SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Fondly Collisions: Archival hierarchy 
and the Europeana Data Model 
Valentine Charles and Kerstin Arnold 
8th October 2014, DCMI2014, Austin
Overview 
 The Archives Portal Europe - Introduction 
• Projects and content 
• Standards and tools 
 Europeana - Introduction 
• Content and ecosystem 
 Europeana - Data models 
• From Europeana Semantic Elements (ESE) to the Europeana 
Data Model (EDM) 
• Semantic layer 
• Representing hierarchies
Overview 
 An example 
• Representation in EDM 
• How to get there - conversion in the Archives Portal Europe’s 
dashboard 
• From apeEAD to EDM - a comparison 
 Remaining challenges 
 Preview
The Archives Portal Europe 
 The projects behind 
● APEnet (2009-2012) with 13 partners (incl. Europeana), 
extended to 19 partners until the end of the project 
● APEx (2012-2015) with 29 partners, extended to currently 
33 partners 
 After the projects: Archives Portal Europe Foundation to 
maintain and enhance the portal, its network and its position 
within the European (digital) cultural heritage environment
The Archives Portal Europe 
 The current status 
● 30 countries represented, 27 providing content 
● 683 institutions, 435 providing content 
● more than 50M descriptive units in 335K+ EAD files, 
2M linked with digital archival objects 
● 1044 descriptions of records creators
The Archives Portal Europe 
 The use of standards - profiles for central use 
● apeEAD for finding aids, holdings guides and source guides 
● apeEAC-CPF (Encoded Archival Context - Corporate 
Bodies, 
Persons, and Families) for descriptions of records creators 
● EAG 2012 (Encoded Archival Guide) - for descriptions of 
archival institutions and their services 
● future addition: apeMETS (Metadata Encoding and 
Transmission Standard) and apeMETSRights for structured 
information on digital archival objects
The Archives Portal Europe 
 The use of standards - decentralised responsibility 
● local and central tools for conversion and validation of data 
● local and central tools for creation/edition of data (especially 
EAG 2012 and apeEAC-CPF) 
● central tool for delivery and processing within the Archives 
Portal Europe 
● central tool for conversion and delivery to Europeana
Europeana.eu, Europe’s cultural heritage portal 
32M objects from 2,200 galleries, museums, archives and libraries 
Text 
Image 
Video 
Sound 
3D 
CC
Europeana and its ecosystem 
Audiovisual 
collections 
National 
Aggregators 
Regional 
Aggregators 
Archives 
Thematic 
collections 
Libraries
Represent complex data structure: the challenge 
 Initial data model: Europeana Semantic Elements (ESE) and 
its difficult integration with EAD 
 ESE 
• flat model based on Dublin 
Core 
• item-centric model 
• no links between cultural 
heritage objects (CHO) or 
between objects and 
contextual entities 
 EAD 
• highly structured model 
• hierarchy containing 
descriptions of digital and 
non-digital items/objects 
• nested items/objects with 
references to contextual 
entities
A new data framework: Europeana Data 
Model (EDM) 
 A data model that re-uses several existing Semantic Web-based 
models 
 Adopt Semantic Web representation principles (RDF) 
• Re-use and mix different vocabularies together 
• Preserve original data and still allow for interoperability
EDM basic pattern 
 A data provider submits to Europeana a “bundle” of an object 
and its digital representation(s)
Connect Archives to the other domains 
 Create a “semantic layer” on top of cultural heritage objects
Representing hierarchies in EDM 
 Hierarchies in EDM can be built at the level of 
• ProvidedCHO 
• the hierarchy focuses on the description of the semantic structure of 
the object (fonds, series, subseries, file, item) 
• WebResources (images, scans) 
• hierarchies of the digitised representations of a ProvidedCHO 
• Contextual resources 
• hierarchies of “non-information resources” or contextual resources 
such as edm:Agent, edm:Place, edm:TimeSpan, edm:Concept, 
edm:Event
An example
An example - representation in EDM
An example - representation in EDM
Fondly Collisions: Archival hierarchy and the Europeana Data Model
Fondly Collisions: Archival hierarchy and the Europeana Data Model
An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM 
 quick note on future extensions 
● include apeEAC-CPF for conversion to edm:Agent 
● use apeMETS/apeMETSRights for more detailed input on 
digital archival objects, their relations and their rights status
An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
An example - apeEAD / fonds
An example - EDM / fonds
An example - EDM / fonds
An example - apeEAD / hierarchy
An example - EDM / hierarchy (I)
An example - EDM / hierarchy (II)
Fondly Collisions: Archival hierarchy and the Europeana Data Model
Some challenges remain 
 Representing hierarchies with one level missing metadata 
• when a missing ProvidedCHO is an inner node (i.e. it has 
children) it could imply losing information about the context of the 
children CHOs.
Some challenges remain 
 Representing hierarchies with one level missing a digital 
representation
Publishing data: for data consumers 
 Hierarchical data are available via 
• data.europeana.eu, Europeana Linked Data pilot 
• Europeana API 
• Structured data for search engines (Schema.org markups) 
• One of the challenges is to make developers understand a specific 
structure of the data.
Publishing data: for end-users 
 Displaying hierarchical objects has been Europeana’s biggest 
challenge! 
• Searching hierarchical objects 
• It should be possible 
• to make search queries on the objects contained in a 
hierarchy 
• to make search queries in all the levels of descriptions of an 
object 
• to search an object via information on its context 
• to allow a user to find the different objects of a hierarchy
Publishing data: for end-users 
 Presentation of the hierarchies 
• A user should be able to grasp a complex object as a whole and 
understand the relationships between the different objects, of 
which the hierarchy is composed. 
• An object should be always presented in context (digital 
representation and descriptive metadata if possible).
Preview!
Preview!
Thank you ! 
valentine.charles@europeana.eu 
k.arnold@bundesarchiv.de 
www.europeana.eu 
www. pro.europeana.eu 
www.archivesportaleurope.net 
www.apex-project.eu 
8th October 2014, DCMI2014, Austin

More Related Content

PDF
Mapping cross-­domain metadata to the Europeana Data Model (EDM) - EDM introd...
PDF
The Europeana Datamodel: A semantic layer on top of Cultural Heritage Objects
PPT
Validation of Europeana data: application profile, OWL ontology, or else?
PPT
EDM - American Art Collaborative LOD Meeting
PPT
LDBC 19 November 2013
PPT
Culture Hack panel SXSW 2013
PPT
Europeana and open data
PPT
W3C Library Linked Data Incubator Group - 2011
Mapping cross-­domain metadata to the Europeana Data Model (EDM) - EDM introd...
The Europeana Datamodel: A semantic layer on top of Cultural Heritage Objects
Validation of Europeana data: application profile, OWL ontology, or else?
EDM - American Art Collaborative LOD Meeting
LDBC 19 November 2013
Culture Hack panel SXSW 2013
Europeana and open data
W3C Library Linked Data Incubator Group - 2011

What's hot (20)

PDF
Designing a multilingual knowledge graph - DCMI2018
PPT
AAC Education Session
PPT
Linking data for Europeana
PDF
Alexandria winer20100623
PPT
Wikidata, a target for Europeana's semantic strategy - GLAM-WIKI 2015
PPT
Europeana, more than data aggregation?
PDF
Eun lre brussels_winer20100616
PPT
Harmony project - JISC Synthesis meeting 2001
PPT
EIFL 2014 - Linked Open Data
PPT
A portrait of Europeana as a Linked Open Data case
PPT
Europeana and Schema.org - DC2013
PPT
Europeana @ NISO Bibliographic Roadmap Meeting
PPT
Europeana and the relevance of the DM2E results
PPT
Mapping the European(a) metadata landscape
PPT
December 2, 2015: NISO/NFAIS Virtual Conference: Semantic Web: What's New and...
PPT
Europeana - American Art Collaborative LOD Meeting
PPT
Tutorial on Semantic Digital Libraries (WWW'2007)
PPT
Data modelling at Europeana and DM2E - SMW13
PDF
WWW2014 Tutorial: Online Learning & Linked Data - Lessons Learned
PDF
LoCloud: Local Cultural Heritage Online and in the Cloud
Designing a multilingual knowledge graph - DCMI2018
AAC Education Session
Linking data for Europeana
Alexandria winer20100623
Wikidata, a target for Europeana's semantic strategy - GLAM-WIKI 2015
Europeana, more than data aggregation?
Eun lre brussels_winer20100616
Harmony project - JISC Synthesis meeting 2001
EIFL 2014 - Linked Open Data
A portrait of Europeana as a Linked Open Data case
Europeana and Schema.org - DC2013
Europeana @ NISO Bibliographic Roadmap Meeting
Europeana and the relevance of the DM2E results
Mapping the European(a) metadata landscape
December 2, 2015: NISO/NFAIS Virtual Conference: Semantic Web: What's New and...
Europeana - American Art Collaborative LOD Meeting
Tutorial on Semantic Digital Libraries (WWW'2007)
Data modelling at Europeana and DM2E - SMW13
WWW2014 Tutorial: Online Learning & Linked Data - Lessons Learned
LoCloud: Local Cultural Heritage Online and in the Cloud
Ad

Viewers also liked (17)

PPT
2. Esercitazione. Culturaitalia ed Europeana
PPT
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Aubery Es...
PPT
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Jill Cousins
PPT
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Johan Oomen
PDF
A guide to using Europeana for education
PPTX
#Europeana4Education: final teachers’ workshop (February, 2017)
PDF
Europeana4Education at Open Education Week 2017 - webinar slides
PPT
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Lizzy Jongma
PPTX
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Uldis Zarins
PPTX
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Johan Oomen
PPT
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Uldis Zarins
PPTX
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Merete Sa...
PPTX
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Joke van ...
PPTX
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Eleanor K...
PPTX
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Aubery Es...
PPT
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Jill Cousins
PPTX
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Sergiu Go...
2. Esercitazione. Culturaitalia ed Europeana
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Aubery Es...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Jill Cousins
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Johan Oomen
A guide to using Europeana for education
#Europeana4Education: final teachers’ workshop (February, 2017)
Europeana4Education at Open Education Week 2017 - webinar slides
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Lizzy Jongma
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Uldis Zarins
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Johan Oomen
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Uldis Zarins
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Merete Sa...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Joke van ...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Eleanor K...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Aubery Es...
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Jill Cousins
Europeana Network Association Members Council Meeting, The Hague by Sergiu Go...
Ad

Similar to Fondly Collisions: Archival hierarchy and the Europeana Data Model (20)

PPTX
European databases in cultural heritage: making connections
PPTX
Connecting European Archaeology datasets: prospects and challenges
PPT
Open Data Masterclass - Europeana and LOD
PPT
Achieving Interoperability between the CARARE Schema for Monuments and Sites ...
PDF
Data quality in cultural heritage (meta)data
PPTX
Europeana as a Linked Data (Quality) case
PPTX
The Europeana Community: Semantics and Cultural Heritage Data
PDF
Europeana Creative. EDM Endpoint. Custom Views
PPTX
The Europeana Strategy and Linked Open Data
PDF
Europeana datainaction nov2012
PDF
The Europeana Data Model - TPDL2018
PPTX
Digital cultural heritage works and object description within the scope of Eu...
PDF
Achille Felicetti "Introduction to the Ariadne winter school and to the ARIAD...
PDF
Entity Management at Europeana - DCMI 2021
PDF
Valentine Charles: Linking cultural heritage with KOS: the Europeana example
PPT
Class 5-introto dl
PPT
Class 5-introto dl
PPT
Union catalogandknowledge engineering for teldap
PPTX
Linked Data for EuropeanaCultural Heritage: the Europeana approach
PPTX
Semantics and the Humanities: some lessons from my journey 2000-2012
European databases in cultural heritage: making connections
Connecting European Archaeology datasets: prospects and challenges
Open Data Masterclass - Europeana and LOD
Achieving Interoperability between the CARARE Schema for Monuments and Sites ...
Data quality in cultural heritage (meta)data
Europeana as a Linked Data (Quality) case
The Europeana Community: Semantics and Cultural Heritage Data
Europeana Creative. EDM Endpoint. Custom Views
The Europeana Strategy and Linked Open Data
Europeana datainaction nov2012
The Europeana Data Model - TPDL2018
Digital cultural heritage works and object description within the scope of Eu...
Achille Felicetti "Introduction to the Ariadne winter school and to the ARIAD...
Entity Management at Europeana - DCMI 2021
Valentine Charles: Linking cultural heritage with KOS: the Europeana example
Class 5-introto dl
Class 5-introto dl
Union catalogandknowledge engineering for teldap
Linked Data for EuropeanaCultural Heritage: the Europeana approach
Semantics and the Humanities: some lessons from my journey 2000-2012

More from Valentine Charles (9)

PPTX
Building a Framework for Semantic Cultural Heritage Data
PDF
When Semantics support Multilingual Access to Digital Cultural Heritage - the...
PDF
Evaluation of metadata enrichment practices in digital libraries:steps toward...
PPT
Europeana 1914-1918, User-Generated Content and Linked Open Data
PDF
Achieving interoperability between CARARE schema for monuments and sites and ...
PPT
Defining collections and creating their descriptions
PPT
Links, languages and semantics: linked data approaches in The European Libra...
PPT
Discovering libraries's gold through collection-level descriptions
PDF
The GLAMwiki toolset project
Building a Framework for Semantic Cultural Heritage Data
When Semantics support Multilingual Access to Digital Cultural Heritage - the...
Evaluation of metadata enrichment practices in digital libraries:steps toward...
Europeana 1914-1918, User-Generated Content and Linked Open Data
Achieving interoperability between CARARE schema for monuments and sites and ...
Defining collections and creating their descriptions
Links, languages and semantics: linked data approaches in The European Libra...
Discovering libraries's gold through collection-level descriptions
The GLAMwiki toolset project

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Moving the Public Sector (Government) to a Digital Adoption
PPTX
Database Infoormation System (DBIS).pptx
PDF
“Getting Started with Data Analytics Using R – Concepts, Tools & Case Studies”
PDF
TRAFFIC-MANAGEMENT-AND-ACCIDENT-INVESTIGATION-WITH-DRIVING-PDF-FILE.pdf
PPTX
IBA_Chapter_11_Slides_Final_Accessible.pptx
PPTX
Data_Analytics_and_PowerBI_Presentation.pptx
PDF
.pdf is not working space design for the following data for the following dat...
PPTX
Supervised vs unsupervised machine learning algorithms
PPTX
Acceptance and paychological effects of mandatory extra coach I classes.pptx
PPTX
advance b rammar.pptxfdgdfgdfsgdfgsdgfdfgdfgsdfgdfgdfg
PPT
Quality review (1)_presentation of this 21
PPTX
mbdjdhjjodule 5-1 rhfhhfjtjjhafbrhfnfbbfnb
PDF
Fluorescence-microscope_Botany_detailed content
PPTX
Business Ppt On Nestle.pptx huunnnhhgfvu
PDF
Mega Projects Data Mega Projects Data
PPTX
STUDY DESIGN details- Lt Col Maksud (21).pptx
PDF
Foundation of Data Science unit number two notes
PPT
Miokarditis (Inflamasi pada Otot Jantung)
PPTX
Computer network topology notes for revision
PPTX
climate analysis of Dhaka ,Banglades.pptx
Moving the Public Sector (Government) to a Digital Adoption
Database Infoormation System (DBIS).pptx
“Getting Started with Data Analytics Using R – Concepts, Tools & Case Studies”
TRAFFIC-MANAGEMENT-AND-ACCIDENT-INVESTIGATION-WITH-DRIVING-PDF-FILE.pdf
IBA_Chapter_11_Slides_Final_Accessible.pptx
Data_Analytics_and_PowerBI_Presentation.pptx
.pdf is not working space design for the following data for the following dat...
Supervised vs unsupervised machine learning algorithms
Acceptance and paychological effects of mandatory extra coach I classes.pptx
advance b rammar.pptxfdgdfgdfsgdfgsdgfdfgdfgsdfgdfgdfg
Quality review (1)_presentation of this 21
mbdjdhjjodule 5-1 rhfhhfjtjjhafbrhfnfbbfnb
Fluorescence-microscope_Botany_detailed content
Business Ppt On Nestle.pptx huunnnhhgfvu
Mega Projects Data Mega Projects Data
STUDY DESIGN details- Lt Col Maksud (21).pptx
Foundation of Data Science unit number two notes
Miokarditis (Inflamasi pada Otot Jantung)
Computer network topology notes for revision
climate analysis of Dhaka ,Banglades.pptx

Fondly Collisions: Archival hierarchy and the Europeana Data Model

  • 1. Fondly Collisions: Archival hierarchy and the Europeana Data Model Valentine Charles and Kerstin Arnold 8th October 2014, DCMI2014, Austin
  • 2. Overview  The Archives Portal Europe - Introduction • Projects and content • Standards and tools  Europeana - Introduction • Content and ecosystem  Europeana - Data models • From Europeana Semantic Elements (ESE) to the Europeana Data Model (EDM) • Semantic layer • Representing hierarchies
  • 3. Overview  An example • Representation in EDM • How to get there - conversion in the Archives Portal Europe’s dashboard • From apeEAD to EDM - a comparison  Remaining challenges  Preview
  • 4. The Archives Portal Europe  The projects behind ● APEnet (2009-2012) with 13 partners (incl. Europeana), extended to 19 partners until the end of the project ● APEx (2012-2015) with 29 partners, extended to currently 33 partners  After the projects: Archives Portal Europe Foundation to maintain and enhance the portal, its network and its position within the European (digital) cultural heritage environment
  • 5. The Archives Portal Europe  The current status ● 30 countries represented, 27 providing content ● 683 institutions, 435 providing content ● more than 50M descriptive units in 335K+ EAD files, 2M linked with digital archival objects ● 1044 descriptions of records creators
  • 6. The Archives Portal Europe  The use of standards - profiles for central use ● apeEAD for finding aids, holdings guides and source guides ● apeEAC-CPF (Encoded Archival Context - Corporate Bodies, Persons, and Families) for descriptions of records creators ● EAG 2012 (Encoded Archival Guide) - for descriptions of archival institutions and their services ● future addition: apeMETS (Metadata Encoding and Transmission Standard) and apeMETSRights for structured information on digital archival objects
  • 7. The Archives Portal Europe  The use of standards - decentralised responsibility ● local and central tools for conversion and validation of data ● local and central tools for creation/edition of data (especially EAG 2012 and apeEAC-CPF) ● central tool for delivery and processing within the Archives Portal Europe ● central tool for conversion and delivery to Europeana
  • 8. Europeana.eu, Europe’s cultural heritage portal 32M objects from 2,200 galleries, museums, archives and libraries Text Image Video Sound 3D CC
  • 9. Europeana and its ecosystem Audiovisual collections National Aggregators Regional Aggregators Archives Thematic collections Libraries
  • 10. Represent complex data structure: the challenge  Initial data model: Europeana Semantic Elements (ESE) and its difficult integration with EAD  ESE • flat model based on Dublin Core • item-centric model • no links between cultural heritage objects (CHO) or between objects and contextual entities  EAD • highly structured model • hierarchy containing descriptions of digital and non-digital items/objects • nested items/objects with references to contextual entities
  • 11. A new data framework: Europeana Data Model (EDM)  A data model that re-uses several existing Semantic Web-based models  Adopt Semantic Web representation principles (RDF) • Re-use and mix different vocabularies together • Preserve original data and still allow for interoperability
  • 12. EDM basic pattern  A data provider submits to Europeana a “bundle” of an object and its digital representation(s)
  • 13. Connect Archives to the other domains  Create a “semantic layer” on top of cultural heritage objects
  • 14. Representing hierarchies in EDM  Hierarchies in EDM can be built at the level of • ProvidedCHO • the hierarchy focuses on the description of the semantic structure of the object (fonds, series, subseries, file, item) • WebResources (images, scans) • hierarchies of the digitised representations of a ProvidedCHO • Contextual resources • hierarchies of “non-information resources” or contextual resources such as edm:Agent, edm:Place, edm:TimeSpan, edm:Concept, edm:Event
  • 16. An example - representation in EDM
  • 17. An example - representation in EDM
  • 20. An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
  • 21. An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
  • 22. An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
  • 23. An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
  • 24. An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
  • 25. An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
  • 26. An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
  • 27. An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
  • 28. An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM  quick note on future extensions ● include apeEAC-CPF for conversion to edm:Agent ● use apeMETS/apeMETSRights for more detailed input on digital archival objects, their relations and their rights status
  • 29. An example - Converting a finding aid to EDM
  • 30. An example - apeEAD / fonds
  • 31. An example - EDM / fonds
  • 32. An example - EDM / fonds
  • 33. An example - apeEAD / hierarchy
  • 34. An example - EDM / hierarchy (I)
  • 35. An example - EDM / hierarchy (II)
  • 37. Some challenges remain  Representing hierarchies with one level missing metadata • when a missing ProvidedCHO is an inner node (i.e. it has children) it could imply losing information about the context of the children CHOs.
  • 38. Some challenges remain  Representing hierarchies with one level missing a digital representation
  • 39. Publishing data: for data consumers  Hierarchical data are available via • data.europeana.eu, Europeana Linked Data pilot • Europeana API • Structured data for search engines (Schema.org markups) • One of the challenges is to make developers understand a specific structure of the data.
  • 40. Publishing data: for end-users  Displaying hierarchical objects has been Europeana’s biggest challenge! • Searching hierarchical objects • It should be possible • to make search queries on the objects contained in a hierarchy • to make search queries in all the levels of descriptions of an object • to search an object via information on its context • to allow a user to find the different objects of a hierarchy
  • 41. Publishing data: for end-users  Presentation of the hierarchies • A user should be able to grasp a complex object as a whole and understand the relationships between the different objects, of which the hierarchy is composed. • An object should be always presented in context (digital representation and descriptive metadata if possible).
  • 44. Thank you ! valentine.charles@europeana.eu k.arnold@bundesarchiv.de www.europeana.eu www. pro.europeana.eu www.archivesportaleurope.net www.apex-project.eu 8th October 2014, DCMI2014, Austin