![Netnography: Definition and Quality Criterion
Reflexivity Judges the extent to which the role of the researcher is
acknowledged and is open to alternative interpretations
Praxis Judges the extent to which the netnography inspires and
empowers social action
Resonance Judges to what extent personalized and sensitizing connection
with the cultural phenomenon is gained
Verisimilitude Judges the extent to which a believable and lifelike sense of
cultural and communal contact is achieved
Rigour Judges the extent to which netnography recognizes and
adheres to the procedural standards of netnographic research
[adapted from adapted from Kozinets, 2010: p. 1 – 8 & p. 1 – 20, 189 – 195]
The practice of ‘netnography’ is a useful method for researchers interested in revealing, analyzing and
understanding “the self-presentation strategies individuals use to construct a digital self” (Kozinets, 2010: p.2)
Criterion for quality netnography include reflexivity, praxis, resonance, verisimilitude and rigour [Kozinets, 2010]
Netnography Definition
“A specialized form of ethnography
adapted to the unique computer-
mediated contingencies of today’s social
world’s” (Kozinets 2010: p. 1)](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/finalslideshareppt-160310025904/85/EDRD-6000-Netnography-eFieldnotes-3-320.jpg)
![• When researchers encounter the field through social media, the local-global divide shrinks - the distinction
between being ‘in the field’ and ‘out of the field’ can blur
“Digital communication technologies do not dissolve boundaries between field and home, but they can bring
disparate worlds into close proximity”
[Jordan Kramer p. 123]
• eFieldnotes are widening the complexity of qualitative data collection and analysis
• New methods for combining eFieldnotes with standard fieldnotes is a necessary evolution
Encountering the Field Through Social Media
Sanjek, Roger &Tratner,Susan W. (2016) eFieldnotes:The Making of Anthropology in the DigitalWorld. University of Pennsylvania Press: Philadelphia, USA](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/finalslideshareppt-160310025904/85/EDRD-6000-Netnography-eFieldnotes-5-320.jpg)
![Ethical Considerations for Netnographic Research
“Social media is affecting researcher’s efforts to recruit participants, gain informed consent, collect data, leave the field, and
disseminate results because participants have greater ability to respond to those findings. [This] points to shifts of power between
participants and researchers…suggests that this might promise greater equity between participants and researchers, while also
potentially introducing new pitfalls.” [Reich, 2015. p. 395]](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/finalslideshareppt-160310025904/85/EDRD-6000-Netnography-eFieldnotes-6-320.jpg)
![More Ethical Considerations
Consideration: How do parameters of ‘informed consent’ change across privately/publically accessed information?
[Sin, Harng Luh (2015)]](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/finalslideshareppt-160310025904/85/EDRD-6000-Netnography-eFieldnotes-7-320.jpg)
![Consent, Identification and Anonymity
Purpose Procedures Risks Benefits Compensation Confidentiality Costs Participant rights
[Sin, Harng Luh (2015)]](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/finalslideshareppt-160310025904/85/EDRD-6000-Netnography-eFieldnotes-8-320.jpg)
![GLOSSARY [adapted from adapted from Kozinets, 2010: p. 189 – 195]
Asynchronous
Communication
Communications that are staggered in time, such as billboards, web-pages, forum postings, emails; spread over days,
weeks, months; contrasted with synchronous “real-time” communication
Blended netnography Combines collection of online data/interactions with face-to-face data/interactions. Contrasted to ‘pure’ netnography
Computer-mediated
communication (CMC)
Communication that takes place through a computer or network; forums, postings, instant messaging, e-mails, chat rooms,
texting etc…
Cyberculture Distinct type of culture; developed along with digital information, communication technologies & the Internet: learned systems of
meaning, which include beliefs, values, practices, roles & languages that organize online social formations
Online community
research
Examines some phenomenon directly related to online communities and online culture itself, its manifestations and/or elements
Research on online
communities
Examines general social phenomenon whose social existence extends beyond the Internet and online interactions, where online
communication plays an important, but not exclusive, role in the group membership
Rings organizations of related web-pages, linked together & structured by interest
SocialContentAggregators Sites/services designed to facilitate communal discovery & sharing of Internet content, vote on it, and comment upon it; a
potential sit of online community and culture. Ex: Reddit, Buzzfeed etc…
Social NetworkingAnalysis determining structural relationships among and between communities
Technoculture Term to represent that technology does not determine culture and culture does not determine technology; they are co-evolving
Online (orVirtual)
Communities
Terms popularized by Howard Rheingold (1993: p.5): “social aggregations that emerge from the Internet when enough people
carry on… public discussions long enough, with sufficient human feelings, to form webs of personal relationships in cyber space.”](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/finalslideshareppt-160310025904/85/EDRD-6000-Netnography-eFieldnotes-10-320.jpg)
EDRD *6000 Netnography & eFieldnotes
- 1. Purpose: to present an overview of • the practice of netnography • the use of eFieldnotes • ethical considerations for collecting data in the digital world By: Stephanie Page
- 2. Evolving Context, Evolving Methods
- 3. Netnography: Definition and Quality Criterion Reflexivity Judges the extent to which the role of the researcher is acknowledged and is open to alternative interpretations Praxis Judges the extent to which the netnography inspires and empowers social action Resonance Judges to what extent personalized and sensitizing connection with the cultural phenomenon is gained Verisimilitude Judges the extent to which a believable and lifelike sense of cultural and communal contact is achieved Rigour Judges the extent to which netnography recognizes and adheres to the procedural standards of netnographic research [adapted from adapted from Kozinets, 2010: p. 1 – 8 & p. 1 – 20, 189 – 195] The practice of ‘netnography’ is a useful method for researchers interested in revealing, analyzing and understanding “the self-presentation strategies individuals use to construct a digital self” (Kozinets, 2010: p.2) Criterion for quality netnography include reflexivity, praxis, resonance, verisimilitude and rigour [Kozinets, 2010] Netnography Definition “A specialized form of ethnography adapted to the unique computer- mediated contingencies of today’s social world’s” (Kozinets 2010: p. 1)
- 4. eFieldnotes Sanjek, Roger & Tratner, Susan W. (2016) eFieldnotes: The Making of Anthropology in the Digital World. University of Pennsylvania Press: Philadelphia, USA
- 5. • When researchers encounter the field through social media, the local-global divide shrinks - the distinction between being ‘in the field’ and ‘out of the field’ can blur “Digital communication technologies do not dissolve boundaries between field and home, but they can bring disparate worlds into close proximity” [Jordan Kramer p. 123] • eFieldnotes are widening the complexity of qualitative data collection and analysis • New methods for combining eFieldnotes with standard fieldnotes is a necessary evolution Encountering the Field Through Social Media Sanjek, Roger &Tratner,Susan W. (2016) eFieldnotes:The Making of Anthropology in the DigitalWorld. University of Pennsylvania Press: Philadelphia, USA
- 6. Ethical Considerations for Netnographic Research “Social media is affecting researcher’s efforts to recruit participants, gain informed consent, collect data, leave the field, and disseminate results because participants have greater ability to respond to those findings. [This] points to shifts of power between participants and researchers…suggests that this might promise greater equity between participants and researchers, while also potentially introducing new pitfalls.” [Reich, 2015. p. 395]
- 7. More Ethical Considerations Consideration: How do parameters of ‘informed consent’ change across privately/publically accessed information? [Sin, Harng Luh (2015)]
- 8. Consent, Identification and Anonymity Purpose Procedures Risks Benefits Compensation Confidentiality Costs Participant rights [Sin, Harng Luh (2015)]
- 9. Summary
- 10. GLOSSARY [adapted from adapted from Kozinets, 2010: p. 189 – 195] Asynchronous Communication Communications that are staggered in time, such as billboards, web-pages, forum postings, emails; spread over days, weeks, months; contrasted with synchronous “real-time” communication Blended netnography Combines collection of online data/interactions with face-to-face data/interactions. Contrasted to ‘pure’ netnography Computer-mediated communication (CMC) Communication that takes place through a computer or network; forums, postings, instant messaging, e-mails, chat rooms, texting etc… Cyberculture Distinct type of culture; developed along with digital information, communication technologies & the Internet: learned systems of meaning, which include beliefs, values, practices, roles & languages that organize online social formations Online community research Examines some phenomenon directly related to online communities and online culture itself, its manifestations and/or elements Research on online communities Examines general social phenomenon whose social existence extends beyond the Internet and online interactions, where online communication plays an important, but not exclusive, role in the group membership Rings organizations of related web-pages, linked together & structured by interest SocialContentAggregators Sites/services designed to facilitate communal discovery & sharing of Internet content, vote on it, and comment upon it; a potential sit of online community and culture. Ex: Reddit, Buzzfeed etc… Social NetworkingAnalysis determining structural relationships among and between communities Technoculture Term to represent that technology does not determine culture and culture does not determine technology; they are co-evolving Online (orVirtual) Communities Terms popularized by Howard Rheingold (1993: p.5): “social aggregations that emerge from the Internet when enough people carry on… public discussions long enough, with sufficient human feelings, to form webs of personal relationships in cyber space.”
- 11. References