SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Downsize a MOOC
Brenda M. Perea
Instructional Design Project Manager
Targeted Learning
Outside Higher Ed’s
Traditional Models
Session Evaluations Contest
• Open OLC Conferences Mobile App
• Navigate to session to evaluate
• Click on "Rate this Session“
• Complete Session Evaluation*
(As part of our "green" initiatives, OLC is no longer using
paper forms for session evaluations.)
*Contact information required for contest entry but will not be shared with the presenters.
Winners will be contacted post-conference.
Each session evaluation completed (limited to one per session) = one contest entry
Five (5) $25 gift cards will be awarded to five (5) individuals
Must submit evals using the OLC Conferences mobile app
Expected Outcomes…..Hopefully
As a result of this session attendees will be
able to:
• Understand the potential benefits for institutions
to incorporate MOOCs into their educational
pathways
• Understand the benefits of higher ed. Institutions
partnering with industry to offer non-traditional
learning
• Discuss the benefits and challenges in building
MOOCs
Why Develop a MOOC?
• Learning access and opportunity
• Scale
• Student success
Who Takes MOOCs and Who
Succeeds
Image from EduCause Infographic-crash course in MOOCs info graphic
Why CCCS Developed 3 MOOCs
• Required in the SOW for the consortium’s TAACCCT3 grant
• Scale - Cost effective for participants (free resources)
• Student success - Flexible access, targeted learning and no
cost to the student
• Introduction to the Colorado Community College System
We Selected to build a . . .
sMOOC
smaller Massive Online Open Course
Why. . . .
• Industry request to accelerate the time
frame for their employees to become
certificate and degree completers.
• Specific participation group to identify
• Provided with $0 to build an of the MOOCs
• Learning access and opportunity -
community centered learning with world-
wide access
sMOOC Prep 101
What, why, when, who, how
Need to Recognize Challenges
• Launching a MOOC in a traditional community
college semester based system
• Developing “buy-in” from existing math faculty
to “accept” the MOOC vs. traditional semester
course
• Completers passing at a certain level what
does that mean for a participant
• What does this do to faculty FTE
Decisions to Make
•Credits, Credentials, and Certificates
• Badging? —Not yet, but estimate ETA SU15 for 1 sMOOC
• Do we want badges for skill attainment? all modules?
• Or identify what skills are high priority, backwards design
those skills to a competency, and award badge for
competency?
• Credentials—How and Why?
• Certificates?
• What is acceptable?
• Completing all modules?
• Completing at 70%, 80%?
Design Challenges
• Needed to be designed and launched within 6
months
• MOOC length 4-7 weeks?—settled for a 5 week
course
• Designing micro-learning “chunks” tied to
specific competencies
• Needed non-textbook based course material
• Required Content contextualized for Advanced
Manufacturing
sMOOC 1---A MOOC for
Technical Math Skills
Focus on supplementing math skills not on
replacing traditional MAT108 course
• Tool to “refresh” their math skills to test out of
MAT108
• Critically evaluated the “must” cover
• measurements, algebra, geometry,
trigonometry, graphs, and finance.
• Supplemental resource for struggling current
students
sMOOC 2- Employability Skills
• Focus on soft skills needed in the work
place whether new hire or current
employee
• Content based on
• Employer and industry advisory board,
Colorado 21st Century Workforce Skills
Report, Colorado Workforce Training
• Demand from business partners for
better prepared employees
sMOOC 3-Prior Learning
Assessment
• Change in SB Policy
• Need to build a standard level of
awareness of accessibility
• Effectively deliver professional
development to all Colorado Community
College employees (13 colleges spread
across the state)
Downsizing a MOOC: Targeted Learning Outside Higher Education's Traditional Delivery Models
Final MOOC template
Detailed
MOOC
plan
Typical Online Look and Feel
Typical Micro Learning Lesson
Content Designed to Create
“Stickiness”
• Easy to “jump in and around” content
• Each topic had a clear “golden nugget”
• Provide relevant content
• Embed the critical ideas throughout the
content
• Provide visuals
• Facilitate connection or relationship to
the content
Technical Bumps in the Road
• Lack of OER materials other than Khan Academy
• MOOC host requested us to change title and
refine course description to appeal to a broader
audience.
• Ideas on a “new” name was Career Math
• However, that was in direct conflict with an
existing CCCS courses which might lead
students to confuse the course with a credit
bearing course
QUESTIONS????
Downsizing a MOOC: Targeted Learning Outside Higher Education's Traditional Delivery Models
Downsizing a MOOC: Targeted Learning Outside Higher Education's Traditional Delivery Models
CC BY License
This Workforce Solution Downsize a MOOC by Brenda M. Perea is
licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
License. Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available
at www.cccs.edu.
This workforce solution was funded by a grant awarded by the U.S.
Department of Labor’s Employment and Training Administration. The
solution was created by the grantee and does not necessarily reflect
the official position of the U.S. Department of Labor. The Department
of Labor makes no guarantees, warranties, or assurances of any kind,
express or implied, with respect to such information, including any
information on linked sites, and including, but not limited to accuracy
of the information or its completeness, timeliness, usefulness,
adequacy, continued availability or ownership.

More Related Content

PPTX
Reaping the benefits of open educational resources
PPTX
MOOC's Targeted Learning Outside Higher Education's Traditional Models STEMTe...
PPTX
Champ Year 1 Rutgers Report Presentation
PPTX
Taaccct On! Presentation
PPTX
CHAMP grant Y2 Leadership team presentation final 12.02.2015
PPTX
Teaching and learning technology conference -msu blended learning final
PPTX
Mining for oer
PPTX
CHAMP Colorado Career Action Tools Website Webinar October 2014
Reaping the benefits of open educational resources
MOOC's Targeted Learning Outside Higher Education's Traditional Models STEMTe...
Champ Year 1 Rutgers Report Presentation
Taaccct On! Presentation
CHAMP grant Y2 Leadership team presentation final 12.02.2015
Teaching and learning technology conference -msu blended learning final
Mining for oer
CHAMP Colorado Career Action Tools Website Webinar October 2014

What's hot (20)

PPTX
CCCS CHAMP Prior Learning Assessment credit 2 20 15
PPTX
CHAMP Advisory Meeting Reporting presentation
PPTX
Adventures in Designing a MOOC with OER--STEMTech Denver, CO Nov. 2014
PPTX
Champ Navigator Leadership Update Dec 2014
PPTX
Colorado CHAMP PLA 101 training feb 2015
PPTX
Colomatyc
PPTX
Cdhe tf presentation 7 27 12
PPTX
CHMAP Grant overview august 2015
PPTX
Massively Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Game
PPTX
CCCS' Digital Badge Possibilitites IMS Global Badging and Credentials Conveni...
PPTX
Champ Oer and MOOC Presentation December 2014
PPTX
Blended Welding
PPTX
Rutgers University CHAMP Evaluation presentation 8 24.14
PPTX
Developmental Education Presentation to Adams50 Nov 2013
PPTX
Developmental Education Redesign Update CCCS student services conference June...
PPTX
CHAMP Content Development Report
PPTX
DETF presentation 1 4 13
PPTX
Cca academy 1.0 july 2013
PPTX
CHAMP Advsiory Meeting Instructional Design presentation 11 21 13
PPTX
Strategies for securing participant motivation and engagement in a 19 week on...
CCCS CHAMP Prior Learning Assessment credit 2 20 15
CHAMP Advisory Meeting Reporting presentation
Adventures in Designing a MOOC with OER--STEMTech Denver, CO Nov. 2014
Champ Navigator Leadership Update Dec 2014
Colorado CHAMP PLA 101 training feb 2015
Colomatyc
Cdhe tf presentation 7 27 12
CHMAP Grant overview august 2015
Massively Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Game
CCCS' Digital Badge Possibilitites IMS Global Badging and Credentials Conveni...
Champ Oer and MOOC Presentation December 2014
Blended Welding
Rutgers University CHAMP Evaluation presentation 8 24.14
Developmental Education Presentation to Adams50 Nov 2013
Developmental Education Redesign Update CCCS student services conference June...
CHAMP Content Development Report
DETF presentation 1 4 13
Cca academy 1.0 july 2013
CHAMP Advsiory Meeting Instructional Design presentation 11 21 13
Strategies for securing participant motivation and engagement in a 19 week on...
Ad

Viewers also liked (15)

PPTX
Colorado community college system credit for prior learning update june 2015
PPTX
CHAMP Leadership Team Meeting June 2014
PPTX
Digital badges encourage attainment of descrete math skills
PPTX
Champ project leads june 2016
PPTX
Badges II December 2015
PPTX
A Survival Guide for TAACCCT Grantees
PPTX
CHAMP MOOC Meeting Feb 13 2014
PPTX
CHAMP Reporting Counts presentation for the Project Leads meeting may 4 2015
PPTX
Flipped-Hybrid Project Based Advanced Manufacturing Course design by Red Rock...
PPTX
Job Skills Course Development Presentation - July 7, 2014
PPTX
CHAMP CCDA Pathways to in-demand careers in Colorado April 14, 2014
PPTX
CHAMP Instructional Design presentation advisory meeting june 23 2014
PPTX
CHAMP Instructional Design Meeting May 1, 2014
PPTX
Credit for Prior Learning Leadership Meeting 3 6 14
PPTX
CHAMP presentation on SkillsCommons
Colorado community college system credit for prior learning update june 2015
CHAMP Leadership Team Meeting June 2014
Digital badges encourage attainment of descrete math skills
Champ project leads june 2016
Badges II December 2015
A Survival Guide for TAACCCT Grantees
CHAMP MOOC Meeting Feb 13 2014
CHAMP Reporting Counts presentation for the Project Leads meeting may 4 2015
Flipped-Hybrid Project Based Advanced Manufacturing Course design by Red Rock...
Job Skills Course Development Presentation - July 7, 2014
CHAMP CCDA Pathways to in-demand careers in Colorado April 14, 2014
CHAMP Instructional Design presentation advisory meeting june 23 2014
CHAMP Instructional Design Meeting May 1, 2014
Credit for Prior Learning Leadership Meeting 3 6 14
CHAMP presentation on SkillsCommons
Ad

Similar to Downsizing a MOOC: Targeted Learning Outside Higher Education's Traditional Delivery Models (20)

PPTX
Applying Gamification Principles to Online Faculty Professional Development
PPTX
STEM tech presentation TriC MATH MOOC
PPTX
Applying Gamification Principles to Online Faculty Professional Development
PDF
MOOCS@Work Working Group Session 2
PDF
Learning analytics on MOOCs
PDF
MOOCS@Work Working Group Session 4
PDF
Learning cafe call moo cs wgmeet4_ver0.1
PPTX
Why a MOOC?
PPTX
The Rise of MOOCs
PPTX
The Rise of the MOOCs
PPTX
MOOCs and Quality Issues
PDF
Musing on MOOCs
PPTX
4 Gerard L. Hanley_ aportando al exito de las personas de la educ. superior ...
PDF
MOOCS@Work Working Group Session 3
PDF
Mooc for professional learning - A Presentation
PPTX
Moocsv1 130828090147-phpapp01 (4)
PDF
MOOCs for Employee Learning – Practitioners View – Online Forum
PPTX
Stockholm, 18.02.2014
PPTX
Edu trend mooc
PDF
Higher Education's Answer to the Call for Change
Applying Gamification Principles to Online Faculty Professional Development
STEM tech presentation TriC MATH MOOC
Applying Gamification Principles to Online Faculty Professional Development
MOOCS@Work Working Group Session 2
Learning analytics on MOOCs
MOOCS@Work Working Group Session 4
Learning cafe call moo cs wgmeet4_ver0.1
Why a MOOC?
The Rise of MOOCs
The Rise of the MOOCs
MOOCs and Quality Issues
Musing on MOOCs
4 Gerard L. Hanley_ aportando al exito de las personas de la educ. superior ...
MOOCS@Work Working Group Session 3
Mooc for professional learning - A Presentation
Moocsv1 130828090147-phpapp01 (4)
MOOCs for Employee Learning – Practitioners View – Online Forum
Stockholm, 18.02.2014
Edu trend mooc
Higher Education's Answer to the Call for Change

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
STATICS OF THE RIGID BODIES Hibbelers.pdf
PPTX
human mycosis Human fungal infections are called human mycosis..pptx
PPTX
Microbial diseases, their pathogenesis and prophylaxis
PDF
Abdominal Access Techniques with Prof. Dr. R K Mishra
PPTX
Pharma ospi slides which help in ospi learning
PPTX
school management -TNTEU- B.Ed., Semester II Unit 1.pptx
PDF
Basic Mud Logging Guide for educational purpose
PDF
RMMM.pdf make it easy to upload and study
PPTX
Pharmacology of Heart Failure /Pharmacotherapy of CHF
PDF
Computing-Curriculum for Schools in Ghana
PDF
O5-L3 Freight Transport Ops (International) V1.pdf
PDF
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KỸ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH 9 GLOBAL SUCCESS - CẢ NĂM - BÁM SÁT FORM Đ...
PPTX
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
PDF
Saundersa Comprehensive Review for the NCLEX-RN Examination.pdf
PDF
Pre independence Education in Inndia.pdf
PDF
TR - Agricultural Crops Production NC III.pdf
PDF
Chapter 2 Heredity, Prenatal Development, and Birth.pdf
PDF
01-Introduction-to-Information-Management.pdf
PPTX
Renaissance Architecture: A Journey from Faith to Humanism
PPTX
PPT- ENG7_QUARTER1_LESSON1_WEEK1. IMAGERY -DESCRIPTIONS pptx.pptx
STATICS OF THE RIGID BODIES Hibbelers.pdf
human mycosis Human fungal infections are called human mycosis..pptx
Microbial diseases, their pathogenesis and prophylaxis
Abdominal Access Techniques with Prof. Dr. R K Mishra
Pharma ospi slides which help in ospi learning
school management -TNTEU- B.Ed., Semester II Unit 1.pptx
Basic Mud Logging Guide for educational purpose
RMMM.pdf make it easy to upload and study
Pharmacology of Heart Failure /Pharmacotherapy of CHF
Computing-Curriculum for Schools in Ghana
O5-L3 Freight Transport Ops (International) V1.pdf
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KỸ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH 9 GLOBAL SUCCESS - CẢ NĂM - BÁM SÁT FORM Đ...
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
Saundersa Comprehensive Review for the NCLEX-RN Examination.pdf
Pre independence Education in Inndia.pdf
TR - Agricultural Crops Production NC III.pdf
Chapter 2 Heredity, Prenatal Development, and Birth.pdf
01-Introduction-to-Information-Management.pdf
Renaissance Architecture: A Journey from Faith to Humanism
PPT- ENG7_QUARTER1_LESSON1_WEEK1. IMAGERY -DESCRIPTIONS pptx.pptx

Downsizing a MOOC: Targeted Learning Outside Higher Education's Traditional Delivery Models

  • 1. Downsize a MOOC Brenda M. Perea Instructional Design Project Manager Targeted Learning Outside Higher Ed’s Traditional Models
  • 2. Session Evaluations Contest • Open OLC Conferences Mobile App • Navigate to session to evaluate • Click on "Rate this Session“ • Complete Session Evaluation* (As part of our "green" initiatives, OLC is no longer using paper forms for session evaluations.) *Contact information required for contest entry but will not be shared with the presenters. Winners will be contacted post-conference. Each session evaluation completed (limited to one per session) = one contest entry Five (5) $25 gift cards will be awarded to five (5) individuals Must submit evals using the OLC Conferences mobile app
  • 3. Expected Outcomes…..Hopefully As a result of this session attendees will be able to: • Understand the potential benefits for institutions to incorporate MOOCs into their educational pathways • Understand the benefits of higher ed. Institutions partnering with industry to offer non-traditional learning • Discuss the benefits and challenges in building MOOCs
  • 4. Why Develop a MOOC? • Learning access and opportunity • Scale • Student success
  • 5. Who Takes MOOCs and Who Succeeds Image from EduCause Infographic-crash course in MOOCs info graphic
  • 6. Why CCCS Developed 3 MOOCs • Required in the SOW for the consortium’s TAACCCT3 grant • Scale - Cost effective for participants (free resources) • Student success - Flexible access, targeted learning and no cost to the student • Introduction to the Colorado Community College System
  • 7. We Selected to build a . . . sMOOC smaller Massive Online Open Course Why. . . . • Industry request to accelerate the time frame for their employees to become certificate and degree completers. • Specific participation group to identify • Provided with $0 to build an of the MOOCs • Learning access and opportunity - community centered learning with world- wide access
  • 8. sMOOC Prep 101 What, why, when, who, how
  • 9. Need to Recognize Challenges • Launching a MOOC in a traditional community college semester based system • Developing “buy-in” from existing math faculty to “accept” the MOOC vs. traditional semester course • Completers passing at a certain level what does that mean for a participant • What does this do to faculty FTE
  • 10. Decisions to Make •Credits, Credentials, and Certificates • Badging? —Not yet, but estimate ETA SU15 for 1 sMOOC • Do we want badges for skill attainment? all modules? • Or identify what skills are high priority, backwards design those skills to a competency, and award badge for competency? • Credentials—How and Why? • Certificates? • What is acceptable? • Completing all modules? • Completing at 70%, 80%?
  • 11. Design Challenges • Needed to be designed and launched within 6 months • MOOC length 4-7 weeks?—settled for a 5 week course • Designing micro-learning “chunks” tied to specific competencies • Needed non-textbook based course material • Required Content contextualized for Advanced Manufacturing
  • 12. sMOOC 1---A MOOC for Technical Math Skills Focus on supplementing math skills not on replacing traditional MAT108 course • Tool to “refresh” their math skills to test out of MAT108 • Critically evaluated the “must” cover • measurements, algebra, geometry, trigonometry, graphs, and finance. • Supplemental resource for struggling current students
  • 13. sMOOC 2- Employability Skills • Focus on soft skills needed in the work place whether new hire or current employee • Content based on • Employer and industry advisory board, Colorado 21st Century Workforce Skills Report, Colorado Workforce Training • Demand from business partners for better prepared employees
  • 14. sMOOC 3-Prior Learning Assessment • Change in SB Policy • Need to build a standard level of awareness of accessibility • Effectively deliver professional development to all Colorado Community College employees (13 colleges spread across the state)
  • 20. Content Designed to Create “Stickiness” • Easy to “jump in and around” content • Each topic had a clear “golden nugget” • Provide relevant content • Embed the critical ideas throughout the content • Provide visuals • Facilitate connection or relationship to the content
  • 21. Technical Bumps in the Road • Lack of OER materials other than Khan Academy • MOOC host requested us to change title and refine course description to appeal to a broader audience. • Ideas on a “new” name was Career Math • However, that was in direct conflict with an existing CCCS courses which might lead students to confuse the course with a credit bearing course
  • 25. CC BY License This Workforce Solution Downsize a MOOC by Brenda M. Perea is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at www.cccs.edu. This workforce solution was funded by a grant awarded by the U.S. Department of Labor’s Employment and Training Administration. The solution was created by the grantee and does not necessarily reflect the official position of the U.S. Department of Labor. The Department of Labor makes no guarantees, warranties, or assurances of any kind, express or implied, with respect to such information, including any information on linked sites, and including, but not limited to accuracy of the information or its completeness, timeliness, usefulness, adequacy, continued availability or ownership.

Editor's Notes

  • #2: Page URL: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File%3ALogo_MOOC_GdP_d%C3%A9tour%C3%A9.png File URL: Attribution: By Ofol (Own work) [CC BY-SA 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0)], via Wikimedia Commons
  • #4: Expected Outcomes…hopefully As a result of this session attendees will be able to: Understand the potential benefits for institutions to incorporate MOOCs into their educational pathways Understand the benefits of higher ed. Institutions partnering with industry to offer non-traditional learning Discuss the benefits and challenges in building MOOCs
  • #5: Why Develop a MOOC? Learning access and opportunity Scale Student success
  • #6: Average student: lurks in the first MOOC registered, usually doesn’t complete the MOOC predominately male currently employed; in this country they’re also older than you might expect. Far more enrollees view them as a diversion than they do as a means to a college degree or a new job Typically have a 2 or 4 year degree Only allots 2-3 hours per week in 15 to 20 minute increments Only completes 1 out of 4 MOOCs registered in To take advantage of a MOOC requires sufficient schooling to be able to follow college-level material, consistent access to the Web, reliable internet
  • #7: Why CCCS Developed 3 sMOOCs Required in the SOW for the consortium’s TAACCCT3 grant Learning access and opportunity-- community centered learning with world-wide access Scale - Cost effective for participants (free resources) Meeting Industry needs-- rapid prototype development avoids the year long process of traditional new program/course development while avoid 'reinventing the wheel' for time efficiency Student success -- Flexible access, targeted learning and no cost to the student Introduction to the Colorado Community College System
  • #8: We elected to build a … sMOOC—smaller Massive Online Open Course Part of our Statement of Work for the Trade Adjustment Assistance Community College and Career Training (TAACCCT grant) Industry request to accelerate the time frame for their employees to become certificate and degree completers. Specific participation group to identify Provided with $0 to build an of the MOOCs
  • #9: sMOOC Prep 101
  • #10: Need to recognize Challenges Launching a MOOC in a traditional community college semester based system Developing “buy-in” from existing math faculty to “accept” the MOOC vs. traditional semester course Completers passing at a certain level what does that mean for a participant What does this do to faculty FTE Design for a course running 4-7 weeks Cannot build the MOOC like an online course. Must be designed for mobile devices Compact Content with video length less than 3 minutes Total time on task is 30 minutes including practice drills.  Each learning “chunk” contains Context-grabbing the students interest as well as provide relevance to material Challenge- create small packages of learning which can be completed in 15 to 20 minutes Activity-showing that they understand the content Feedback-can be personal or automatic.
  • #11: Decisions to Make Credits, Credentials, and Certificates Badging? —Not yet, but estimate ETA SU15 for 1 sMOOC Do we want badges for skill attainment? all modules? Or identify what skills are high priority, backwards design those skills to a competency, and award badge for competency? Credentials—How and Why? Certificates? What is acceptable? Completing all modules? Completing at 70%, 80%?
  • #12: Design for a course running 4-7 weeks Cannot build the MOOC like an online course. Must be designed for mobile devices Compact Content with video length less than 3 minutes Total time on task is 30 minutes including practice drills.  Each learning “chunk” contains Context-grabbing the students interest as well as provide relevance to material Challenge- create small packages of learning which can be completed in 15 to 20 minutes Activity-showing that they understand the content Feedback-can be personal or automatic.
  • #13: sMOOC 1—Why a MOOC for Technical Math Skills Focus on supplementing math skills not on replacing traditional MAT108 course Tool to “refresh” their math skills to test out of MAT108 Critically evaluated the “must” cover measurements, algebra, geometry, trigonometry, graphs, and finance. Supplemental resource for struggling current students
  • #14: sMOOC 2—Employability Skills Focus on soft skills needed in the work place whether new hire or current employee Content based on Employer and industry advisory board, Colorado 21st Century Workforce Skills Report, Colorado Workforce Training Demand from business partners for better prepared employees
  • #15: sMOOC 3—Prior Learning Assessment Change in SB Policy Need to build a standard level of awareness of accessibility Effectively deliver professional development to all Colorado Community College employees (13 colleges spread across the state)
  • #19: Typical Online look and Feel
  • #20: Micro Learning
  • #21: Content Designed to Create “Stickiness” Each topic had a clear “golden nugget” Provide relevant content Embed the critical ideas throughout the content Provide visuals Facilitate connection or relationship to the content
  • #22: Technical Bumps in the Road Lack of OER materials other than Khan Academy MOOC host requested us to change title and refine course description to appeal to a broader audience. Ideas on a “new” name was Career Math However, that was in direct conflict with an existing CCCS courses which might lead students to confuse the course with a credit bearing course
  • #26: CC BY License This Workforce Solution Downsize a MOOC by Brenda M. Perea is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at www.cccs.edu.   This workforce solution was funded by a grant awarded by the U.S. Department of Labor’s Employment and Training Administration. The solution was created by the grantee and does not necessarily reflect the official position of the U.S. Department of Labor. The Department of Labor makes no guarantees, warranties, or assurances of any kind, express or implied, with respect to such information, including any information on linked sites, and including, but not limited to accuracy of the information or its completeness, timeliness, usefulness, adequacy, continued availability or ownership.