SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Is appraisal really
dead?
How to deliver
sustained high
performance through
people.
Lucinda Carney C.Psychol
lucinda@actus.co.uk
@actusappraisal
Lucinda Carney
Professionally
• Chartered Psychologist
• Senior HR/L&D Background
in Pharma & Telco till 2009
• People and Performance
Management & Culture
Change Consultancy
• Founder Actus™
performance management
software
Personally
• Married with two children
• Back to netball player
• Passionate about making a
difference
How is the annual performance review
viewed in your organisation?
A: It is a strategic imperative
B: Taken seriously but can be “de-prioritised”
C: It’s a painful tick box exercise
D: Non existent
Why is it so painful?
• Backward looking
• A snapshot in time
• Nothing results from it
• People go through the motions
• People comply rather than see it as valuable
• Doesn’t promote ownership
The focus is all wrong
We need to focus on Performance Achievement not
Performance Review
Lets take a look
at the evidence
Research Review: What
really drives performance
Conducted by:
Dr Nuno da Camara
Lecturer in HR and
Organisational Behaviour
at Southampton Business
School
What are the biggest people challenges in
your organisation currently?
• Recruiting the right people
• Retaining the right people
• Productivity and performance
• Management capability
• Employee engagement
• Something else?
What effective performance
management looks like
Cogs image with 8 items
Goal setting
Transparent communication
Coaching & development
Feedback and recognition
Strategic alignment
Reward for performance
Trained managers
Climate of trust
Making the links
Quality People
Management
Organisational
Performance
Consistent
People &
Performance
Management
Transparency
& Culture of
Trust
Clear
Goals
Feedback
and
Recognition
Trained
Managers
Employee
Engagement
Performance
Management
Induction
It is all about ongoing, meaningful
dialogue
Organisations with a Performance
Achievement Culture are…
51% more likely to outperform their
competitors on financial measures
41% more likely to outperform their
competitors on nonfinancial measures
Cascio (2011)
But how do we convince the ‘fluffy’ brigade
‘Engagement is now an accepted leading indicator
of next year’s financial results’
Human Capital Institute; 2010
We have to speak their language
Profitability
Sainsbury’s found higher
levels of engagement linked
directly to sales performance
contributing up to 15% of a
store’s year on year growth.
Productivity
International Gallup survey
showed that individuals with
the highest engagement scores
averaged 18% higher
productivity than those in the
bottom quartile.
Safety
Levels of employee
engagement directly correlate
with absenteeism and patient
mortality in the NHS
Absenteeism & Retention
Hay found companies with
high levels of engagement
show turnover rates 40% lower
than companies with low
levels of engagement.
Source: Engage for Success “The Evidence” & The Kings Fund Nov 2012
We have to align HR & OD with the needs
of the organisation to gain real
sponsorship
Clear
Expectations
and Goals
Regular
Feedback
and support
Performance
Achievement
Focus
More Donors
More Lives
Saved
High
Performing
Charity
Practical take aways!
• Replace performance review with performance achievement make it
future focused and all year round
• Gain sponsorship for HRM – link it to organisational outcomes
• Motivate good management practice - make people management
important, set clear expectations and monitor them
• Recruit managers with the ‘people gene’ & upskill them
• Be a passionate change leader rather than a custodian of process
Discussion points or questions?
Contact me: Lucinda@advancechange.co.uk
Tweet to us @actusappraisal
www.actus.co.uk
Would you like a copy of
the research?
To download the Research
Review or any of our free
thought leadership, manager
guides or white papers follow
this link to the Knowledge Bank
and help yourself!:
https://actus.co.uk/register-
page/

More Related Content

PPTX
The Future of Work
PPTX
Talent Branding
PPTX
Hidden Talent
PPTX
Recruiting for Values
PPTX
#FIRMday Manchester 9th March 2017 - Broadbean: Social Referral Presentation
PPTX
IBM: The Future of Work is Here: Is the people function 'fit for purpose'?
PDF
Developing a winning strategy for hr in 2021 final
PDF
Establishing an efficient in-house recruiting team in a larger region | Talen...
The Future of Work
Talent Branding
Hidden Talent
Recruiting for Values
#FIRMday Manchester 9th March 2017 - Broadbean: Social Referral Presentation
IBM: The Future of Work is Here: Is the people function 'fit for purpose'?
Developing a winning strategy for hr in 2021 final
Establishing an efficient in-house recruiting team in a larger region | Talen...

What's hot (20)

PPTX
#FIRMday Manchester 9th March 2017: WilsonHCG 'Employment Branding Evolution ...
PPTX
10 Tips to Transition from Reactive to Proactive Recruitment | Talent Connect...
PPTX
Reactive to Proactive Recruitment: Managing the Phases of Change | Talent Con...
PDF
Achieving excellence gen towards building a continuous improvement culture
PPTX
Coffee with Cornerstone: How to Deliver Training to Franchisees and Dealers
PDF
The Talent Measurement Effect
PDF
Three insights that will define your recruiting strategy in 2017 | Talent Con...
PPTX
Shifting Away From Annual Performance Reviews to Increase Productivity and En...
PDF
Building an Employee Experience Team
PDF
Cielo's 2016 Talent Rising Summit - Defining Success in Modern Talent Acquisi...
PPTX
An Agency's Journey to Unified Talent Management
PPTX
Troubleshooting Recruiting: A Location Agnostic Approach to Attracting and Re...
PPTX
PepsiCo Talent Acquisition "Refresh"
PDF
Study on the role of consultancy in Bridging gap between Students and industry.
PPTX
#dubcham Talent Management Presentation by PWC
PDF
The State of Employee Recognition in the UK: A 2015 Research Study
PPTX
IHRM trends
PPTX
Emerging Trends in Learning & Performance: Shift Your Performance Discussions...
PPTX
#FIRMday Manchester 9th March: Sofology 'Turning candidates into brand advoca...
PPTX
Troubleshooting Recruiting: How To Recruit More Women Into Your Workforce
#FIRMday Manchester 9th March 2017: WilsonHCG 'Employment Branding Evolution ...
10 Tips to Transition from Reactive to Proactive Recruitment | Talent Connect...
Reactive to Proactive Recruitment: Managing the Phases of Change | Talent Con...
Achieving excellence gen towards building a continuous improvement culture
Coffee with Cornerstone: How to Deliver Training to Franchisees and Dealers
The Talent Measurement Effect
Three insights that will define your recruiting strategy in 2017 | Talent Con...
Shifting Away From Annual Performance Reviews to Increase Productivity and En...
Building an Employee Experience Team
Cielo's 2016 Talent Rising Summit - Defining Success in Modern Talent Acquisi...
An Agency's Journey to Unified Talent Management
Troubleshooting Recruiting: A Location Agnostic Approach to Attracting and Re...
PepsiCo Talent Acquisition "Refresh"
Study on the role of consultancy in Bridging gap between Students and industry.
#dubcham Talent Management Presentation by PWC
The State of Employee Recognition in the UK: A 2015 Research Study
IHRM trends
Emerging Trends in Learning & Performance: Shift Your Performance Discussions...
#FIRMday Manchester 9th March: Sofology 'Turning candidates into brand advoca...
Troubleshooting Recruiting: How To Recruit More Women Into Your Workforce
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

PDF
Innovation Spotlight: SmartRecruiters
PPTX
Candidate Experience, Tech, & the Human Story
PPTX
Better technology for better cloud
PPTX
TLC Manchester - Russell Beck, Impellam
PPTX
Surviving the downturn – How to keep your key players and help them help you!...
PPTX
Candidate experience - Emy Rumble-Mettle
PPTX
The Job Market Report: Banking, Finance & Fintech
PPTX
Bill Boorman
PPTX
Candidate engagement.the candidate experience awards - Elaine Orler
PPTX
Getting goosebumps with your EVP
PPTX
Innovation Spotlight: Jobvite
PPTX
Creating a winning Candidate Experience - Telefónica Case Study
PPTX
How to Win the War for Graduate Talent
PPTX
TLC London - Kevin Blair, Cisco
PPTX
Millennials – the me, me, me generation!
PPTX
Innovation Spotlight: TheJobPost Lenna Thompson, Account Director, TheJobPost
PPTX
Using Data to Build an Effective Talent Acquisition Strategy
PDF
Unleashing the Tiger: a Journey of Employer Branding
PPTX
Surviving and Thriving in Times of Change Julia Kermode, Chief Executive, Fre...
PPTX
Taking Happiness into Account
Innovation Spotlight: SmartRecruiters
Candidate Experience, Tech, & the Human Story
Better technology for better cloud
TLC Manchester - Russell Beck, Impellam
Surviving the downturn – How to keep your key players and help them help you!...
Candidate experience - Emy Rumble-Mettle
The Job Market Report: Banking, Finance & Fintech
Bill Boorman
Candidate engagement.the candidate experience awards - Elaine Orler
Getting goosebumps with your EVP
Innovation Spotlight: Jobvite
Creating a winning Candidate Experience - Telefónica Case Study
How to Win the War for Graduate Talent
TLC London - Kevin Blair, Cisco
Millennials – the me, me, me generation!
Innovation Spotlight: TheJobPost Lenna Thompson, Account Director, TheJobPost
Using Data to Build an Effective Talent Acquisition Strategy
Unleashing the Tiger: a Journey of Employer Branding
Surviving and Thriving in Times of Change Julia Kermode, Chief Executive, Fre...
Taking Happiness into Account
Ad

Similar to What Really Drives Employee Performance (20)

PDF
TPP HR Seminar Sep 16
PPT
MIS Capabilities
PDF
Why asking why is so important for organisational improvement
PDF
Why Volunteering Programs are no longer just for Large Companies
PDF
Employee Engagement, and why it matters to the Experiential Marketing Industry
PPTX
Employee engagement webinar
PPTX
How Senior Leadership Engage/Disengage in Nonprofits
PPTX
Transforming your organisation
PPTX
Bluprints presentation
PPTX
Transforming Your Business Performance with People Analytics (CIPD Annual Exh...
PDF
2016 China Recruiting Trends Report
PDF
Employee engagement july smu 2015
PPTX
Employee Engagement
PDF
The Employee Experience Engagement & Culture from the Bottom-Up
PPT
Engage To Retain Azshrm Presentation 2010
PPT
Hire Minds Assess Presentation _Employee retention
PDF
BPI group Executive Employment Trends Q2 2013
PPTX
Cordialism: Africa HR Summit
PDF
Employee Engagement Capabilities Report by Altus and Red Balloon
PDF
6 Ways to Improve Employee Engagement and Create a Culture of Learning
TPP HR Seminar Sep 16
MIS Capabilities
Why asking why is so important for organisational improvement
Why Volunteering Programs are no longer just for Large Companies
Employee Engagement, and why it matters to the Experiential Marketing Industry
Employee engagement webinar
How Senior Leadership Engage/Disengage in Nonprofits
Transforming your organisation
Bluprints presentation
Transforming Your Business Performance with People Analytics (CIPD Annual Exh...
2016 China Recruiting Trends Report
Employee engagement july smu 2015
Employee Engagement
The Employee Experience Engagement & Culture from the Bottom-Up
Engage To Retain Azshrm Presentation 2010
Hire Minds Assess Presentation _Employee retention
BPI group Executive Employment Trends Q2 2013
Cordialism: Africa HR Summit
Employee Engagement Capabilities Report by Altus and Red Balloon
6 Ways to Improve Employee Engagement and Create a Culture of Learning

More from TALiNT Partners (20)

PPTX
AI, Automation & Agencies
PPTX
First Universal Solution for Hirers, Agencies, Workers and Payroll Companies
PPTX
JobDiva's Innovations in Intelligent Recruitment
PPTX
Direct Sourcing – The Insider’s View
PPTX
Leveraging Communications Technology in Recruitment & Staffing
PPTX
PR – Why it’s an Investment Rather than a Cost
PPTX
Talent Leaders Connect, The Year Ahead and Candidate Experience 2018 - Welcom...
PPTX
The Impact of Informed Candidates on Your Business
PPTX
Flex or Break - How to Engage the New Talent Economy
PPTX
Connecting Up the Supply Chain
PPTX
The times, they are changing...
PDF
Keep a Pulse: Turning Data into Relationship Insights and (Automated) Action
PDF
Data Analytics in Today's War for Talent
PDF
Exceptional Talent
PDF
WHY – A Sense of Purpose and the Positive Impact That This Can Have on Perfor...
PDF
Innovation Spotlight: The First Universal Solution for Hirers, Agencies, Wor...
PDF
Creating Value Beyond Recruitment
PDF
Welcome to RLCon Scotland 2017
PDF
Finding Your Fit: Using Company Culture to Hire the Right Talent
PDF
The New Talent Journey
AI, Automation & Agencies
First Universal Solution for Hirers, Agencies, Workers and Payroll Companies
JobDiva's Innovations in Intelligent Recruitment
Direct Sourcing – The Insider’s View
Leveraging Communications Technology in Recruitment & Staffing
PR – Why it’s an Investment Rather than a Cost
Talent Leaders Connect, The Year Ahead and Candidate Experience 2018 - Welcom...
The Impact of Informed Candidates on Your Business
Flex or Break - How to Engage the New Talent Economy
Connecting Up the Supply Chain
The times, they are changing...
Keep a Pulse: Turning Data into Relationship Insights and (Automated) Action
Data Analytics in Today's War for Talent
Exceptional Talent
WHY – A Sense of Purpose and the Positive Impact That This Can Have on Perfor...
Innovation Spotlight: The First Universal Solution for Hirers, Agencies, Wor...
Creating Value Beyond Recruitment
Welcome to RLCon Scotland 2017
Finding Your Fit: Using Company Culture to Hire the Right Talent
The New Talent Journey

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
USA's Top Talent Acquisition Trends – 2025
PPTX
HR Payroll Management Amazon presentation
DOCX
"Optimizing Teamwork: The Role of Project Management Tools
PDF
The Silent Sabotage - When A Teammate Undermine You At Work.pdf
PPTX
Plan, acquire , develop , career management ppt
PPTX
ADVANCED WORKFORCE PLANNING FOR mBA GRADS
PDF
Labor Market Regulations, and others (Session 4 Report) DADO.pdf
PDF
How to Identify suspicious Linked In Profiles
PPTX
HR Solution PEOEOR Payroll Outsourcing.pptx
PPT
Training Design strategies and methods.ppt
DOCX
HRMT5110_AnnotatedBibliography_Group5.docx
PPTX
Team_Interventions_with_Maruti_Case_Study.pptx
PDF
Chairman's Presentation - September 2024.pdf
PPTX
Team 5 Final Presentation pptx. (28.07.25) (2).pptx
PDF
Webinar - How AI is reshaping pay decisions.pdf
PDF
LEADERSHIP Horizon : To LEAD with HEART (HR Development))
PPTX
HRM-Compensation, Benefits and Employee Relations.pptx
PPTX
CONFLICT_TRANSACTIONAL_ANALYSIS_OB_.pptx
PPTX
HRM Speciaslization.pptx ,Guidlines for MBA students for their future growth
PDF
Human resources management -RBI in recruitment process
USA's Top Talent Acquisition Trends – 2025
HR Payroll Management Amazon presentation
"Optimizing Teamwork: The Role of Project Management Tools
The Silent Sabotage - When A Teammate Undermine You At Work.pdf
Plan, acquire , develop , career management ppt
ADVANCED WORKFORCE PLANNING FOR mBA GRADS
Labor Market Regulations, and others (Session 4 Report) DADO.pdf
How to Identify suspicious Linked In Profiles
HR Solution PEOEOR Payroll Outsourcing.pptx
Training Design strategies and methods.ppt
HRMT5110_AnnotatedBibliography_Group5.docx
Team_Interventions_with_Maruti_Case_Study.pptx
Chairman's Presentation - September 2024.pdf
Team 5 Final Presentation pptx. (28.07.25) (2).pptx
Webinar - How AI is reshaping pay decisions.pdf
LEADERSHIP Horizon : To LEAD with HEART (HR Development))
HRM-Compensation, Benefits and Employee Relations.pptx
CONFLICT_TRANSACTIONAL_ANALYSIS_OB_.pptx
HRM Speciaslization.pptx ,Guidlines for MBA students for their future growth
Human resources management -RBI in recruitment process

What Really Drives Employee Performance

  • 1. Is appraisal really dead? How to deliver sustained high performance through people. Lucinda Carney C.Psychol lucinda@actus.co.uk @actusappraisal
  • 2. Lucinda Carney Professionally • Chartered Psychologist • Senior HR/L&D Background in Pharma & Telco till 2009 • People and Performance Management & Culture Change Consultancy • Founder Actus™ performance management software Personally • Married with two children • Back to netball player • Passionate about making a difference
  • 3. How is the annual performance review viewed in your organisation? A: It is a strategic imperative B: Taken seriously but can be “de-prioritised” C: It’s a painful tick box exercise D: Non existent
  • 4. Why is it so painful? • Backward looking • A snapshot in time • Nothing results from it • People go through the motions • People comply rather than see it as valuable • Doesn’t promote ownership
  • 5. The focus is all wrong We need to focus on Performance Achievement not Performance Review
  • 6. Lets take a look at the evidence Research Review: What really drives performance Conducted by: Dr Nuno da Camara Lecturer in HR and Organisational Behaviour at Southampton Business School
  • 7. What are the biggest people challenges in your organisation currently? • Recruiting the right people • Retaining the right people • Productivity and performance • Management capability • Employee engagement • Something else?
  • 8. What effective performance management looks like Cogs image with 8 items Goal setting Transparent communication Coaching & development Feedback and recognition Strategic alignment Reward for performance Trained managers Climate of trust
  • 9. Making the links Quality People Management Organisational Performance Consistent People & Performance Management Transparency & Culture of Trust Clear Goals Feedback and Recognition Trained Managers Employee Engagement Performance Management Induction
  • 10. It is all about ongoing, meaningful dialogue
  • 11. Organisations with a Performance Achievement Culture are… 51% more likely to outperform their competitors on financial measures 41% more likely to outperform their competitors on nonfinancial measures Cascio (2011)
  • 12. But how do we convince the ‘fluffy’ brigade ‘Engagement is now an accepted leading indicator of next year’s financial results’ Human Capital Institute; 2010
  • 13. We have to speak their language Profitability Sainsbury’s found higher levels of engagement linked directly to sales performance contributing up to 15% of a store’s year on year growth. Productivity International Gallup survey showed that individuals with the highest engagement scores averaged 18% higher productivity than those in the bottom quartile. Safety Levels of employee engagement directly correlate with absenteeism and patient mortality in the NHS Absenteeism & Retention Hay found companies with high levels of engagement show turnover rates 40% lower than companies with low levels of engagement. Source: Engage for Success “The Evidence” & The Kings Fund Nov 2012
  • 14. We have to align HR & OD with the needs of the organisation to gain real sponsorship Clear Expectations and Goals Regular Feedback and support Performance Achievement Focus More Donors More Lives Saved High Performing Charity
  • 15. Practical take aways! • Replace performance review with performance achievement make it future focused and all year round • Gain sponsorship for HRM – link it to organisational outcomes • Motivate good management practice - make people management important, set clear expectations and monitor them • Recruit managers with the ‘people gene’ & upskill them • Be a passionate change leader rather than a custodian of process
  • 16. Discussion points or questions? Contact me: Lucinda@advancechange.co.uk Tweet to us @actusappraisal www.actus.co.uk
  • 17. Would you like a copy of the research? To download the Research Review or any of our free thought leadership, manager guides or white papers follow this link to the Knowledge Bank and help yourself!: https://actus.co.uk/register- page/