Content Recommendation through
Semantic Annotation of User
Reviews and Linked Data
Iacopo Vagliano, ZBW Kiel
Diego Monti, Politecnico di Torino
Maurizio Morisio, Politecnico di Torino
Ansgar Scherp, ZBW Kiel
K-CAP 2017, Austin, TX, USA
1
Recommender Systems
• Recommender systems
suggest items
– 80% of movies watched
on Netflix from
recommendations1
– 60% of video clicks from
recommendations in
YouTube2
– Typically based on rating
2
“Which movie to watch?”
1. Gomez-Uribe & Hunt. ŒThe netflƒix recommender system: Algorithms, business value, and innovation. ACM
TMIS 6, 4 (2016), 13.
2. Davidson et al. ThŒe YouTube Video Recommendation System. In: RecSys ’10. ACM, NY, USA, pp. 293–296
User Reviews
• More expressive than
ratings (multi-faceted
users’ opinions)
• May reveal connections
among items
3
The visual pattern
also has some
references to the
Kubrick´s „Odissey“
and they are pleasing
to the eye
A review of „Interstellar“
Goals
• Extract information from user reviews and
discover additional knowledge from Linked
Data
• Increase the diversity of recommendations
• Increase the novelty of recommendations
4
Annotating and Discovering Entities
5
The visual pattern
also has some
references to the
Kubrick´s „Odissey“
and they are pleasing
to the eye
dbr:Stanley_Kubrick
dbr:2001:_A_Space_Odyssey
dbr:Full_Metal_Jacket
dbr:A_Clockwork_Orange
dbo:Film
dbp:is_director_of
rdf:typedbo:Person
A review of
„Interstellar“
SemRevRec
• Annotated and
discovery entities
feeding
• Generation of
candidate
recommendations
and ranking
• Independence from
the knowledge
base
6
Recommendation
7
dbr:Stanley_Kubrick
dbr:2001:_A_Space_Odyssey
dbr:Full_Metal_Jacket
dbr:A_Clockwork_Orange
dbo:Film
dbp:is_director_of
rdf:type
dbo:Person
dbr:Interstellar
Ranking
• Frequency of entities in the reviews
• Interlinking of entities
– Between a discovered entity and its origin
– Between each candidate recommendation and
the initial item
8
Results - Books
• Top-10 recommendations
• Ratings from Library Things
• Reviews from Library Things
9
Algorithm Precision Recall nDCG EBN Diversity
SemRevRec 0.0530 0.0530 0.0536 0.1946 0.9118
SPrank 0.0379 0.0346 0.0337 0.1562 0.8037
ItemKNN 0.0620 0.0564 0.0662 1.4956 0.2259
BPR 0.0862 0.0817 0.0895 0.6043 0.7177
Popular 0.0423 0.0343 0.0447 1.6034 0.6483
Results - Movies
• Top-10 recommendations
• Ratings from Movielens 1M
• Reviews from IMDb
10
Algorithm Precision Recall nDCG EBN Diversity
SemRevRec 0.0857 0.0561 0.0686 0.7820 0.2431
SPrank 0.0445 0.0254 0.0280 0.8813 0.1612
ItemKNN 0.1626 0.1105 0.1302 2.6846 0.0696
BPR 0.2347 0.1737 0.1930 1.8358 0.1769
Popular 0.1325 0.0840 0.0969 2.7439 0.1412
Results - Music
• Top-10 recommendations
• Ratings from HotRec 2011 LastFM
• Reviews from Amazon
11
Algorithm Precision Recall nDCG EBN Diversity
SemRevRec 0.0536 0.0549 0.0502 0.2411 0.9329
SPrank 0.0156 0.0158 0.0176 0.1834 0.9077
ItemKNN 0.1392 0.1428 0.1720 1.6023 0.4730
BPR 0.1545 0.1583 0.1808 0.9404 0.6547
Popular 0.0686 0.0703 0.0791 2.0360 0.6519
Conclusions
• Extract information from user reviews and
discover additional knowledge from Linked
Data
• Increase the diversity of recommendations
• Increase the novelty of recommendations
12MOVING is funded by the EU Horizon 2020 Programme under the project number INSO-4-2015: 693092
i.vagliano@zbw.eu @maponaso
More detailed results at https://arxiv.org/abs/1709.09973

More Related Content

PPTX
Олександр Обєдніков “Рекомендательные системы”
PPTX
BOOK RECALL TYPPPPPPBBBBBBBBBHHHHHHHHHHHHY
PDF
Recommender systems
PDF
Building a Recommender systems by Vivek Murugesan - Technical Architect at Cr...
PPTX
535701365-Project-on-Movie-Recommendation.pptx
PPTX
Recommender system
PPT
Online social network based object recommendation system
PDF
One Stop Recommendation
Олександр Обєдніков “Рекомендательные системы”
BOOK RECALL TYPPPPPPBBBBBBBBBHHHHHHHHHHHHY
Recommender systems
Building a Recommender systems by Vivek Murugesan - Technical Architect at Cr...
535701365-Project-on-Movie-Recommendation.pptx
Recommender system
Online social network based object recommendation system
One Stop Recommendation

Similar to Content Recommendation through Semantic Annotation of User Reviews and Linked Data (20)

PPTX
Collaborative Filtering Recommendation System
PPTX
Design Recommender systems from scratch
PDF
Recommender Systems in the Linked Data era
PDF
Recsys 2016
PDF
Machine learning advanced applications
PDF
Recommender Systems and Linked Open Data
PPTX
Recommendation system (1).pptx
PDF
recommendationsystem1-221109055232-c8b46131.pdf
PDF
IRJET- Rating based Recommedation System for Web Service
PDF
Recommendation systems
PDF
VIT336 – Recommender System - Unit 3.pdf
PDF
Recommendation Systems
PDF
Recommendation System using Machine Learning Techniques
PDF
SEMLIB Final Conference | DERI presentation
PPTX
Practical Recommendation System - Scalable Machine Learning
PDF
Further enhancements of recommender systems using deep learning
PDF
A Neural Network-Inspired Approach For Improved And True Movie Recommendations
PDF
IRJET- Hybrid Recommendation System for Movies
PDF
IRJET- Searching an Optimal Algorithm for Movie Recommendation System
PPTX
Recommenders Systems
Collaborative Filtering Recommendation System
Design Recommender systems from scratch
Recommender Systems in the Linked Data era
Recsys 2016
Machine learning advanced applications
Recommender Systems and Linked Open Data
Recommendation system (1).pptx
recommendationsystem1-221109055232-c8b46131.pdf
IRJET- Rating based Recommedation System for Web Service
Recommendation systems
VIT336 – Recommender System - Unit 3.pdf
Recommendation Systems
Recommendation System using Machine Learning Techniques
SEMLIB Final Conference | DERI presentation
Practical Recommendation System - Scalable Machine Learning
Further enhancements of recommender systems using deep learning
A Neural Network-Inspired Approach For Improved And True Movie Recommendations
IRJET- Hybrid Recommendation System for Movies
IRJET- Searching an Optimal Algorithm for Movie Recommendation System
Recommenders Systems
Ad

More from Iacopo Vagliano (7)

PDF
Interpretable and Continuous Prediction of Acute Kidney Injury in the Intensi...
PDF
Training Researchers with the MOVING Platform
PDF
Using Adversarial Autoencoders for Multi-Modal Automatic Playlist Continuation
PDF
Content Recommendation Through Linked Data
PDF
ReDyAl: A Dynamic Recommendation Algorithm based on Linked Data
PDF
DBpedia Mobile Explorer
PDF
Linked Data-Driven Smart Spaces
Interpretable and Continuous Prediction of Acute Kidney Injury in the Intensi...
Training Researchers with the MOVING Platform
Using Adversarial Autoencoders for Multi-Modal Automatic Playlist Continuation
Content Recommendation Through Linked Data
ReDyAl: A Dynamic Recommendation Algorithm based on Linked Data
DBpedia Mobile Explorer
Linked Data-Driven Smart Spaces
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
SlidesGDGoCxRAIS about Google Dialogflow and NotebookLM.pdf
PDF
Exploring VPS Hosting Trends for SMBs in 2025
PPTX
Top Website Bugs That Hurt User Experience – And How Expert Web Design Fixes
PDF
Exploring The Internet Of Things(IOT).ppt
PDF
Understand the Gitlab_presentation_task.pdf
PPTX
TITLE DEFENSE entitle the impact of social media on education
DOCX
Powerful Ways AIRCONNECT INFOSYSTEMS Pvt Ltd Enhances IT Infrastructure in In...
PDF
BIOCHEM CH2 OVERVIEW OF MICROBIOLOGY.pdf
PPT
FIRE PREVENTION AND CONTROL PLAN- LUS.FM.MQ.OM.UTM.PLN.00014.ppt
PPT
12 Things That Make People Trust a Website Instantly
PDF
Course Overview and Agenda cloud security
PPTX
IPCNA VIRTUAL CLASSES INTERMEDIATE 6 PROJECT.pptx
PPTX
Mathew Digital SEO Checklist Guidlines 2025
PPT
415456121-Jiwratrwecdtwfdsfwgdwedvwe dbwsdjsadca-EVN.ppt
PDF
Lean-Manufacturing-Tools-Techniques-and-How-To-Use-Them.pdf
PDF
Alethe Consulting Corporate Profile and Solution Aproach
PDF
📍 LABUAN4D EXCLUSIVE SERVER STAR GAMING ASIA NO.1 TERPOPULER DI INDONESIA ! 🌟
PDF
si manuel quezon at mga nagawa sa bansang pilipinas
PPTX
module 1-Part 1.pptxdddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd
PDF
Smart Home Technology for Health Monitoring (www.kiu.ac.ug)
SlidesGDGoCxRAIS about Google Dialogflow and NotebookLM.pdf
Exploring VPS Hosting Trends for SMBs in 2025
Top Website Bugs That Hurt User Experience – And How Expert Web Design Fixes
Exploring The Internet Of Things(IOT).ppt
Understand the Gitlab_presentation_task.pdf
TITLE DEFENSE entitle the impact of social media on education
Powerful Ways AIRCONNECT INFOSYSTEMS Pvt Ltd Enhances IT Infrastructure in In...
BIOCHEM CH2 OVERVIEW OF MICROBIOLOGY.pdf
FIRE PREVENTION AND CONTROL PLAN- LUS.FM.MQ.OM.UTM.PLN.00014.ppt
12 Things That Make People Trust a Website Instantly
Course Overview and Agenda cloud security
IPCNA VIRTUAL CLASSES INTERMEDIATE 6 PROJECT.pptx
Mathew Digital SEO Checklist Guidlines 2025
415456121-Jiwratrwecdtwfdsfwgdwedvwe dbwsdjsadca-EVN.ppt
Lean-Manufacturing-Tools-Techniques-and-How-To-Use-Them.pdf
Alethe Consulting Corporate Profile and Solution Aproach
📍 LABUAN4D EXCLUSIVE SERVER STAR GAMING ASIA NO.1 TERPOPULER DI INDONESIA ! 🌟
si manuel quezon at mga nagawa sa bansang pilipinas
module 1-Part 1.pptxdddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd
Smart Home Technology for Health Monitoring (www.kiu.ac.ug)

Content Recommendation through Semantic Annotation of User Reviews and Linked Data

  • 1. Content Recommendation through Semantic Annotation of User Reviews and Linked Data Iacopo Vagliano, ZBW Kiel Diego Monti, Politecnico di Torino Maurizio Morisio, Politecnico di Torino Ansgar Scherp, ZBW Kiel K-CAP 2017, Austin, TX, USA 1
  • 2. Recommender Systems • Recommender systems suggest items – 80% of movies watched on Netflix from recommendations1 – 60% of video clicks from recommendations in YouTube2 – Typically based on rating 2 “Which movie to watch?” 1. Gomez-Uribe & Hunt. ŒThe netflƒix recommender system: Algorithms, business value, and innovation. ACM TMIS 6, 4 (2016), 13. 2. Davidson et al. ThŒe YouTube Video Recommendation System. In: RecSys ’10. ACM, NY, USA, pp. 293–296
  • 3. User Reviews • More expressive than ratings (multi-faceted users’ opinions) • May reveal connections among items 3 The visual pattern also has some references to the Kubrick´s „Odissey“ and they are pleasing to the eye A review of „Interstellar“
  • 4. Goals • Extract information from user reviews and discover additional knowledge from Linked Data • Increase the diversity of recommendations • Increase the novelty of recommendations 4
  • 5. Annotating and Discovering Entities 5 The visual pattern also has some references to the Kubrick´s „Odissey“ and they are pleasing to the eye dbr:Stanley_Kubrick dbr:2001:_A_Space_Odyssey dbr:Full_Metal_Jacket dbr:A_Clockwork_Orange dbo:Film dbp:is_director_of rdf:typedbo:Person A review of „Interstellar“
  • 6. SemRevRec • Annotated and discovery entities feeding • Generation of candidate recommendations and ranking • Independence from the knowledge base 6
  • 8. Ranking • Frequency of entities in the reviews • Interlinking of entities – Between a discovered entity and its origin – Between each candidate recommendation and the initial item 8
  • 9. Results - Books • Top-10 recommendations • Ratings from Library Things • Reviews from Library Things 9 Algorithm Precision Recall nDCG EBN Diversity SemRevRec 0.0530 0.0530 0.0536 0.1946 0.9118 SPrank 0.0379 0.0346 0.0337 0.1562 0.8037 ItemKNN 0.0620 0.0564 0.0662 1.4956 0.2259 BPR 0.0862 0.0817 0.0895 0.6043 0.7177 Popular 0.0423 0.0343 0.0447 1.6034 0.6483
  • 10. Results - Movies • Top-10 recommendations • Ratings from Movielens 1M • Reviews from IMDb 10 Algorithm Precision Recall nDCG EBN Diversity SemRevRec 0.0857 0.0561 0.0686 0.7820 0.2431 SPrank 0.0445 0.0254 0.0280 0.8813 0.1612 ItemKNN 0.1626 0.1105 0.1302 2.6846 0.0696 BPR 0.2347 0.1737 0.1930 1.8358 0.1769 Popular 0.1325 0.0840 0.0969 2.7439 0.1412
  • 11. Results - Music • Top-10 recommendations • Ratings from HotRec 2011 LastFM • Reviews from Amazon 11 Algorithm Precision Recall nDCG EBN Diversity SemRevRec 0.0536 0.0549 0.0502 0.2411 0.9329 SPrank 0.0156 0.0158 0.0176 0.1834 0.9077 ItemKNN 0.1392 0.1428 0.1720 1.6023 0.4730 BPR 0.1545 0.1583 0.1808 0.9404 0.6547 Popular 0.0686 0.0703 0.0791 2.0360 0.6519
  • 12. Conclusions • Extract information from user reviews and discover additional knowledge from Linked Data • Increase the diversity of recommendations • Increase the novelty of recommendations 12MOVING is funded by the EU Horizon 2020 Programme under the project number INSO-4-2015: 693092 i.vagliano@zbw.eu @maponaso More detailed results at https://arxiv.org/abs/1709.09973