SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Doing Agile vs. BEING Agile
The Product Value Team
Austin product camp 11   Agile - doing vs being
Eating the World
• 5 Billion Internet connected smartphones
• Sony/Nokia/… – Hardware companies
– (close to death or slaves)
• Disney/Pixar – software companies
• Financial Industry – software companies
• Amazon to Walmart – software companies with warehouses
• Fedex– software company with trucks
• Microsoft/Oracle – old software that needs rewriting
• Dishwashers (lasers!), rice cookers, refrigerators, cars,TV.
– Filled of software
• Defense/Construction/Energy Sectors
– Increasingly software & robots controlled with software
• US Government – World’s largest software development organization
Marc Andressen
WSJ 2011
Key Points
• Software is everywhere – products & services
– Just doing it competently is no longer enough
– Great products need to be the focus
• Agile is now standard best practice for software
development
– Many went in this direction long ago…
– Mostly it is helping, but many are doing it wrong…
• Guiding Agile teams is the next huge challenge
– Creativity of the ENTIRE team is essential
– But great products are rarely “designed by committee”
Process ?
Fad?
Methodology ?
Cult?
No Documentation
Framework ?
Approach ?
No Planning
No Architecture
Chaos
No Discipline
What is Agile ?
5
Original Research by Carol Dweck
Growth Mindset
Ability can grow
Develop Ability
Leads to a
desire to
learn
Fixed Mindset
Ability is inherent and static
Demonstrate Ability
Leads to a
desire to look
good/smart
Success
A mindset is the
established set of
attitudes held by
someone
Looking good and avoiding
challenges and obstacles
because it is a risk for failure
and will make them look bad.
Stick to what they know and
can do and as a result achieve
less than their full potential.
Feedback and criticism is
personal as it impacts self-
image.
They don’t change or improve
much with time, if at all, and so
to them this confirms that “they
are as they are”.
Embracing challenges
because they will learn
something new or they will fail
and that is an opportunity to
learn also.
Not afraid to put lots of effort to
learn and master something
new
Feedback and criticism is not
about them but about current
capabilities
View feedback as a source of
new information that
encourages them to keep
learning and improving.
6
Success Delivering
Software
Aim to look good by delivering
planned results
Assumes that customer knows
exactly what they want
therefore tries to fix the
requirements (change is not
desired)
Assumes that developers
know exactly how to build it
(and learning is punished)
Assumes and hopes that
nothing will change along the
way
Aim to learn and deliver
desired results
Allows the customer to learn
and discover what they want
when they see it and
experience it. (Change is
welcome)
The developers discovers how
to build it when they build it
(learning is rewarded)
Many things change along the
way
Agile Mindset
Ability can grow
Develop Ability
Leads to a
desire to
learn
Leads to a
desire to look
good/smart
Aspire towards
Fixed Mindset
Ability is inherent and static
Demonstrate Ability
7
A mindset is the established set of
attitudes held by someone
• Learn through Discovery
• Collaboration
• Failing Early
• Seeking Feedback for learning
• Strive for Continuous Delivery
• Focus on Value
Agile is a mindset defined by values guided by
principles and manifested through many different
practices
8
Agile is a mindset defined by values guided by
principles and manifested through many different
practices
9
Internalizing the
Mindset, values, and
principles then applying
the right practices and
tailoring them to different
situations as they arise
Learning the practices
and applying them
without know the
mindset and principles
to know when to tailor
and how to select the
appropriate practices
Being Agile Doing Agile
10
Defined Process Empirical Process
Management Approach:
Coordination and Control
Management Approach:
Inspect and Adapt
Predictable Outcome Non-Predictable Outcome
Discovery Needed
High Uncertainty
Creativity Needed
High Change Rates
No Discovery
Low Uncertainty
No Creativity
Low Change Rates
The process needs to provide true visibility as well as be
lightweight, flexible and nimble enough to constantly adapt.
11
Value Driven Customer Focus
Resources
Calendar Time
Scope
Value Driven
12
Welcoming change
by constantly
reprioritizing to
deliver highest
value items first.
Superman/Superwoman needed?
• Expectations continue to expand
– Need a Persuasive Leader
– Need Technical Depth
– Need Sales Skills
– Need Writing Skills
– Accurate Customer Proxy
– Good Researcher
– Good Analyst
– Internal Communication
• Responsibility without Authority?
– Living in the Matrix
• Responsible for the product
• Rarely directs resources
The Value Team Role
• Vision to reality
• Collaborative effort is essential
– Agile techniques supportive
– PO role almost unworkable as defined
• Instead of Manager or Controller think Director
or Auteur.
– A team is needed
“The quality of any collaborative creative endeavor tends to approach
the level of taste of whoever is in charge” – John Gruber
The Business Analyst Role
15
• Often criticized by Agile-ists
– a separate camp pulling in a different direction
• Can be invaluable parts the Value Team
• Key is for the Value Team to be in sync
• Business Analysts must explain both ways
– Business to Programmers
– Technical to Business decision makers
• BA authority “on loan” from Product Owners
Value Team New Roles
16
• Value Team Facilitator
– Make sure the team a team
– Ensure responsiveness and output
– All voices/inputs considered
• Value Director or Product Owner
– Keeper of the Vision – motivator
– Ultimate tie breaker/decision maker
• Needed a lot = smell
– Sets the high level priorities
Key Concepts for Products
• Getting on the same page
– Classic
• Positioning – Reis and Trout
• Crossing the Chasm – Moore
• Innovator’s Dilemma – Christenson
• Cluetrain Manifesto – Locke, Searls, et al.
– New(er) Thinking
• Global Opportunities – Prahalad, Ravel, et al.
• Four steps to the Epiphany – Stephen Blank
• The Lean Startup – Eric Ries
• Product Development Flow – Donald Reinertsen
• Continuous Delivery – Jez Humble
Austin product camp 11   Agile - doing vs being

More Related Content

PDF
Being vs Doing agile
PPTX
Agile Truths and Misconceptions Exposed
PPTX
Agile in the Federal Government
PPTX
The Perfect Product Owner
PDF
The Agile Way
PDF
Let's Build a Product Development Organization!
PDF
Agile: the Good, the Bad and the Ugly - Webinar by Clarke Ching Agile - Septe...
PPTX
Getting started right
Being vs Doing agile
Agile Truths and Misconceptions Exposed
Agile in the Federal Government
The Perfect Product Owner
The Agile Way
Let's Build a Product Development Organization!
Agile: the Good, the Bad and the Ugly - Webinar by Clarke Ching Agile - Septe...
Getting started right

What's hot (20)

PDF
The Agile Manager Mindshift - Paul Ellarby
PPTX
Group hug - Implementing Agile Across Multiple Teams
PDF
Lean Discovery, Agile Delivery & the DevOps Mindset
PDF
Intro to Scrum - Heidi Araya
PDF
Intro to Kanban - Heidi Araya
PDF
Intro to Agile - Heidi Araya
PPTX
What to Look for in a ScrumMaster
PPTX
Edwin Dando (Assurity Consulting)
PPTX
Gavin Coughlan (Boost)
PDF
Why is it so hard? Agile adoption anti-patterns, how to spot them and what to...
PDF
Artem Bykovets: Agile Leader is coming to the pub Team, what to start from?
PPTX
The Perfect Product Owner
PDF
6- Agile.engine - Asad safari
PPTX
Not afraid of the SAFe big bad wolf - Yuval Yeret
PDF
Agile Business Transformation
PPTX
The Right Product Owner
PPT
Salesforce Agile Transformation - Agile 2007 Conference
PPTX
The Ultimate Agile Mix Tape (Agile 2017)
PDF
Harness Tribal Knowledge With Confluence Questions - Kim Wall
PPTX
There is No Spoon: Fostering an Agile Culture
The Agile Manager Mindshift - Paul Ellarby
Group hug - Implementing Agile Across Multiple Teams
Lean Discovery, Agile Delivery & the DevOps Mindset
Intro to Scrum - Heidi Araya
Intro to Kanban - Heidi Araya
Intro to Agile - Heidi Araya
What to Look for in a ScrumMaster
Edwin Dando (Assurity Consulting)
Gavin Coughlan (Boost)
Why is it so hard? Agile adoption anti-patterns, how to spot them and what to...
Artem Bykovets: Agile Leader is coming to the pub Team, what to start from?
The Perfect Product Owner
6- Agile.engine - Asad safari
Not afraid of the SAFe big bad wolf - Yuval Yeret
Agile Business Transformation
The Right Product Owner
Salesforce Agile Transformation - Agile 2007 Conference
The Ultimate Agile Mix Tape (Agile 2017)
Harness Tribal Knowledge With Confluence Questions - Kim Wall
There is No Spoon: Fostering an Agile Culture
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

PPTX
Be agile about agile
PPTX
Christchurch Agile Professionals Network Presentation: Lessons Learned Implem...
PPT
Migratie veroorzaakt niet alleen problemen
PDF
Agile Isn't Enough: Revolution Over Transformation
PPT
Your Team Is Not Agile If...........
PDF
0. review. 린과 애자일 개발
PPTX
Occupational engagement, doing, being, becoming
PPTX
Be agile
PPTX
Don't "Do" Agile, Be Agile
PDF
Sketching, Wireframing, Prototyping - How to Be Agile and Avoid Half-Baked Us...
PPT
Doing Agile Isnt The Same As Being Agile
PPTX
Doing Agile Being Agile - Agile Mississauga Meetup Kick off Event
PPTX
Cultural Change with Spiral Dynamics to transform from "doing agile" to "bein...
PDF
People over Process
PPTX
Understanding and Working with Agile Culture - PMI-SOC
PDF
Bimodal IT - Mode 2 Evolution Roadmap v12
PPT
Agile project management framework
PDF
Agile Project Management - An introduction to Agile and the new PMI-ACP
PPTX
Introduction to Agile Testing
PDF
Agile Doesn't Work - Agile Twin Cities
Be agile about agile
Christchurch Agile Professionals Network Presentation: Lessons Learned Implem...
Migratie veroorzaakt niet alleen problemen
Agile Isn't Enough: Revolution Over Transformation
Your Team Is Not Agile If...........
0. review. 린과 애자일 개발
Occupational engagement, doing, being, becoming
Be agile
Don't "Do" Agile, Be Agile
Sketching, Wireframing, Prototyping - How to Be Agile and Avoid Half-Baked Us...
Doing Agile Isnt The Same As Being Agile
Doing Agile Being Agile - Agile Mississauga Meetup Kick off Event
Cultural Change with Spiral Dynamics to transform from "doing agile" to "bein...
People over Process
Understanding and Working with Agile Culture - PMI-SOC
Bimodal IT - Mode 2 Evolution Roadmap v12
Agile project management framework
Agile Project Management - An introduction to Agile and the new PMI-ACP
Introduction to Agile Testing
Agile Doesn't Work - Agile Twin Cities
Ad

Similar to Austin product camp 11 Agile - doing vs being (20)

PDF
Good agile / Bad agile: Proving the value of Agile to a skeptical organization
PPTX
Exec Leadership workshop
PPTX
Agility In Innovation - Delivering Breakthrough Products
PDF
Andy van der Gugten, Agile Tauranga 2018 Presentation
PDF
Agile = scrum = no project managers
PDF
Solit 2014, Agile ValueTeam, учимся понимать Scrum, Семенченко Антон
PDF
Adaptive Leadership: Accelerating Enterprise Agility
PDF
A Practical Approach to Agile Adoption - Case Studies from Egypt by Amr Noama...
PPTX
Agile = scrum = no Project Managers!
PPTX
The relevancy of Agile and Agility to Project Management
PDF
about agility
PDF
Agile transformation in a large financial institution
PDF
Ewan developing the agile mindset for organizational agility
PDF
Agile Transformation White Paper
PDF
5590 agile transformation_white_paper_3_1
PDF
Introduction to the International Consortium for Agile (ICAgile)
PPTX
BA Skills and Competency
PDF
Developers Developers Developers
PDF
Five Common Challenges With Agile Transformation - Anikh Subhan - Scrum Day L...
Good agile / Bad agile: Proving the value of Agile to a skeptical organization
Exec Leadership workshop
Agility In Innovation - Delivering Breakthrough Products
Andy van der Gugten, Agile Tauranga 2018 Presentation
Agile = scrum = no project managers
Solit 2014, Agile ValueTeam, учимся понимать Scrum, Семенченко Антон
Adaptive Leadership: Accelerating Enterprise Agility
A Practical Approach to Agile Adoption - Case Studies from Egypt by Amr Noama...
Agile = scrum = no Project Managers!
The relevancy of Agile and Agility to Project Management
about agility
Agile transformation in a large financial institution
Ewan developing the agile mindset for organizational agility
Agile Transformation White Paper
5590 agile transformation_white_paper_3_1
Introduction to the International Consortium for Agile (ICAgile)
BA Skills and Competency
Developers Developers Developers
Five Common Challenges With Agile Transformation - Anikh Subhan - Scrum Day L...

More from Kelly Looney (10)

PPTX
How do you eat a whale velocity 2017
PPTX
How do you eat a whale? cloud expo 2017
PDF
How to eat a whale?
PPTX
DevOps Workshops Fall 2016
PPTX
DevOps Days Ohio
PPTX
Continuous Delivery Decision points
PDF
Gartner Infrastructure and Operations Summit Berlin 2015 - DevOps Journey
PDF
The DevOps Journey at bwin.party
PDF
Product Pricing: What your pricing says about you
PPT
Product Negatives to Positives
How do you eat a whale velocity 2017
How do you eat a whale? cloud expo 2017
How to eat a whale?
DevOps Workshops Fall 2016
DevOps Days Ohio
Continuous Delivery Decision points
Gartner Infrastructure and Operations Summit Berlin 2015 - DevOps Journey
The DevOps Journey at bwin.party
Product Pricing: What your pricing says about you
Product Negatives to Positives

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
CIFDAQ's Market Insight: SEC Turns Pro Crypto
PDF
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
PDF
Encapsulation_ Review paper, used for researhc scholars
PDF
Diabetes mellitus diagnosis method based random forest with bat algorithm
PDF
Electronic commerce courselecture one. Pdf
PPTX
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
PPTX
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
PPTX
KOM of Painting work and Equipment Insulation REV00 update 25-dec.pptx
PPTX
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity
PDF
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
PDF
Advanced methodologies resolving dimensionality complications for autism neur...
PDF
Chapter 3 Spatial Domain Image Processing.pdf
PDF
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
PDF
Encapsulation theory and applications.pdf
PPTX
PA Analog/Digital System: The Backbone of Modern Surveillance and Communication
PDF
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
PDF
Spectral efficient network and resource selection model in 5G networks
PDF
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
PDF
Unlocking AI with Model Context Protocol (MCP)
PPTX
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx
CIFDAQ's Market Insight: SEC Turns Pro Crypto
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
Encapsulation_ Review paper, used for researhc scholars
Diabetes mellitus diagnosis method based random forest with bat algorithm
Electronic commerce courselecture one. Pdf
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
KOM of Painting work and Equipment Insulation REV00 update 25-dec.pptx
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
Advanced methodologies resolving dimensionality complications for autism neur...
Chapter 3 Spatial Domain Image Processing.pdf
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
Encapsulation theory and applications.pdf
PA Analog/Digital System: The Backbone of Modern Surveillance and Communication
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
Spectral efficient network and resource selection model in 5G networks
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
Unlocking AI with Model Context Protocol (MCP)
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx

Austin product camp 11 Agile - doing vs being

  • 1. Doing Agile vs. BEING Agile The Product Value Team
  • 3. Eating the World • 5 Billion Internet connected smartphones • Sony/Nokia/… – Hardware companies – (close to death or slaves) • Disney/Pixar – software companies • Financial Industry – software companies • Amazon to Walmart – software companies with warehouses • Fedex– software company with trucks • Microsoft/Oracle – old software that needs rewriting • Dishwashers (lasers!), rice cookers, refrigerators, cars,TV. – Filled of software • Defense/Construction/Energy Sectors – Increasingly software & robots controlled with software • US Government – World’s largest software development organization Marc Andressen WSJ 2011
  • 4. Key Points • Software is everywhere – products & services – Just doing it competently is no longer enough – Great products need to be the focus • Agile is now standard best practice for software development – Many went in this direction long ago… – Mostly it is helping, but many are doing it wrong… • Guiding Agile teams is the next huge challenge – Creativity of the ENTIRE team is essential – But great products are rarely “designed by committee”
  • 5. Process ? Fad? Methodology ? Cult? No Documentation Framework ? Approach ? No Planning No Architecture Chaos No Discipline What is Agile ? 5
  • 6. Original Research by Carol Dweck Growth Mindset Ability can grow Develop Ability Leads to a desire to learn Fixed Mindset Ability is inherent and static Demonstrate Ability Leads to a desire to look good/smart Success A mindset is the established set of attitudes held by someone Looking good and avoiding challenges and obstacles because it is a risk for failure and will make them look bad. Stick to what they know and can do and as a result achieve less than their full potential. Feedback and criticism is personal as it impacts self- image. They don’t change or improve much with time, if at all, and so to them this confirms that “they are as they are”. Embracing challenges because they will learn something new or they will fail and that is an opportunity to learn also. Not afraid to put lots of effort to learn and master something new Feedback and criticism is not about them but about current capabilities View feedback as a source of new information that encourages them to keep learning and improving. 6
  • 7. Success Delivering Software Aim to look good by delivering planned results Assumes that customer knows exactly what they want therefore tries to fix the requirements (change is not desired) Assumes that developers know exactly how to build it (and learning is punished) Assumes and hopes that nothing will change along the way Aim to learn and deliver desired results Allows the customer to learn and discover what they want when they see it and experience it. (Change is welcome) The developers discovers how to build it when they build it (learning is rewarded) Many things change along the way Agile Mindset Ability can grow Develop Ability Leads to a desire to learn Leads to a desire to look good/smart Aspire towards Fixed Mindset Ability is inherent and static Demonstrate Ability 7
  • 8. A mindset is the established set of attitudes held by someone • Learn through Discovery • Collaboration • Failing Early • Seeking Feedback for learning • Strive for Continuous Delivery • Focus on Value Agile is a mindset defined by values guided by principles and manifested through many different practices 8
  • 9. Agile is a mindset defined by values guided by principles and manifested through many different practices 9
  • 10. Internalizing the Mindset, values, and principles then applying the right practices and tailoring them to different situations as they arise Learning the practices and applying them without know the mindset and principles to know when to tailor and how to select the appropriate practices Being Agile Doing Agile 10
  • 11. Defined Process Empirical Process Management Approach: Coordination and Control Management Approach: Inspect and Adapt Predictable Outcome Non-Predictable Outcome Discovery Needed High Uncertainty Creativity Needed High Change Rates No Discovery Low Uncertainty No Creativity Low Change Rates The process needs to provide true visibility as well as be lightweight, flexible and nimble enough to constantly adapt. 11
  • 12. Value Driven Customer Focus Resources Calendar Time Scope Value Driven 12 Welcoming change by constantly reprioritizing to deliver highest value items first.
  • 13. Superman/Superwoman needed? • Expectations continue to expand – Need a Persuasive Leader – Need Technical Depth – Need Sales Skills – Need Writing Skills – Accurate Customer Proxy – Good Researcher – Good Analyst – Internal Communication • Responsibility without Authority? – Living in the Matrix • Responsible for the product • Rarely directs resources
  • 14. The Value Team Role • Vision to reality • Collaborative effort is essential – Agile techniques supportive – PO role almost unworkable as defined • Instead of Manager or Controller think Director or Auteur. – A team is needed “The quality of any collaborative creative endeavor tends to approach the level of taste of whoever is in charge” – John Gruber
  • 15. The Business Analyst Role 15 • Often criticized by Agile-ists – a separate camp pulling in a different direction • Can be invaluable parts the Value Team • Key is for the Value Team to be in sync • Business Analysts must explain both ways – Business to Programmers – Technical to Business decision makers • BA authority “on loan” from Product Owners
  • 16. Value Team New Roles 16 • Value Team Facilitator – Make sure the team a team – Ensure responsiveness and output – All voices/inputs considered • Value Director or Product Owner – Keeper of the Vision – motivator – Ultimate tie breaker/decision maker • Needed a lot = smell – Sets the high level priorities
  • 17. Key Concepts for Products • Getting on the same page – Classic • Positioning – Reis and Trout • Crossing the Chasm – Moore • Innovator’s Dilemma – Christenson • Cluetrain Manifesto – Locke, Searls, et al. – New(er) Thinking • Global Opportunities – Prahalad, Ravel, et al. • Four steps to the Epiphany – Stephen Blank • The Lean Startup – Eric Ries • Product Development Flow – Donald Reinertsen • Continuous Delivery – Jez Humble

Editor's Notes

  • #4: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424053111903480904576512250915629460.html#articleTabs=articleThis article provides the primary background needed present this slide. Might talk about Andreessen a bit.The overall point is that nearly every industry and product is being fundamentally changed by software. The ability to create software has become a critical part of competiveness to an almost universal degree.One final Looney opinion: Much of the history of IT has been about reaching a goal on competently built software, reliably delivered with consistent quality. It’s not clear that goal is good enough anymore…Your software has to be better than your competition and quite likely has to be one of the things to set your product apart.
  • #6: Emphasize here that Agile is NOT a process, but there are agile processes