary marketing-trends-2025.pdf
FCL vs. LCL Freight Forwarding An Ultimate Handbook for Logistics Experts.docx
CAP 9.- Building the Price Foundation.pdf
APA Examples Reference Examples Style and
Events Management Overview of Events Management
DigiBrandX: Crafting Identities That Resonate
Top-Rated Marketplaces to Buy Verified Cash App Accounts Safely.pdf
EX Kathmandu _Kailash Mansarovar Yatra 2025 by Nagarjuna Travels.pdf
Social Media Optimization Basic Introduction
FINAL PPT strategic management lessons.pptx
Plastic Products-price poster holder pricing board-Loripos.pdf
Chapter 8,9.pdfVGGGCFDRGFDXCRFTGDSEDSFCTGHNHGBVHG
IREV Platform: Future of Affiliate Marketing
Retaining SEO Rankings During Website Redesign.pdf
1 percent Clicks, percent Traffic Loss-Your SEO Stack Isn’t Built for AI
Biography of Brady Beitlich
Market Segmentation and Positioning(3).ppt
Mastering in Website Competitor Analysis

Why the "New Keyword = New Page" Approach is Bonkers

Editor's Notes

  • #8: Robots tag removes the element of choice from Google – they can choose whether or not to use a canonical tag, but a robots noindex tag is far clearer
  • #10: Scour your site for search terms where Google doesn’t see the difference – and even if Google still does, ask whether they are really necessary or if two pages are serving the same purpose. If needed, the noindex tag is your best friend, but every site is better served by thinking about what content is necessary and making sure only that content is accessible.
  • #17: 0 above the fold to 4 above the fold, plus a video and an instant answer box, neither beyond the reach of any client or requiring paid media spend
  • #21: If that content can fit alongside your main content, it’s going to work harder for you – fit more naturally into the conversion journey while funnelling search authority via earned media links & coverage due to its value
  • #22: No matter the content – make sure it’s easy and obvious to move on to a conversion path
  • #29: Check your keyword targeting! Don’t target words that are semantically similar on the same pages – if you need to have those separate pages, think about which one should be in the index Think beyond keywords with your content – what does your audience want from you? What should you be telling them that isn’t specifically focused around the product or service that you offer, but which plays a part in their journey to you? Keep your eye on being the most useful resource online – only then will you be in a good place for the future