SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Success Online by DesignConceptualizing Successful Online Learning
Assessing ExperienceHow many of you have taught an online course in the past 24 months?How many of you have designed /developed curriculum for online learning environments?How many of you occupy an eLearning administration / oversight position?Does your institution strongly support your eLearning initiatives with faculty training and administrative support?
Setting the SceneWhy are we here? The Paradox:More StudentsMore Suspicion Sloan Consortium Annual Report:Online enrollments up 17% in 20094.6 million students enrolled in 1 or more online courses75% of all institutions report increased demand for online coursesWhy the enrollment trend?  Turn to CNN.
The Value of Online Education?Based on the CNN news report, what values were NOT reflected in the evaluation and promotion of online education? *Convenience, job training, low cost were the values*Confronting the inevitable: when quantity and quality collideSloan Consortium Report ALSO reports:Two-thirds of chief academic officers assert that their faculty reject the “value and legitimacy” of online education70% of faculty assert online courses are inferior to face-to-face courses; 48% of faculty who have taught online assert this as wellWhy is there widespread perception that online courses lack quality?
Why Is There Widespread Perception That Online Courses Lack Quality?Generational issues Early linkage of online courses with correspondence coursesPerception that online courses were developed to accommodate degree-mill industry Lack of embodied face-to-face contact (the socializing element some believe is an important part of higher education)Inability to verify integrity of student work (plagiarism, other people taking your tests for you, etc); Faculty object to the value students place on online learning - cost, flexibility, convenience...these are not the "true" values of higher education.
Demythification2008 National Survey of Student Engagement.
Tests multiple variables of student engagement
On several of the indicators of engagement online students reported significantly better results.
On no indicators did classroom students do so. Relative to classroom students the 2008 NSSE found that online students were significantly more likely to report they
Very often participate in course activities that challenged them intellectually.
Very often participate in discussions that enhanced their understanding of different cultures.
Very often discuss topics of importance to their major.
U.S. Department of Education
Survey of 1000 studies on face-to-face vs online pedagogical practices
Results: Blended and online courses consistently produce better results for student learning than 100% face-to-face instruction The Quest for QualityWhat are the characteristics of quality face-to-face instruction?Should these characteristics be any different for online instruction?The debate over derivative standards.What are the specific demands of online education that require unique quality control standards?
Seven Principles of Good Practice in Undergraduate EducationFOUNDATIONBottom line: meta-practices that you recognize as quality instructional practice face-to-face IS relevant to online environments – but it is just a starting pointGood practice encourages student-faculty contactGood practice encourages cooperation among studentsGood practice encourages active learningGood practice gives prompt feedbackGood practice emphasizes time on taskGood practice communicates high expectationsGood practice respects diverse talents and ways of learning
The Quest for QualityWhat are the specific demands of online education that require unique quality control standards?Accessibility Course navigation Appropriateness of technology Appropriateness of digitally mediated assessment instruments Resources allocated
Three Strategies for Establishing QualityKnowing the emerging industry standards for the purpose of:Initial design considerationsSelf-EvaluationInstitutional EvaluationNew and grounded development in industry-standard design processesMaking sensible decisions regarding class sizeThe ResearchThe variables to consider
Articulating Industry StandardsAdvantages of articulated standards
Provides benchmarks for course development, faculty training
Increases student and faculty confidence in course quality; important for user satisfaction, course transfer and articulation, and accreditation
Examples
State-specific standards (California, etc)

More Related Content

PPTX
Leadership in eLearning: Developing the Next Generation of Leaders
PPTX
California eLearning Census
PPTX
TTitle: A Study of Faculty Governance Leaders' Perceptions of Online and Blen...
PPTX
Fall 2011 Online Reviews: An Interactive Approach
PPTX
Assessment 2 feb sarah davies
PPTX
K-12 Virtual Schools Share their Research Needs (Pt. 1 of 4)
PPTX
Vss2009 Going Virtual III Presentation
PPT
Key elements in successful online faculty development
Leadership in eLearning: Developing the Next Generation of Leaders
California eLearning Census
TTitle: A Study of Faculty Governance Leaders' Perceptions of Online and Blen...
Fall 2011 Online Reviews: An Interactive Approach
Assessment 2 feb sarah davies
K-12 Virtual Schools Share their Research Needs (Pt. 1 of 4)
Vss2009 Going Virtual III Presentation
Key elements in successful online faculty development

What's hot (20)

PDF
How are students actually using technology? EMEA Online Symposium 2020
PPT
PPTX
Quality frameworks for e-learning (SIEAD 2018, Brazil)
PPTX
Using Analytics for Institutional Transformation - Dr. Yvette Mozie-Ross - Un...
PPTX
MCCVLC webinar - Online Program Review
PPTX
Challenges, Trends & Important Developments in Higher Education
PDF
Lessons from 10 years of E-xcellence quality reviews for e-learning
PPTX
March 15 presentation evergreen 3 14 v3
PPTX
Embedding Quality Assurance in Online Course Design (An African Perspective)
PPTX
Online professionaldevelopment[1]
PDF
Analysing students' digital experience: personas and key drivers
PDF
Addressing the question of quality in e learning umass it conference 2008
PPTX
Give them what they want: Participatory approaches to developing anonymous as...
PPTX
Academy of engineering discussion of the implementation study, mary visher-...
PPTX
Students First 2020: Digital Campus, A program to empower & enable digital ed...
PDF
Challenges faced by universities in online education - EMEA Online Symposium ...
PPTX
Rutgers University CHAMP Evaluation presentation 8 24.14
PPT
MCC Blended Learning
PPTX
Lawrick_TechUsePlanEdTech501
PDF
eLearning Introduction at Mountain View College
How are students actually using technology? EMEA Online Symposium 2020
Quality frameworks for e-learning (SIEAD 2018, Brazil)
Using Analytics for Institutional Transformation - Dr. Yvette Mozie-Ross - Un...
MCCVLC webinar - Online Program Review
Challenges, Trends & Important Developments in Higher Education
Lessons from 10 years of E-xcellence quality reviews for e-learning
March 15 presentation evergreen 3 14 v3
Embedding Quality Assurance in Online Course Design (An African Perspective)
Online professionaldevelopment[1]
Analysing students' digital experience: personas and key drivers
Addressing the question of quality in e learning umass it conference 2008
Give them what they want: Participatory approaches to developing anonymous as...
Academy of engineering discussion of the implementation study, mary visher-...
Students First 2020: Digital Campus, A program to empower & enable digital ed...
Challenges faced by universities in online education - EMEA Online Symposium ...
Rutgers University CHAMP Evaluation presentation 8 24.14
MCC Blended Learning
Lawrick_TechUsePlanEdTech501
eLearning Introduction at Mountain View College
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

PPT
Eric Winegardner: Recruiting & Placement Strategies
PPTX
Open access and the South Australian Red Cross Information Bureau: A case stu...
PPT
Governments Powerpoint
PPT
Scotland dr5
PPT
Dr. Connie Johnson: Student Success & MyFoundationsLab
PPTX
Centenary of Anzac
PPTX
Digital storytelling in the ESOL classroom
PPTX
Transforming good experiences into great & engaging user experiences
PPT
Rise Of Napoleon Ch 21 Sec 3 And 4
PPTX
The Dark Knight study
PPT
Xp2 2013版
PPTX
Hooduku - Cloud and Big data practice
PPT
Key Data Sources for Public Health - Local Perspective - Irina Holland
PDF
AS Watson verwerkt haar inkoopfacturen met Basware door ICreative | Referenti...
PPT
09 24 09
PPTX
Radikal Ungdom twitter oplæg
PDF
Taller de creación de documentos ePub
PPTX
Computers a Time Line
Eric Winegardner: Recruiting & Placement Strategies
Open access and the South Australian Red Cross Information Bureau: A case stu...
Governments Powerpoint
Scotland dr5
Dr. Connie Johnson: Student Success & MyFoundationsLab
Centenary of Anzac
Digital storytelling in the ESOL classroom
Transforming good experiences into great & engaging user experiences
Rise Of Napoleon Ch 21 Sec 3 And 4
The Dark Knight study
Xp2 2013版
Hooduku - Cloud and Big data practice
Key Data Sources for Public Health - Local Perspective - Irina Holland
AS Watson verwerkt haar inkoopfacturen met Basware door ICreative | Referenti...
09 24 09
Radikal Ungdom twitter oplæg
Taller de creación de documentos ePub
Computers a Time Line
Ad

Similar to FTCC - Distance Education Track (20)

PPT
Keynote_RonLegon_Online Learning and Student Success
PPTX
Teaching Online
PPT
Strategies 4 Quality
PPT
Vass march2012
PPT
Avoiding Shovelware
PPTX
Quality Online Learning
PPTX
Online Teaching - An Introduction
PPTX
From onsite to online learning contexts
PPT
Best practice strategies for online teaching cswe apm 2010
PDF
Introduction to Online Teaching - Handout Packet
PPT
Best practice strategies for online teaching cswe apm 2010
PPTX
Effective Online Learning
PPSX
Effective Online
PPSX
Effective Online Learning
PPTX
E learning2
PPTX
E learning
PPTX
Best practices in online education ppt
PPTX
San Juan College - Quality in Online Learning
PPTX
Assign8 need for online teachers
PPTX
RE ECHO from prev seminars blahblah.pptx
Keynote_RonLegon_Online Learning and Student Success
Teaching Online
Strategies 4 Quality
Vass march2012
Avoiding Shovelware
Quality Online Learning
Online Teaching - An Introduction
From onsite to online learning contexts
Best practice strategies for online teaching cswe apm 2010
Introduction to Online Teaching - Handout Packet
Best practice strategies for online teaching cswe apm 2010
Effective Online Learning
Effective Online
Effective Online Learning
E learning2
E learning
Best practices in online education ppt
San Juan College - Quality in Online Learning
Assign8 need for online teachers
RE ECHO from prev seminars blahblah.pptx

More from Pearson North America (20)

PPTX
Holistic, Innovative, and Data-Driven Student Success at Southern Illinois Un...
PPTX
Pearson cbe playbook for sxsw 7 16
PDF
Embrace the Shift for SoMe Teaching and Learning
PPT
2013 Social Media in Higher Education Survey Results
PPT
Jeff Borden: Education 3.0: Learn Better
PPTX
Krista Jackman: Twitter and Tweeting; Community and Composition
PPT
2012 Social Media in Higher Education Results
PPT
Rey Junco & Eric Gordon: Social Media for Engaging Multiple Learning Styles
PPT
Pearson social media survey 2011
PPT
Pearson social media survey 2011
PDF
Rob Curtin: Digital Migration Strategies
PPT
Online Learning and Student Success
POTX
Jesse Marquez: Default Prevention
PPTX
2010 PLS Career Summit: Tom Kosel, Director of Government Relations, Globe Un...
PPT
2010 PLS Career Summit: Eric Winegardner, VP of Client Adoptions, Monster.com
PPTX
2010 PLS Career Summit: Rob Curtin, Chief Applications Officer, Microsoft Corp
PDF
2010 PLS Career Summit: Chris Slatter, Senior Analyst, Eduventures
PDF
2010 PLS Career Summit: Seth Reynolds, Parthenon Group
PPT
Pearson Social Media Survey 2010
PPT
FTCC - Executive Leadership Track
Holistic, Innovative, and Data-Driven Student Success at Southern Illinois Un...
Pearson cbe playbook for sxsw 7 16
Embrace the Shift for SoMe Teaching and Learning
2013 Social Media in Higher Education Survey Results
Jeff Borden: Education 3.0: Learn Better
Krista Jackman: Twitter and Tweeting; Community and Composition
2012 Social Media in Higher Education Results
Rey Junco & Eric Gordon: Social Media for Engaging Multiple Learning Styles
Pearson social media survey 2011
Pearson social media survey 2011
Rob Curtin: Digital Migration Strategies
Online Learning and Student Success
Jesse Marquez: Default Prevention
2010 PLS Career Summit: Tom Kosel, Director of Government Relations, Globe Un...
2010 PLS Career Summit: Eric Winegardner, VP of Client Adoptions, Monster.com
2010 PLS Career Summit: Rob Curtin, Chief Applications Officer, Microsoft Corp
2010 PLS Career Summit: Chris Slatter, Senior Analyst, Eduventures
2010 PLS Career Summit: Seth Reynolds, Parthenon Group
Pearson Social Media Survey 2010
FTCC - Executive Leadership Track

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Module 4: Burden of Disease Tutorial Slides S2 2025
PDF
Pre independence Education in Inndia.pdf
PPTX
Final Presentation General Medicine 03-08-2024.pptx
PPTX
human mycosis Human fungal infections are called human mycosis..pptx
PPTX
Pharma ospi slides which help in ospi learning
PPTX
PPH.pptx obstetrics and gynecology in nursing
PDF
Mark Klimek Lecture Notes_240423 revision books _173037.pdf
PPTX
BOWEL ELIMINATION FACTORS AFFECTING AND TYPES
PDF
Complications of Minimal Access Surgery at WLH
PPTX
IMMUNITY IMMUNITY refers to protection against infection, and the immune syst...
PDF
Supply Chain Operations Speaking Notes -ICLT Program
PDF
Chapter 2 Heredity, Prenatal Development, and Birth.pdf
PDF
RMMM.pdf make it easy to upload and study
PDF
Anesthesia in Laparoscopic Surgery in India
PDF
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KỸ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH 9 GLOBAL SUCCESS - CẢ NĂM - BÁM SÁT FORM Đ...
PDF
The Lost Whites of Pakistan by Jahanzaib Mughal.pdf
PDF
O5-L3 Freight Transport Ops (International) V1.pdf
PPTX
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
PPTX
Introduction_to_Human_Anatomy_and_Physiology_for_B.Pharm.pptx
PDF
TR - Agricultural Crops Production NC III.pdf
Module 4: Burden of Disease Tutorial Slides S2 2025
Pre independence Education in Inndia.pdf
Final Presentation General Medicine 03-08-2024.pptx
human mycosis Human fungal infections are called human mycosis..pptx
Pharma ospi slides which help in ospi learning
PPH.pptx obstetrics and gynecology in nursing
Mark Klimek Lecture Notes_240423 revision books _173037.pdf
BOWEL ELIMINATION FACTORS AFFECTING AND TYPES
Complications of Minimal Access Surgery at WLH
IMMUNITY IMMUNITY refers to protection against infection, and the immune syst...
Supply Chain Operations Speaking Notes -ICLT Program
Chapter 2 Heredity, Prenatal Development, and Birth.pdf
RMMM.pdf make it easy to upload and study
Anesthesia in Laparoscopic Surgery in India
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KỸ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH 9 GLOBAL SUCCESS - CẢ NĂM - BÁM SÁT FORM Đ...
The Lost Whites of Pakistan by Jahanzaib Mughal.pdf
O5-L3 Freight Transport Ops (International) V1.pdf
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
Introduction_to_Human_Anatomy_and_Physiology_for_B.Pharm.pptx
TR - Agricultural Crops Production NC III.pdf

FTCC - Distance Education Track

  • 1. Success Online by DesignConceptualizing Successful Online Learning
  • 2. Assessing ExperienceHow many of you have taught an online course in the past 24 months?How many of you have designed /developed curriculum for online learning environments?How many of you occupy an eLearning administration / oversight position?Does your institution strongly support your eLearning initiatives with faculty training and administrative support?
  • 3. Setting the SceneWhy are we here? The Paradox:More StudentsMore Suspicion Sloan Consortium Annual Report:Online enrollments up 17% in 20094.6 million students enrolled in 1 or more online courses75% of all institutions report increased demand for online coursesWhy the enrollment trend? Turn to CNN.
  • 4. The Value of Online Education?Based on the CNN news report, what values were NOT reflected in the evaluation and promotion of online education? *Convenience, job training, low cost were the values*Confronting the inevitable: when quantity and quality collideSloan Consortium Report ALSO reports:Two-thirds of chief academic officers assert that their faculty reject the “value and legitimacy” of online education70% of faculty assert online courses are inferior to face-to-face courses; 48% of faculty who have taught online assert this as wellWhy is there widespread perception that online courses lack quality?
  • 5. Why Is There Widespread Perception That Online Courses Lack Quality?Generational issues Early linkage of online courses with correspondence coursesPerception that online courses were developed to accommodate degree-mill industry Lack of embodied face-to-face contact (the socializing element some believe is an important part of higher education)Inability to verify integrity of student work (plagiarism, other people taking your tests for you, etc); Faculty object to the value students place on online learning - cost, flexibility, convenience...these are not the "true" values of higher education.
  • 6. Demythification2008 National Survey of Student Engagement.
  • 7. Tests multiple variables of student engagement
  • 8. On several of the indicators of engagement online students reported significantly better results.
  • 9. On no indicators did classroom students do so. Relative to classroom students the 2008 NSSE found that online students were significantly more likely to report they
  • 10. Very often participate in course activities that challenged them intellectually.
  • 11. Very often participate in discussions that enhanced their understanding of different cultures.
  • 12. Very often discuss topics of importance to their major.
  • 13. U.S. Department of Education
  • 14. Survey of 1000 studies on face-to-face vs online pedagogical practices
  • 15. Results: Blended and online courses consistently produce better results for student learning than 100% face-to-face instruction The Quest for QualityWhat are the characteristics of quality face-to-face instruction?Should these characteristics be any different for online instruction?The debate over derivative standards.What are the specific demands of online education that require unique quality control standards?
  • 16. Seven Principles of Good Practice in Undergraduate EducationFOUNDATIONBottom line: meta-practices that you recognize as quality instructional practice face-to-face IS relevant to online environments – but it is just a starting pointGood practice encourages student-faculty contactGood practice encourages cooperation among studentsGood practice encourages active learningGood practice gives prompt feedbackGood practice emphasizes time on taskGood practice communicates high expectationsGood practice respects diverse talents and ways of learning
  • 17. The Quest for QualityWhat are the specific demands of online education that require unique quality control standards?Accessibility Course navigation Appropriateness of technology Appropriateness of digitally mediated assessment instruments Resources allocated
  • 18. Three Strategies for Establishing QualityKnowing the emerging industry standards for the purpose of:Initial design considerationsSelf-EvaluationInstitutional EvaluationNew and grounded development in industry-standard design processesMaking sensible decisions regarding class sizeThe ResearchThe variables to consider
  • 19. Articulating Industry StandardsAdvantages of articulated standards
  • 20. Provides benchmarks for course development, faculty training
  • 21. Increases student and faculty confidence in course quality; important for user satisfaction, course transfer and articulation, and accreditation
  • 24. Higher Learning Commission (publishes qualitative data from accreditation reviews related to eLearning best practices; guidance for establishing eLearning consortium)
  • 26. Quality MattersQuality Matters“Quality Matters (QM) is a faculty-centered, peer review process designed to certify the quality of online courses and online components.”
  • 31. 40 Specific Standards85% pass rate required / all mandatory standards must be met
  • 32. Sloan-C ConsortiumThe Sloan Consortium is an institutional and professional leadership organization dedicated to integrating online education into the mainstream of higher education, helping institutions and individual educators improve the quality, scale, and breadth of online education. Membership in the Sloan Consortium provides knowledge, practice, community, and direction for educators. Originally funded by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, Sloan-C is now a non-profit, member sustained organization. Join with Sloan-C to lead higher education in meeting social needs for affordable access, quality innovations, and teaching and learning excellence.Standards Development
  • 35. Instructional Technology TrainingOnline CertificationProperly skilled and trained online teachers will be in high demand, and a consolidated approach to capturing that market with training and certification is well-within the grasp of PLS perhaps more than any other entityIntroduction to Online Learning
  • 37. Instructional Design for Online Learning
  • 38. Promoting Student Success in the Online Learning Environment
  • 39. Assessing Knowledge and Skills in the Online Learning Environment
  • 40. Beyond the Online ClassroomDesign Process: Where to Start?Why instructional design?
  • 41. Learning fails when we don’t know the needs and abilities of the learner
  • 42. Learning fails when we don’t articulate goals of instruction
  • 43. Learning fails when we don’t conceive of specific interventions to bridge the gap between needs, abilities, and goals.
  • 44. Many design models are applicable to eCourses development. Here are but two successful design approaches that emphasize quality design as a prerequisite to student success
  • 47. Backward DesignConceive of desired results first, then work backward to develop instructional content and strategies (rather than beginning with topics)Stage 1: Identify desired outcomes and results.Stage 2: Determine what constitutes acceptable evidence of competency in the outcomes and results (assessment).Stage 3: Plan instructional strategies and learning experiences that bring students to these competency levels.** Understanding By Design**
  • 48. MyCourseTools Thousands of assets that can be supplied for custom course augmentationAnimationsSimulationsVideosPuzzlesAudio GlossariesWeb ResearchPodcastsTutorialsDrag/Drop ActivitiesPowerPointsAssessmentsOnline Games
  • 49. Quality Objections: Class SizeWhy does your college push eLearning?
  • 53. More efficient use of adjuncts
  • 57. Push higher numbers because of retention issues
  • 58. Quantity vs. quality is crux of issueClass Size ResearchSurprisingly, this is remains a poorly researched question.NEA research (2000, 2004)31% online courses have1-20 students33% online courses have 21-40 students17% online courses have 41+ students19% (unknown reporting)Prevailing wisdom for online class size: maximize student interaction to promote learning community (15-25 students)*However, recent studies indicate: Higher class sizes may yield more significant interaction between students, and significant interaction positively correlates with higher grade performance.
  • 59. Class size considerationsTechnology and technology support (LMS capacity, Help Desk support, sophistication of courseware, etc)
  • 60. Assessment strategies and time resources
  • 64. Tutorial oriented (courseware and technology as content provider)
  • 65. Instructor oriented (faculty as content provider) Managing Interaction in Large Online ClassesFrom the Sloan Consortium: Effective Practices for Managing High Enrollment Online CoursesInformation organization and retrievalSynchronization of class activitiesCoordination, collaboration, and socializing among course participantsSharing knowledgeSharing learning and feedbackRequiring participation
  • 66. Designing SuccessRemember:As educators, our primary goal is to create learning environments that foster student achievement.The value of design and evaluation standardsNo ID dept, a ton of moneyTake the best of all the different strategies and create something customized to your comfort level---at the end of the day, its your courseStart to emphasize quality more in an era that places a premium on quantityCommitting to standards requires time and energy. However, this use of your resources not only enhances the likelihood of genuine learning and student satisfaction but also provides verification of the great work you already do!

Editor's Notes

  • #3: This should create a pyramid. Many will have taught online…fewer will be well-supported. Use this exercise to suggest that “many of us are tasked with teaching online, fewer of us have development experience, and fewer still feel well-supported” Here’s the bottom line: Most community college faculty are pressured to teach online BUT they feel they lack grants/money/incentives to support design and development, they have no targets for quality standards, and they are concerned about time resources for development and maintenance of online courses. So, your role here is to be suggestive of tools/considerations for self-starters.
  • #4: Hyperlinks = professor overview of report’s findings AND a CNN report on the attraction to online education in bad economic times. Use the next few slides to establish urgency…there are more online students than ever before, and there is more doubt than ever before about the validity of this modality.
  • #5: Quality was not mentioned in the CNN clip….convenience, job training, cost were the values. Not quality.
  • #6: Quality was not mentioned in the CNN clip….convenience, job training, cost were the values. Not quality.
  • #7: Use this slide to establish that, in fact, the industry is showing some great promise. Quality can be achieved, as can student success.
  • #8: Get them thinking about what constitutes quality in general. Use Q/A. Then, once they brainstorm, use the next slide to demonstrate that fundamentals are fundamentals and that best practices for instruction, in general, are achievable in eLearning.
  • #9: Arthur W. Chickering's and Zelda F. Gamson's book entitled, Seven Principles for Good Practice in Undergraduate Education
  • #10: Get them thinking about what constitutes quality in general. Use Q/A. Then, once they brainstorm, use the next slide to demonstrate that fundamentals are fundamentals and that best practices for instruction, in general, are achievable in eLearning.
  • #11: Use this as the framing slide for what you are delivering to the audience
  • #12: Sending you a PDF file containing HLC best practices. Just use as an example of published guidelines so people understand that there are specific, industry standard resources available.
  • #16: Remember, 99% of higher ed faculty have NO background in ID or pedagogy. Equipping them with a basic framework might be helpful. Provide a design document sample to illustrate the application of a design model to a development process.
  • #18: Provide examples of design documents
  • #21: * Palloff, R. & Pratt, K. (1999) Building Learning Communities in Cyberspace. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers
  • #23: Information organization and retrieval: Carefully structure course activities into different conferences or discussion forums, so that all of the information in one conference relates to a small number of topics, and no single conference gets so large that it is difficult to find information within that conference. Synchronization of the class as a whole: Set clear guidelines that tells students what needs to be done, where, and when so that the students are focusing on the same activities at the same time. Strictly enforce these guidelines to maintain the order laid out in the conference organization. Coordination, collaboration, and socializing among the members: A key instructor role is to motivate, encourage, and facilitate authentic, active and collaborative interaction among the students. Frequent (ideally daily) instructor activity helps to create a socially welcoming environment. Another critical strategy is establishing and enforcing a course structure that can accommodate high levels of interaction without creating an information overload, as well as support levels of trust required for open expression of views. Such a structure enables students to realize that their active participation supports content mastery, higher grades, and overall learning. The software used should enable students to have their own private conferences for doing group work. Sharing knowledge: Upper division and graduate courses usually have a mix of students with and without considerable working experience, so 'contextualized learning' is important: promote the relevance between experience and learning by teaching experienced students course concepts in the context of their real life experiences. These students then can bring these understandings to the rest of the class. Students then take what the course professor has to say far more seriously. Sharing learning and feedback: Particularly in courses with many abstract concepts, encouraging students to make experiential associations by elaborating course concepts in their own frames of reference helps the instructor to better gauge teaching effectiveness. Students may understand other students' representations and understandings better than the ones the instructor use. This is a form of the Montessori effect, i.e., having students help other students and thus minimizing instructor workload in the process. Requiring participation: Grade students on the quality and timeliness of their contributions rather than quantity (number or size) of their contributions. In the case study courses, 'required' (i.e. specified based on assignment) and 'voluntary' (i.e., discretionary) contributions each accounted for 10% of the total course grade.