SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The Arrival of Quantum Computing
Jeremy Witmer
Phd. Candidate at Stanford University, Applied
Sciences
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Quantum networks
Jeremy Witmer
Stanford University
Impact Seminar
2018-04-19
Laboratory for Integrated
Nano-Quantum Systems
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Quantum technologies
Quantum Computing
Applications:
• Code breaking (Shor’s
algorithm)
• Quantum simulation (chemistry,
materials, drug discovery)
• Machine learning
Hardware:
• Superconducting circuits
• Trapped ions
• Silicon quantum dots
• Many others…
Quantum Communication
Applications:
• Secure communication
(quantum key distribution)
• Quantum internet
Hardware:
• Light in optical fiber
• Light in free-space
Quantum Sensing
Applications:
• Gravitometry (geo-surveying)
• Magnetometry (materials
science, MRI)
Hardware:
• Atomic clocks
• NV centers in diamond
Our research
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Quantum communication in the news
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
What is quantum key distribution?
• “One-time pad”
• Share secret key ahead of time (random string of bits, as long as
message).
• To encrypt message, XOR it with key. Decrypt is the same.
• Impossible to decrypt, information is completely scrambled.
• Question: How to share secret key?
• Idea: Transmit the secret key using single photons. Allows
eavesdroppers can be detected!
• Potential for perfectly encrypted communication. (But
still need to design system carefully)
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Quantum communication: major players
• DARPA (Boston)
• Los Alamos National Lab
• Tokyo
• Geneva
• Beijing-Shanghai fiber link
• China quantum satellite
Government-sponsored QKD networks:
Geneva New YorkCanberra
Quantum key distribution companies:
Newer companies:
• SeQure Net (France)
• Infiniquant (Germany)
• KETS Quantum Security (UK)
• QuNu Labs (India)
Notes:
• Chinese government is hugely invested (~ $2 billion)
• Nothing in Silicon Valley (that I know of)
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Quantum technologies
Quantum Computing
Applications:
• Code breaking (Shor’s
algorithm)
• Quantum simulation (chemistry,
materials, drug discovery)
• Machine learning
Hardware:
• Superconducting circuits
• Trapped ions
• Silicon quantum dots
• Many others…
Quantum Communication
Applications:
• Secure communication
(quantum key distribution)
• Quantum internet
Hardware:
• Light in optical fiber
• Light in free-space
Quantum Sensing
Applications:
• Gravitometry (geo-surveying)
• Magnetometry (materials
science, MRI)
Hardware:
• Atomic clocks
• NV centers
Our research
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Why a quantum internet?
1. Allows for parallelized computation. (Computational power scales exponentially
with number of processors.)
1. Scaling superconducting quantum processors beyond ~ 1000 qubits impossible
with current RF cables. Optical communication provides an alternative.
1. Enables quantum-secured private communication over long distances.
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Courtesy of IEEE Spectrum, Google
Google
Quantum Computing Quantum
CommunicationPhotons in optical fibers
How can we connect these?
Superconducting qubits
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
The backbone of the (classical)
internet
Electro-optic modulators Electro-optic effect:
n: refractive index
E: electric field
r: electro-optic coefficient
Light in
Signal
electro-optic
Modulated light out
V +
- 1
0
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
electro-optic
L
C
Microwave
input/output
Optical fiber
input/output
Electro-optic conversion
Mirrors Resonant LC circuit
Qubit processor
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Electro-optic converter design
Grating (light input)
Photo
nic
crystal
mirror
Optical
resonator
Capaci
tor
Photonic crystal mirror
2 um
Grating
10 um
Overview
1 mm
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Our hardware
Dilution refrigerator
Converter chip
Optical IO
Microwave IO
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Cryogenic microwave-to-optical conversion
Optical power measurement
Our first converted photons!
Current conversion efficiency is low (<< 1%), but we have ideas to improve it.
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Quantum technologies
Quantum Computing
Applications:
• Code breaking (Shor’s
algorithm)
• Quantum simulation (chemistry,
materials, drug discovery)
• Machine learning
Hardware:
• Superconducting circuits
• Trapped ions
• Silicon quantum dots
• Many others…
Quantum Communication
Applications:
• Secure communication
(quantum key distribution)
• Quantum internet
Hardware:
• Light in optical fiber
• Light in free-space
Quantum Sensing
Applications:
• Gravitometry (geo-surveying)
• Magnetometry (materials
science, MRI)
Hardware:
• Atomic clocks
• NV centers
Our research
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Acknowledgements
Laboratory for Integrated
Nano-Quantum Systems
Stanford
Graduate
Fellowship
Stanford Nanofabrication Facility
& Stanford Nano Shared Facitilities
Collaborators:
Prof. Jingdong Luo
Prof. Alex Jen
Francis Lin
(U Washington, City U Hong Kong)
Timothy
McKenna
Raphael
Van Laer
Patricio
Arrangoiz-Arriola
Prof. Amir
Safavi-Naeini
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Extra slides
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Conclusions
• Electro-optic effect allows us to convert light and microwaves directly
• Make converter chip using electro-optic polymer and silicon photonics
• Demonstrated microwave-to-optical signal conversion in dilution
refrigerator
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
What is “quantum key distribution”?
Provably secure (unbreakable) assuming the following three conditions:
• The key is completely random
• The key is as long as the message
• The key is never reused
Plain-text
1
1
1
0
1
0
1
0
1
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
1
1
0
XOR
Alice Bob
Secret key Cypher-text
One-time pad encryption
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Silicon photonics with electro-optic
polymers
EO polymer properties:
• Highly polar chromophore molecule
embedded in host polymer
• Large electro-optic coefficients:
EO polymers: > 400 pm/V
(Lithium niobate: 31 pm/V)
• Spin coat as final cladding layer
→ simplifies fabrication
• Low optical loss (can be < 1 dB/cm)
• Low MW loss (not piezo-electric!)
• Must be poled in-device
+-
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Two operating modes
Pump on low-frequency side:
Converts microwave photon to optical photon
Pump on high-frequency side:
Creates entangled microwave and optical photons
Freq.
pump
…
Freq.
pump
…
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Next step: high-L spiral inductors
Grating coupler
Photonic
crystal
mirror
Optical
cavity
Capacitor
High-Z0 spiral
inductor
High-Z0 spiral inductor
20 um
Airbridge process
2 um
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Scaling superconducting quantum
computers
Courtesy of IEEE Spectrum, Google
IBM
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Connecting quantum computers
mm waves?
M. Pechal et al, Phys. Rev. A 96, 042305 (2017)
Solution: use light!
Jeremy Witmer Stanford
University
Microwave-to-optical different approaches
Electro-optics:
Schwefel, Painter and Leuchs groups, 2016
Optomechanics:
Cleland group, U Chicago, 2016
Also Srivinavasan group, NISTLehnert and Regal groups,
CU Boulder, 2014
Magnonics:
Nakamura group, Tokyo, 2016
Spin systems:
Faraon group, Caltech, 2017

More Related Content

PDF
The Quantum Internet: Hype or the Next Step
PDF
Introduction to Quantum Computer
PDF
The Quantum Internet: Hype or the Next Step
PPTX
Quantum computers
PPTX
Quantum Computers
PPTX
Quantum Computing
PPTX
Quantum Internet Explained
The Quantum Internet: Hype or the Next Step
Introduction to Quantum Computer
The Quantum Internet: Hype or the Next Step
Quantum computers
Quantum Computers
Quantum Computing
Quantum Internet Explained

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Quantum Internet By Professor Lili Saghafi
PDF
quantum computing and Quantum Communications
PDF
Introduction to Quantum Computing and Engineering
PDF
What quantum computers may tell us about quantum mechanics
PDF
Quantum Computers PART 4 Quantum Computer’sHardware by Lili Saghafi
PPTX
Quantum computers, quantum key distribution, quantum networks
PPTX
Quantum computing seminar
PPTX
Quantum Computing by Rajeev Chauhan
PDF
Quantum Computing Quantum Internet 2020_unit 1 By: Prof. Lili Saghafi
PDF
Quantum Computing
PPTX
Qunatum computing
DOCX
Quantum Computing
PDF
Quantum Computers New Generation of Computers Part 8 Quantum Error Correction...
PPTX
2013.09.13 quantum computing has arrived s.nechuiviter
PPT
Des2017 quantum computing_final
PPTX
Quantum computing
PDF
Quantum computation: EPR Paradox and Bell's Inequality
PDF
Quantum Computers new Generation of Computers part 7 by prof lili saghafi Qua...
PPTX
Quantum Computing and Blockchain: Facts and Myths
PPTX
Quantum Computing
Quantum Internet By Professor Lili Saghafi
quantum computing and Quantum Communications
Introduction to Quantum Computing and Engineering
What quantum computers may tell us about quantum mechanics
Quantum Computers PART 4 Quantum Computer’sHardware by Lili Saghafi
Quantum computers, quantum key distribution, quantum networks
Quantum computing seminar
Quantum Computing by Rajeev Chauhan
Quantum Computing Quantum Internet 2020_unit 1 By: Prof. Lili Saghafi
Quantum Computing
Qunatum computing
Quantum Computing
Quantum Computers New Generation of Computers Part 8 Quantum Error Correction...
2013.09.13 quantum computing has arrived s.nechuiviter
Des2017 quantum computing_final
Quantum computing
Quantum computation: EPR Paradox and Bell's Inequality
Quantum Computers new Generation of Computers part 7 by prof lili saghafi Qua...
Quantum Computing and Blockchain: Facts and Myths
Quantum Computing
Ad

Similar to The Arrival of Quantum Computing – Quantum Networks (20)

PPT
Quantum photonics
PDF
Quantum Photonics
PPTX
The convergence of IoT and Quantum Computing
PPTX
Wolfgang Ketterle - Quantum Computing, Science & Engineering at SIT Insights...
PDF
Paris Quantum Computing & Technologies Meetup #1
PPT
AdS Biology and Quantum Information Science
PPTX
Quantum communication and its applications.pptx
PDF
(SACON) M T Karunakaran  - Quantum safe Networks
PDF
Quantum Internet: Everything You Need To Know | Enterprise Wired
PPTX
Quantum Computing and computation and features
PDF
Quantum nature poli_mi_ddm_200115
PPTX
Quantum Teleportation
PDF
Quantum Communications and Cryptography 1st Edition Alexander V. Sergienko
PDF
Quantum Communications and Cryptography 1st Edition Alexander V. Sergienko
PPTX
Quantum Information FINAL.pptx
PDF
slidesgo-revolutionizing-computing-an-overview-of-quantum-technology-20240502...
PDF
Quantum communications and cryptography 1st Edition Alexander V. Sergienko
PPT
Quantum computer
PDF
Hacking Quantum Cryptography
PDF
Photonics Essentials An Introduction With Experiments T Pearsall
Quantum photonics
Quantum Photonics
The convergence of IoT and Quantum Computing
Wolfgang Ketterle - Quantum Computing, Science & Engineering at SIT Insights...
Paris Quantum Computing & Technologies Meetup #1
AdS Biology and Quantum Information Science
Quantum communication and its applications.pptx
(SACON) M T Karunakaran  - Quantum safe Networks
Quantum Internet: Everything You Need To Know | Enterprise Wired
Quantum Computing and computation and features
Quantum nature poli_mi_ddm_200115
Quantum Teleportation
Quantum Communications and Cryptography 1st Edition Alexander V. Sergienko
Quantum Communications and Cryptography 1st Edition Alexander V. Sergienko
Quantum Information FINAL.pptx
slidesgo-revolutionizing-computing-an-overview-of-quantum-technology-20240502...
Quantum communications and cryptography 1st Edition Alexander V. Sergienko
Quantum computer
Hacking Quantum Cryptography
Photonics Essentials An Introduction With Experiments T Pearsall
Ad

More from Impact.Tech (18)

PDF
Impact.Tech "Statistical Literacy for Deep Tech"
PDF
"Bridging Carbon Markets and Agriculture" by David Babson
PDF
"Sustainable Fashion" by Beth Esponnette
PDF
"Statistical Literacy for Deep Tech" by Noel Jee
PPTX
"Carbon Sequestration" by Noah Deich
PPTX
Clean Chemicals
PDF
"The Future of Connectivity" by Siamak Ebadi
PDF
Intellectual Property for Deep Tech
PDF
Impact.tech: "Bioengineering is not Programming" by Louis Metzger IV
PDF
Impact.tech: Cellular Agriculture by Elliot Swartz
PDF
Martin Borch Jensen - The Science of Aging 2019
PDF
Genome Editing & Gene Therapy by Eric Kelsic
PDF
Impact.tech: Clean Chemicals by Wojciech Osowiecki
PDF
Impact tech: Opportunities in Clean Meat and Cellular Agriculture by Liz Specht
PDF
Impact.tech: Opportunities in Plant-based Food Technologies by Liz Specht
PPTX
"The Arrival of Quantum Computing" by Will Zeng
PDF
"The Science of Aging" by Martin Borch Jensen
PDF
Preserving and Enhancing Impact: Corporate Forms
Impact.Tech "Statistical Literacy for Deep Tech"
"Bridging Carbon Markets and Agriculture" by David Babson
"Sustainable Fashion" by Beth Esponnette
"Statistical Literacy for Deep Tech" by Noel Jee
"Carbon Sequestration" by Noah Deich
Clean Chemicals
"The Future of Connectivity" by Siamak Ebadi
Intellectual Property for Deep Tech
Impact.tech: "Bioengineering is not Programming" by Louis Metzger IV
Impact.tech: Cellular Agriculture by Elliot Swartz
Martin Borch Jensen - The Science of Aging 2019
Genome Editing & Gene Therapy by Eric Kelsic
Impact.tech: Clean Chemicals by Wojciech Osowiecki
Impact tech: Opportunities in Clean Meat and Cellular Agriculture by Liz Specht
Impact.tech: Opportunities in Plant-based Food Technologies by Liz Specht
"The Arrival of Quantum Computing" by Will Zeng
"The Science of Aging" by Martin Borch Jensen
Preserving and Enhancing Impact: Corporate Forms

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Optimiser vos workloads AI/ML sur Amazon EC2 et AWS Graviton
PDF
Review of recent advances in non-invasive hemoglobin estimation
PDF
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
PPTX
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
PPTX
VMware vSphere Foundation How to Sell Presentation-Ver1.4-2-14-2024.pptx
PPTX
sap open course for s4hana steps from ECC to s4
PDF
Unlocking AI with Model Context Protocol (MCP)
PPTX
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
PPTX
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
PDF
Empathic Computing: Creating Shared Understanding
PDF
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
DOCX
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
PDF
Profit Center Accounting in SAP S/4HANA, S4F28 Col11
PDF
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
PDF
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
PDF
Building Integrated photovoltaic BIPV_UPV.pdf
PPTX
Programs and apps: productivity, graphics, security and other tools
PDF
Peak of Data & AI Encore- AI for Metadata and Smarter Workflows
PPT
“AI and Expert System Decision Support & Business Intelligence Systems”
PPTX
ACSFv1EN-58255 AWS Academy Cloud Security Foundations.pptx
Optimiser vos workloads AI/ML sur Amazon EC2 et AWS Graviton
Review of recent advances in non-invasive hemoglobin estimation
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
VMware vSphere Foundation How to Sell Presentation-Ver1.4-2-14-2024.pptx
sap open course for s4hana steps from ECC to s4
Unlocking AI with Model Context Protocol (MCP)
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
Empathic Computing: Creating Shared Understanding
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
Profit Center Accounting in SAP S/4HANA, S4F28 Col11
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
Building Integrated photovoltaic BIPV_UPV.pdf
Programs and apps: productivity, graphics, security and other tools
Peak of Data & AI Encore- AI for Metadata and Smarter Workflows
“AI and Expert System Decision Support & Business Intelligence Systems”
ACSFv1EN-58255 AWS Academy Cloud Security Foundations.pptx

The Arrival of Quantum Computing – Quantum Networks

  • 1. The Arrival of Quantum Computing Jeremy Witmer Phd. Candidate at Stanford University, Applied Sciences
  • 2. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Quantum networks Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Impact Seminar 2018-04-19 Laboratory for Integrated Nano-Quantum Systems
  • 3. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Quantum technologies Quantum Computing Applications: • Code breaking (Shor’s algorithm) • Quantum simulation (chemistry, materials, drug discovery) • Machine learning Hardware: • Superconducting circuits • Trapped ions • Silicon quantum dots • Many others… Quantum Communication Applications: • Secure communication (quantum key distribution) • Quantum internet Hardware: • Light in optical fiber • Light in free-space Quantum Sensing Applications: • Gravitometry (geo-surveying) • Magnetometry (materials science, MRI) Hardware: • Atomic clocks • NV centers in diamond Our research
  • 5. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Quantum communication in the news
  • 6. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University What is quantum key distribution? • “One-time pad” • Share secret key ahead of time (random string of bits, as long as message). • To encrypt message, XOR it with key. Decrypt is the same. • Impossible to decrypt, information is completely scrambled. • Question: How to share secret key? • Idea: Transmit the secret key using single photons. Allows eavesdroppers can be detected! • Potential for perfectly encrypted communication. (But still need to design system carefully)
  • 7. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Quantum communication: major players • DARPA (Boston) • Los Alamos National Lab • Tokyo • Geneva • Beijing-Shanghai fiber link • China quantum satellite Government-sponsored QKD networks: Geneva New YorkCanberra Quantum key distribution companies: Newer companies: • SeQure Net (France) • Infiniquant (Germany) • KETS Quantum Security (UK) • QuNu Labs (India) Notes: • Chinese government is hugely invested (~ $2 billion) • Nothing in Silicon Valley (that I know of)
  • 8. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Quantum technologies Quantum Computing Applications: • Code breaking (Shor’s algorithm) • Quantum simulation (chemistry, materials, drug discovery) • Machine learning Hardware: • Superconducting circuits • Trapped ions • Silicon quantum dots • Many others… Quantum Communication Applications: • Secure communication (quantum key distribution) • Quantum internet Hardware: • Light in optical fiber • Light in free-space Quantum Sensing Applications: • Gravitometry (geo-surveying) • Magnetometry (materials science, MRI) Hardware: • Atomic clocks • NV centers Our research
  • 9. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Why a quantum internet? 1. Allows for parallelized computation. (Computational power scales exponentially with number of processors.) 1. Scaling superconducting quantum processors beyond ~ 1000 qubits impossible with current RF cables. Optical communication provides an alternative. 1. Enables quantum-secured private communication over long distances.
  • 10. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Courtesy of IEEE Spectrum, Google Google Quantum Computing Quantum CommunicationPhotons in optical fibers How can we connect these? Superconducting qubits
  • 11. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University The backbone of the (classical) internet Electro-optic modulators Electro-optic effect: n: refractive index E: electric field r: electro-optic coefficient Light in Signal electro-optic Modulated light out V + - 1 0
  • 12. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University electro-optic L C Microwave input/output Optical fiber input/output Electro-optic conversion Mirrors Resonant LC circuit Qubit processor
  • 13. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Electro-optic converter design Grating (light input) Photo nic crystal mirror Optical resonator Capaci tor Photonic crystal mirror 2 um Grating 10 um Overview 1 mm
  • 14. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Our hardware Dilution refrigerator Converter chip Optical IO Microwave IO
  • 15. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Cryogenic microwave-to-optical conversion Optical power measurement Our first converted photons! Current conversion efficiency is low (<< 1%), but we have ideas to improve it.
  • 16. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Quantum technologies Quantum Computing Applications: • Code breaking (Shor’s algorithm) • Quantum simulation (chemistry, materials, drug discovery) • Machine learning Hardware: • Superconducting circuits • Trapped ions • Silicon quantum dots • Many others… Quantum Communication Applications: • Secure communication (quantum key distribution) • Quantum internet Hardware: • Light in optical fiber • Light in free-space Quantum Sensing Applications: • Gravitometry (geo-surveying) • Magnetometry (materials science, MRI) Hardware: • Atomic clocks • NV centers Our research
  • 17. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Acknowledgements Laboratory for Integrated Nano-Quantum Systems Stanford Graduate Fellowship Stanford Nanofabrication Facility & Stanford Nano Shared Facitilities Collaborators: Prof. Jingdong Luo Prof. Alex Jen Francis Lin (U Washington, City U Hong Kong) Timothy McKenna Raphael Van Laer Patricio Arrangoiz-Arriola Prof. Amir Safavi-Naeini
  • 19. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Conclusions • Electro-optic effect allows us to convert light and microwaves directly • Make converter chip using electro-optic polymer and silicon photonics • Demonstrated microwave-to-optical signal conversion in dilution refrigerator
  • 20. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University What is “quantum key distribution”? Provably secure (unbreakable) assuming the following three conditions: • The key is completely random • The key is as long as the message • The key is never reused Plain-text 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 XOR Alice Bob Secret key Cypher-text One-time pad encryption
  • 21. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Silicon photonics with electro-optic polymers EO polymer properties: • Highly polar chromophore molecule embedded in host polymer • Large electro-optic coefficients: EO polymers: > 400 pm/V (Lithium niobate: 31 pm/V) • Spin coat as final cladding layer → simplifies fabrication • Low optical loss (can be < 1 dB/cm) • Low MW loss (not piezo-electric!) • Must be poled in-device +-
  • 22. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Two operating modes Pump on low-frequency side: Converts microwave photon to optical photon Pump on high-frequency side: Creates entangled microwave and optical photons Freq. pump … Freq. pump …
  • 23. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Next step: high-L spiral inductors Grating coupler Photonic crystal mirror Optical cavity Capacitor High-Z0 spiral inductor High-Z0 spiral inductor 20 um Airbridge process 2 um
  • 24. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Scaling superconducting quantum computers Courtesy of IEEE Spectrum, Google IBM
  • 25. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Connecting quantum computers mm waves? M. Pechal et al, Phys. Rev. A 96, 042305 (2017) Solution: use light!
  • 26. Jeremy Witmer Stanford University Microwave-to-optical different approaches Electro-optics: Schwefel, Painter and Leuchs groups, 2016 Optomechanics: Cleland group, U Chicago, 2016 Also Srivinavasan group, NISTLehnert and Regal groups, CU Boulder, 2014 Magnonics: Nakamura group, Tokyo, 2016 Spin systems: Faraon group, Caltech, 2017