SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1
Philippe Beauchamp
OPAL-RT Technologies
philippe.beauchamp@opal-rt.com
Real-Time Simulation for Cyber-Security
2
Challenges in 1980
Modern and SMART transmission systems
rely on control and protection systems
For performance, security and economical reasons
• Fast machine AVR and PSS
• SVC and FACTS
• HVDC transmission and interconnections
• Fast local protection and automatic systems
• wide area special control and protection (SPS)
Québec
> 1000 km
> 1500 km
AC/DC SMARTPower system transmission-
challenges : optimizing controls, protection, FACTS, HVDC
to increase performance and reliability at minimum cost
3
Evolution of Integrated Power Systems :
from passive to SMART Active distribution systems
Passive loads and distribution systems
AC/DC, FACTS, SPS
Transmission
Distribution
Distribution are becoming as complex and dependent on control
performance as transmission network are.
 Renewable energy systems (solar, wind, etc) are less preditable
 Use of power electronics such as HVDCs, FACTS, fast protection system
 Use of wide area control and protection systems (SPS)
 Security and performance relies on more complex controls and protection
 How do you design and test them s an integrated system with the grid
4
• Reliability
• Security
• Efficiency
• Eco Friendly
5
6
7
8
9
Risk = Threat x Vulnerability x Consequence
Threat
• Human Error
• Hacker
• Spy
• Weather
Vulnerability
• Design flaw
• System failure
• Cascading event
• System complexity
• # of vendors
• # of devices
• Testing flaws
• Cascading events
• Aging components
Consequence
• Reduced system reliability
• Economic losses
• Equipment losses
• Human losses
• Sensitive data exposure
10
PDC
ePHASORsim
HYPERSIM
eMEGAsim
EMT
311
Low Voltage (±5V)
311
120V – 5A
Amplifier C37.118
C37.118
Control Prototyping
State Estimation
C37.118 C37.118
Telecom Simulation
311
IEC 61850 – (SV)
IEC 61850 – (GOOSE)
Control Commands
DNP3, OPC, TCP/IP
Virtual Grid
config
11
OPAL-RT Communication Protocols
12
311
311
Denial of Service (DOS)
PDC
Simulated Grid
13
Man in the middle (MiM)
311
311
PDC
Telecom
Simulated Grid
14
GPS spoofing (clock screw)
311
311
Simulated Grid
234d 23h54 00s 0000us
234d 23h54 00s 0100us
15
GPS spoofing (clock screw)
311
311
Simulated Grid
234d 23h54 00s 0000us
234d 23h54 00s 0100us
Simulated GPS
Control
16
Detection (State estimation)
311
311
• Delays
• Noise
• Data Losses
• Packet Injection
PDC
State
Estimation
Validation
Custom C-Code
Machine Learning
HMM
Kalman Filters
Support vectors
Statistics
Prbabilities
17
Case 1
Case 2
Case 3
Case 100 000
…
18
19
KTH Royal Institute of Technology – WAMPAC Laboratory
SEL421 - PMU
OP5600
eMEGAsim
ABB – Line Distance
- PMU
Megger V/I
Amplifiers
SEL3373 - PDC
Arbiter Master GPS
Subs. Clock
GPS Antenna
Network Switch
Communication
Server
Opnet, Synchrowave
20
• DNP3
• IEC60870-5-104
• IEC61850
• IEC61850-8-1 GOOSE
• IEC61850-9-2 SV
• Modbus
• C37.118
21
powerNET
ePHASORsim
Cyber Security Test Bed at PNNL
22
• Smart grid and Wide Area Controls (WACS) testing
• PMU «Phase Measurment Unit»
• PDC «Phasor Data Concentrator»
• SSU «Substation Synchronous Unit»
> Local controls & Specific Protection System (SPS) testing
• LID, OLD, RPS, SMCT, MB-PSS, Protection relays
Smart grid, Wide-Area Control Systems and Specific Protection System
23
Real-Time Simulated Grid
Up to 20 000 Nodes (Phasor)
OPC Client
(ETAP Server)
1 Licence
OPAL-RT Simulator
Suggested
PMU/Relays
Integration
ETAP Clients
OPAL-RT
OPC Server
ePHASORsim
24
Microgrid Simulation Combined with OPNET
25
What can be learned from automotive industry
Hardware in the Loop
for over 20 years
26
I/O Channels
(V and I meas.)
PMUs
RT-LAB
I/O
Manager
Simulated
Telecommunication
Ie: OPNET
GUI
(RTDMS, ETAP, RT-LAB)
Wide Area
Controller
Simulated GRID
(HYPERSIM, ePHASORsim, SPS)
RT-LAB Next Gen

More Related Content

PDF
RT15 Berkeley | ePHASORsim: Real-time transient stability simulation tool - O...
PPTX
Power Grid Cybersecurity
PDF
RT15 Berkeley | OPAL-RT Solutions for Microgrid Applications
PDF
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Microgrid Demos
PDF
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar Introduction
PPTX
RT15 Berkeley | ARTEMiS-SSN Features for Micro-grid / Renewable Energy Sourc...
PDF
Webinar | HIL-based Wide-area Monitoring, Protection and Control R&D and Testing
PDF
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Virtualizing Industrial Control Systems ...
RT15 Berkeley | ePHASORsim: Real-time transient stability simulation tool - O...
Power Grid Cybersecurity
RT15 Berkeley | OPAL-RT Solutions for Microgrid Applications
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Microgrid Demos
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar Introduction
RT15 Berkeley | ARTEMiS-SSN Features for Micro-grid / Renewable Energy Sourc...
Webinar | HIL-based Wide-area Monitoring, Protection and Control R&D and Testing
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Virtualizing Industrial Control Systems ...

What's hot (20)

PDF
RT15 Berkeley | HYPERSIM - OPAL-RT
PDF
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Using OPAL-RT Real-Time Simulation and H...
PPT
OPAL-RT | Setup and Performance of a Combined Hardware-in-loop and Software-i...
PDF
RT15 Berkeley | Real-Time Simulation of A Modular Multilevel Converter Based ...
PPT
OPAL-RT and RTDS Technologies Co-Simulation
PDF
RT15 Berkeley | Power HIL Simulator (SimP) A prototype to develop a high band...
PDF
RT15 Berkeley | Introduction to FPGA Power Electronic & Electric Machine real...
PDF
RT15 Berkeley | Multi-Terminal Power Hardware-in-the-Loop Test-Bench for Powe...
PPTX
Rapid Control Prototyping Solutions
PDF
OPAL-RT Seminar on HYPERSIM
PDF
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Volt/Var Optimization Scheme f...
PDF
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Residential Battery Storage Systems. Des...
PDF
RT15 Berkeley | Optimized Power Flow Control in Microgrids - Sandia Laboratory
PDF
RT15 Berkeley | Power Grid Simulation and Beyond at PNNL
PDF
RT15 Berkeley | Grid Intergration Group - Lawrence Berkeley National Lab
PDF
RT15 Berkeley | NI / OPAL-RT Power Electronics HIL Teaching Laboratory - Nati...
PDF
RT15 Berkeley | Enel Distribuzione activities and Real-Time simulations exper...
PDF
RT15 Berkeley | End-to-End Simulation Solution for Smart Grids Applications -...
PDF
OPAL-RT Model-In-the-Loop real-time simulation
PDF
Smart grid and wide area monitoring
RT15 Berkeley | HYPERSIM - OPAL-RT
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Using OPAL-RT Real-Time Simulation and H...
OPAL-RT | Setup and Performance of a Combined Hardware-in-loop and Software-i...
RT15 Berkeley | Real-Time Simulation of A Modular Multilevel Converter Based ...
OPAL-RT and RTDS Technologies Co-Simulation
RT15 Berkeley | Power HIL Simulator (SimP) A prototype to develop a high band...
RT15 Berkeley | Introduction to FPGA Power Electronic & Electric Machine real...
RT15 Berkeley | Multi-Terminal Power Hardware-in-the-Loop Test-Bench for Powe...
Rapid Control Prototyping Solutions
OPAL-RT Seminar on HYPERSIM
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Volt/Var Optimization Scheme f...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Residential Battery Storage Systems. Des...
RT15 Berkeley | Optimized Power Flow Control in Microgrids - Sandia Laboratory
RT15 Berkeley | Power Grid Simulation and Beyond at PNNL
RT15 Berkeley | Grid Intergration Group - Lawrence Berkeley National Lab
RT15 Berkeley | NI / OPAL-RT Power Electronics HIL Teaching Laboratory - Nati...
RT15 Berkeley | Enel Distribuzione activities and Real-Time simulations exper...
RT15 Berkeley | End-to-End Simulation Solution for Smart Grids Applications -...
OPAL-RT Model-In-the-Loop real-time simulation
Smart grid and wide area monitoring
Ad

Viewers also liked (13)

PPSX
Lab-Scale MMC Test Bench
PDF
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Conclusion
PDF
Webinar | HIL Testing of Electric Transportation
PDF
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
PDF
Aerospace Project Integration at OPAL-RT
PDF
Performance improvement of parallel active power filters using droop control ...
PPTX
OPAL-RT RT14: Running OPAL-RT's eHS solver on NI cRIO
PDF
OPAL-RT RT13: OP5600 & OP7000 hardware
PDF
OPAL-RT RT14: MMC in RT-LAB
PDF
OPAL-RT Webinar - MMC RCP HIL Solutions
PDF
Modular Multilevel Converter MMC tutorial
PDF
Comparison of Non-real-time and Real-time Simulators with Relays-in-the-Loop ...
PPT
Gps-signal
Lab-Scale MMC Test Bench
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Conclusion
Webinar | HIL Testing of Electric Transportation
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
Aerospace Project Integration at OPAL-RT
Performance improvement of parallel active power filters using droop control ...
OPAL-RT RT14: Running OPAL-RT's eHS solver on NI cRIO
OPAL-RT RT13: OP5600 & OP7000 hardware
OPAL-RT RT14: MMC in RT-LAB
OPAL-RT Webinar - MMC RCP HIL Solutions
Modular Multilevel Converter MMC tutorial
Comparison of Non-real-time and Real-time Simulators with Relays-in-the-Loop ...
Gps-signal
Ad

Similar to RT15 Berkeley | Real-time simulation as a prime tool for Cybersecurity - OPAL-RT (20)

PPTX
Open Source Software Tools for Synchrophasor Applications
PDF
OPAL-RT Modern power systems
PPSX
HYPERSIM Relay Protection Webinar
PDF
OPAL-RT Webinar - Challenges in Protection Relay Testing
PPTX
Towards CIM-Compliant Model-Based Cyber-Physical Power System Design and Simu...
PPTX
Towards CIM Compliant Model-Based Cyber-Physical Power System Design and Simu...
PDF
Industry outlook_ ABB.pdf
PDF
Power system and communication network co simulation for smart grid applications
PDF
OPAL-RT Webinar - HYPERSIM
PDF
Real time co-simulation platform using opal-rt and opnet for analyzing smart ...
PDF
OPAL-RT HYPERSIM Features applied for Relay Testing
PDF
Making The Smart Grid Smarter
PPTX
Computer Application in Power system chapter one - introduction
PDF
23 9754 assessment paper id 0023 (ed l)2
PPTX
2.4_Overview of Microgrid Research, Development, and Resiliency Analysis_Hovs...
PDF
Challenges of Parallel Simulation of Power Systems_english
PDF
chapter-- one Introduction to Computer application in power systemn
PPTX
CPSSecurityBITSWorkshopDec15.2012 (1).pptx
PPTX
Cps security bitsworkshopdec15.2012 (1)
PDF
OPAL-RT ePHASORsim Webinar
Open Source Software Tools for Synchrophasor Applications
OPAL-RT Modern power systems
HYPERSIM Relay Protection Webinar
OPAL-RT Webinar - Challenges in Protection Relay Testing
Towards CIM-Compliant Model-Based Cyber-Physical Power System Design and Simu...
Towards CIM Compliant Model-Based Cyber-Physical Power System Design and Simu...
Industry outlook_ ABB.pdf
Power system and communication network co simulation for smart grid applications
OPAL-RT Webinar - HYPERSIM
Real time co-simulation platform using opal-rt and opnet for analyzing smart ...
OPAL-RT HYPERSIM Features applied for Relay Testing
Making The Smart Grid Smarter
Computer Application in Power system chapter one - introduction
23 9754 assessment paper id 0023 (ed l)2
2.4_Overview of Microgrid Research, Development, and Resiliency Analysis_Hovs...
Challenges of Parallel Simulation of Power Systems_english
chapter-- one Introduction to Computer application in power systemn
CPSSecurityBITSWorkshopDec15.2012 (1).pptx
Cps security bitsworkshopdec15.2012 (1)
OPAL-RT ePHASORsim Webinar

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Enhancing Cyber Defense Against Zero-Day Attacks using Ensemble Neural Networks
PDF
SM_6th-Sem__Cse_Internet-of-Things.pdf IOT
PPT
Project quality management in manufacturing
PDF
Evaluating the Democratization of the Turkish Armed Forces from a Normative P...
PPTX
Engineering Ethics, Safety and Environment [Autosaved] (1).pptx
PPTX
IOT PPTs Week 10 Lecture Material.pptx of NPTEL Smart Cities contd
PPTX
CYBER-CRIMES AND SECURITY A guide to understanding
PPTX
additive manufacturing of ss316l using mig welding
PPTX
KTU 2019 -S7-MCN 401 MODULE 2-VINAY.pptx
PDF
July 2025 - Top 10 Read Articles in International Journal of Software Enginee...
PDF
BMEC211 - INTRODUCTION TO MECHATRONICS-1.pdf
PPTX
Geodesy 1.pptx...............................................
PDF
Well-logging-methods_new................
PDF
Embodied AI: Ushering in the Next Era of Intelligent Systems
PDF
Automation-in-Manufacturing-Chapter-Introduction.pdf
PDF
Operating System & Kernel Study Guide-1 - converted.pdf
PPTX
Infosys Presentation by1.Riyan Bagwan 2.Samadhan Naiknavare 3.Gaurav Shinde 4...
PPTX
CH1 Production IntroductoryConcepts.pptx
DOCX
573137875-Attendance-Management-System-original
PPTX
Internet of Things (IOT) - A guide to understanding
Enhancing Cyber Defense Against Zero-Day Attacks using Ensemble Neural Networks
SM_6th-Sem__Cse_Internet-of-Things.pdf IOT
Project quality management in manufacturing
Evaluating the Democratization of the Turkish Armed Forces from a Normative P...
Engineering Ethics, Safety and Environment [Autosaved] (1).pptx
IOT PPTs Week 10 Lecture Material.pptx of NPTEL Smart Cities contd
CYBER-CRIMES AND SECURITY A guide to understanding
additive manufacturing of ss316l using mig welding
KTU 2019 -S7-MCN 401 MODULE 2-VINAY.pptx
July 2025 - Top 10 Read Articles in International Journal of Software Enginee...
BMEC211 - INTRODUCTION TO MECHATRONICS-1.pdf
Geodesy 1.pptx...............................................
Well-logging-methods_new................
Embodied AI: Ushering in the Next Era of Intelligent Systems
Automation-in-Manufacturing-Chapter-Introduction.pdf
Operating System & Kernel Study Guide-1 - converted.pdf
Infosys Presentation by1.Riyan Bagwan 2.Samadhan Naiknavare 3.Gaurav Shinde 4...
CH1 Production IntroductoryConcepts.pptx
573137875-Attendance-Management-System-original
Internet of Things (IOT) - A guide to understanding

RT15 Berkeley | Real-time simulation as a prime tool for Cybersecurity - OPAL-RT

  • 2. 2 Challenges in 1980 Modern and SMART transmission systems rely on control and protection systems For performance, security and economical reasons • Fast machine AVR and PSS • SVC and FACTS • HVDC transmission and interconnections • Fast local protection and automatic systems • wide area special control and protection (SPS) Québec > 1000 km > 1500 km AC/DC SMARTPower system transmission- challenges : optimizing controls, protection, FACTS, HVDC to increase performance and reliability at minimum cost
  • 3. 3 Evolution of Integrated Power Systems : from passive to SMART Active distribution systems Passive loads and distribution systems AC/DC, FACTS, SPS Transmission Distribution Distribution are becoming as complex and dependent on control performance as transmission network are.  Renewable energy systems (solar, wind, etc) are less preditable  Use of power electronics such as HVDCs, FACTS, fast protection system  Use of wide area control and protection systems (SPS)  Security and performance relies on more complex controls and protection  How do you design and test them s an integrated system with the grid
  • 4. 4 • Reliability • Security • Efficiency • Eco Friendly
  • 5. 5
  • 6. 6
  • 7. 7
  • 8. 8
  • 9. 9 Risk = Threat x Vulnerability x Consequence Threat • Human Error • Hacker • Spy • Weather Vulnerability • Design flaw • System failure • Cascading event • System complexity • # of vendors • # of devices • Testing flaws • Cascading events • Aging components Consequence • Reduced system reliability • Economic losses • Equipment losses • Human losses • Sensitive data exposure
  • 10. 10 PDC ePHASORsim HYPERSIM eMEGAsim EMT 311 Low Voltage (±5V) 311 120V – 5A Amplifier C37.118 C37.118 Control Prototyping State Estimation C37.118 C37.118 Telecom Simulation 311 IEC 61850 – (SV) IEC 61850 – (GOOSE) Control Commands DNP3, OPC, TCP/IP Virtual Grid config
  • 12. 12 311 311 Denial of Service (DOS) PDC Simulated Grid
  • 13. 13 Man in the middle (MiM) 311 311 PDC Telecom Simulated Grid
  • 14. 14 GPS spoofing (clock screw) 311 311 Simulated Grid 234d 23h54 00s 0000us 234d 23h54 00s 0100us
  • 15. 15 GPS spoofing (clock screw) 311 311 Simulated Grid 234d 23h54 00s 0000us 234d 23h54 00s 0100us Simulated GPS Control
  • 16. 16 Detection (State estimation) 311 311 • Delays • Noise • Data Losses • Packet Injection PDC State Estimation Validation Custom C-Code Machine Learning HMM Kalman Filters Support vectors Statistics Prbabilities
  • 17. 17 Case 1 Case 2 Case 3 Case 100 000 …
  • 18. 18
  • 19. 19 KTH Royal Institute of Technology – WAMPAC Laboratory SEL421 - PMU OP5600 eMEGAsim ABB – Line Distance - PMU Megger V/I Amplifiers SEL3373 - PDC Arbiter Master GPS Subs. Clock GPS Antenna Network Switch Communication Server Opnet, Synchrowave
  • 20. 20 • DNP3 • IEC60870-5-104 • IEC61850 • IEC61850-8-1 GOOSE • IEC61850-9-2 SV • Modbus • C37.118
  • 22. 22 • Smart grid and Wide Area Controls (WACS) testing • PMU «Phase Measurment Unit» • PDC «Phasor Data Concentrator» • SSU «Substation Synchronous Unit» > Local controls & Specific Protection System (SPS) testing • LID, OLD, RPS, SMCT, MB-PSS, Protection relays Smart grid, Wide-Area Control Systems and Specific Protection System
  • 23. 23 Real-Time Simulated Grid Up to 20 000 Nodes (Phasor) OPC Client (ETAP Server) 1 Licence OPAL-RT Simulator Suggested PMU/Relays Integration ETAP Clients OPAL-RT OPC Server ePHASORsim
  • 25. 25 What can be learned from automotive industry Hardware in the Loop for over 20 years
  • 26. 26 I/O Channels (V and I meas.) PMUs RT-LAB I/O Manager Simulated Telecommunication Ie: OPNET GUI (RTDMS, ETAP, RT-LAB) Wide Area Controller Simulated GRID (HYPERSIM, ePHASORsim, SPS) RT-LAB Next Gen