SlideShare a Scribd company logo
MATERIALS
GROUP 9
ELOK ROFIQOHNUGRAHANI
MAYA MASYITAH
RIZKY TANTIA CESARIDHA
B-B1 ENGLISHCURRICULUM
Materials
After working on needs analysis, goals and
objectives, and tests, curriculum developers
need to work on materials development.
Materials is defined as any systematic
description of the techniques and exercises to
be used in classroom teaching.
The key : ensure that they are described and
organized well enough so that teachers can use
them with no confusion.
Framework for Materials Design
Approach
Syllabuses
Techniques
Exercises
There must be some kind of theoritical motivation
underlying any curriculum development. (Anthony
1963; Richard & Rogers 1982; McKay 1978)
Such motivations is called approaches; ways of
defining what the students need to learn based on
assumptions and theoritical positions drawn from
disciplines.
e.g classical approach, grammar-translation
approach, direct approach, audiolingual approach,
communicative approach.
Approach
Syllabuses are concerned with the choice
necessary to organize the language content of a
course or a program.
The information gathered from needs analysis
will help to determine the direction that a
particular syllabus will go.
e.g structural, situational, topical, functional,
notional, skills, task or activity based
Syllabuses
Techniques are ways of presenting language
points to students.
Presentation typically includes various
combination of interaction between T&S, S&S,
Cassete player&S, etc.
e.g example video tape showing a native speaker
describing various commonly encountered
objects; analysis of models of good writing, etc.
Techniques
Exercises are ways of having the students
practice the language points thay have been
presented.
Language can be practiced in many ways : L to
L, L to T, L to group, L to class, etc.
Exercises
Types of Exercises
Speaking
Dialogue
Teacher-Student
Interaction
Peer feedback
sessions
Pair work
Free conversation
Writing
Brainstorming
Quick writing
Group writing
Free composition
activities
Materials Blueprint
A set of guidelines for teachers.
Made by gathering teachers’s point of
view and information from the previous
stages (needs analysis, objectives setting,
and testing stages.
It can be used as a manual which describe
the program and it’s curriculum for teachers.
It contains definition of the program, clients
to be served, delivery, intensity, content,
outcome, and special considerations.
Materials Blueprint Checklist
Background information
Overall curriculum description
A description of a program’s needs
A decription of goals and objectives
Tests description
Materials description
Teaching description
Program evaluation
Units of Analysis
Syllabus design theory has been an active area of
investigation within applied linguistics for many
years.
The conceptions of the nature of a syllabus are related
to the approaches to language and language learning
processes to which the curriculum designers and
program participants subscribe.
Under the influence of prescriptive, grammar-based
approaches to language learning, syllabuses have
tended to be expressed in more communicative terms.
Scope and Sequence Charts
Closely related to syllabus design is the
question of deciding what kind of
organizational framework to adopt for
developing materials. The syllabus should be
thought out in terms of units of analysis and
then in terms of curriculum scope and
sequence.
Curriculum Developing - Material
Some overall curriculum plan that specifies the
techniques that will be used should be developed.
Detailed
Curriculum
A formalized lock-step
curriculum complete
with lesson plan that
detail every minute of
classroom plan.
This curriculum may be
viewed as stifling /
inflexible, because it is
difficult to revise and
change.
Informal
Curriculum
A curriculum that a
teacher plans on the
spur of the moment.
Highly flexible and
easily respond to
needs for change.
Gantt Diagrams
One useful technique for representing
the different steps involved in large-
scale materials development and
implementation projects is the Gantt
diagram.
A Gantt diagram is a two-axis figure
with time divisions labeled across the
horizontal axis and task division
down the vertical axis.
Useful for
providing an
overview that
can be
understood at
a glance.
Shows all the tasks
involved and the
time frames in
which each task
must be begun and
completed.
Useful tool for
explaining a
curriculum
development project
to outsiders, also
can help the insiders
on schedule.
WHERE DO MATERIALS COME FROM?
ADOPTING
DEVELOPING
ADAPTING
MATERIALS
Working fromprogramgoals and objectives, the
teacher must address the essential questions of what
the content will be and how it will be sequenced.
HOW?
TEACHING
MATERIALS
NEEDSANALYSIS,
OBJECTIVES, AND
TESTSHOULD
PROVIDE
INFORMATIONWILL
SUFFICEFOR
ANSWERING.
ADOPTING,
DEVELOPING, OR
ADAPTING
MATERIALSTHAT
MATCHTHE
CONTENTIS THE
NEXTLOGICAL
STEP.
THE SEQUENCING
OF THATCONTENT
SHOULDALSOBE
ADDRESSEDIN THE
PROCESS.
THE
PROCESS
ADOPTING MATERIALS
It is
necessary
to decide
what
types of
materials
are
desirable.
All
available
materials of
these types
should be
located.
Review or
evaluation
procedures
must be list
down to
materials
that should
be
seriously
considered.
Strategy for
these
adopted
materials
must be set
up so they
do not
become
irrelevant.
TYPES OF MATERIALS
BOOKS
WORKBOOKS
JOURNALS
MAPS
REALIA
VIDEO TAPES
TEACHER BOOKS
MAGAZINES
PICTURES
CHARTS/GRAPHS
DIAGRAMS
CASSETTE TAPES
COMPUTER SOFTWARE
VIDEODISC
COMPUTER
COMBINATIONS
LOCATING MATERIALS
Sources of
Information
Teachers’
Shelves
“Books
Received”
sections of
journal
Publishers
’ Catalogs
PUBLISHERS’ CATALOGS
Catalogs are usually free for the asking. It also produce
materials for other languages. Catalogs are very well organized
most of the time, and including lists of relevant publications
with brief descriptions and its price.
PUBLISHERS’ CATALOGS
For this, hands-on examination is necessary. Most
publishers are happy to sendus desk copies, which are
textbooks, manuals, or workbooks, of their materials.
“BOOKS RECEIVED” SECTION
It is usually found in many of the well-known language
teaching journals. These are listednear the back of a
journal most of the time.
THE TEACHERS’ SHELVES
These shelves withinthe programmay be full of materials
that could prove interesting anduseful. Teachers are more
likely to have experience with materials they already own.
EVALUATING MATERIALS
STEVICK
(1971)
THREE
QUALITIES
THREE
DIMENSIONS
FOUR
COMPONENTS
THREE QUALITIES
Strength
Lightness
Transparency
THREE DIMENSIONS
Linguistic
Social
Topical
FOUR COMPONENTS
Occasions for use
Sample of language use
Lexical exploration
Exploration of structural relationships
Five perspectives for materials :
Background
Fit to curriculum
Physical Characteristics
Logistical Characteristics
Teachability
Can be made only with the
materials physically in hand.
EVALUATING MATERIALS
STEPS
First, the degree of relationship
between a set of materials and a
particular program can best be
determined by considering the degree
to which the materials fit to the
curriculum.
Next, focus on the degree to which the
materials match the language needs of
the students in a general way.
EVALUATING MATERIALS
STEPS
Then, the specific language and
situation needs of the students should
be considered.
After that, examine any materials that
are still in the running for adoption in
terms of their physical characteristics.
EVALUATING MATERIALS
STEPS
Editorial characteristics such as the
accuracy of the content, the degree to
which the materials edited in a manner
consistent with the program’s style, the
degree to which the directions are clear
and easy to follow, and the clarity or
clearness of the examples should be
considered.
EVALUATING MATERIALS
STEPS
Logistical characteristics such as the
price and number of auxiliary parts
that are required, the availability of the
materials, time that it will take to ship
them should be considered.
Last, the teachability of the materials
should also be appraised.
EVALUATING MATERIALS
Teachers can keep notes on students reactions to the
materials as teachers use them.
This reviewmight take the formof a yearly straw
count of how many teachers want to continue using
the same texts, or more involved series of meetings.
ONGOING REVIEWOF MATERIALS
With the help of and ideas of a
number of people within a
program, especially the teachers,
materials can be developed that
will create the best possible match
between materials and the
curriculum.
DEVELOPING MATERIALS
CREATING PHASE
• Find teachers who are willing to work on materials.
• Identify a pool of materials developers provided with
copies of all relevant documents.
• Divide the labor to pull all the materials developers weight
in the project.
• Use peer pressure that can be a wonderful curriculum tool.
• Use a modular system to enhanced the working
arrangement by developing the materials modules
separately by different groups.
TEACHING PHASE
•The original developers can be involved in the
field testing along with one teacher who was not
involved in the original development process.
•Revision should be made, with input from all
teachers who may ultimately use the materials.
EVALUATING PHASE
•It might be worthwhile to consider
sending the materials to a publisher.
• Remember that materials are never
finished so provisions should be made
for ongoing materials development.
Four steps for finding and
evaluating materials plus several
distinctive features:
Analyzing
Classifying
Filling the gaps
Reorganizing
ADAPTING MATERIALS
ADAPTING MATERIALS
ANALYZING CLASSIFYING
FILL THE BLANKS REORGANIZING
Use any logical
classes of objectives
List places in
materials
Leave blanks where
supplemental
materials are needed
Complete the list
Reorganize
 From other materials
 From created materials
 Teachers as resources
 Resource file
 Matches to current
objectives
 Mismatches to current
objectives
 Percentage of objectives
 Percent of existing
matches
 Decide which materials to
adapt
THANK YOU

More Related Content

PPT
Needs assessment for curriculum
PPTX
educational planning
PPTX
Approches to course design in ESP
PDF
The current state of generative AI
PPTX
Curriculum Concepts, Nature and Purposes
PDF
𝐆𝐞𝐧𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐯𝐞 𝐀𝐈: 𝐂𝐡𝐚𝐧𝐠𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐇𝐨𝐰 𝐁𝐮𝐬𝐢𝐧𝐞𝐬𝐬 𝐈𝐧𝐧𝐨𝐯𝐚𝐭𝐞𝐬 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐎𝐩𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐞𝐬
PPTX
Story Telling
PPT
Daya pembeda & tingkat kesukaran
Needs assessment for curriculum
educational planning
Approches to course design in ESP
The current state of generative AI
Curriculum Concepts, Nature and Purposes
𝐆𝐞𝐧𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐯𝐞 𝐀𝐈: 𝐂𝐡𝐚𝐧𝐠𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐇𝐨𝐰 𝐁𝐮𝐬𝐢𝐧𝐞𝐬𝐬 𝐈𝐧𝐧𝐨𝐯𝐚𝐭𝐞𝐬 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐎𝐩𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐞𝐬
Story Telling
Daya pembeda & tingkat kesukaran

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Classroom research
PPTX
Curriculum organization
PPTX
Elements Of Curriculum Development
PPTX
Tyler model of curriculum development
PPTX
Meaning and Nature of Curriculum
PPT
Lesson planning.
PPTX
Taba model of curriculum development
PPTX
Needs analysis
PPTX
Curriculum theory
PPTX
Need analysis for curriculum development.pptx
PPT
Methods, approaches and techniques of teaching english
PPTX
Competency-based language teaching
PPT
Foundation of curriculum
PPTX
Curriculum objectives
PDF
Curriculum organization
PDF
3. unit vi advantages and disadvantages of learner centered teaching or lear...
PPTX
Adopting and Adapting Materials
PPTX
Structural Approach and Functional Approach
PPTX
Process of curriculum change
PPTX
Elements/Components of Curriculum
Classroom research
Curriculum organization
Elements Of Curriculum Development
Tyler model of curriculum development
Meaning and Nature of Curriculum
Lesson planning.
Taba model of curriculum development
Needs analysis
Curriculum theory
Need analysis for curriculum development.pptx
Methods, approaches and techniques of teaching english
Competency-based language teaching
Foundation of curriculum
Curriculum objectives
Curriculum organization
3. unit vi advantages and disadvantages of learner centered teaching or lear...
Adopting and Adapting Materials
Structural Approach and Functional Approach
Process of curriculum change
Elements/Components of Curriculum
Ad

Similar to Curriculum Developing - Material (20)

PPTX
Esp section 3 application
PPTX
Preparation and evaluation of instruction materials
PPT
Ch 1 Overview of Language Curriculum Design.ppt
PPT
ESP MATERIAL DESIGN
PPTX
Developing Instructional Materials
PPTX
Curriculum and Material Development
PPTX
Language curriculum design
PPTX
Intro to the Course_8430d414e16f36a38d49b93d49b35589.pptx
PPTX
Chapter 9 developing instructional materials
PPTX
ESP materials development
PPTX
chapter9developinginstructionalmaterials-161016165607.pptx
PDF
Syllabus design copy
PDF
Syllabus%20 design%20 %20copy
PPTX
Curriculum Design Chapter3 Needs Analysis.pptx
PPTX
Language course design
DOCX
Running head PROBLEM STATEMENT .docx
DOCX
Running head PROBLEM STATEMENT .docx
PPTX
RevistingABC: Beyond blended: new definitions, principles and resources
PPTX
Nguyen, Phuong LIT5203 Strengthening Literacy - Module 4
PPTX
ELE14-GROUP 3-Instructinal Planning Models-Lacson_Alday_De Jesus_Del Rosario_...
Esp section 3 application
Preparation and evaluation of instruction materials
Ch 1 Overview of Language Curriculum Design.ppt
ESP MATERIAL DESIGN
Developing Instructional Materials
Curriculum and Material Development
Language curriculum design
Intro to the Course_8430d414e16f36a38d49b93d49b35589.pptx
Chapter 9 developing instructional materials
ESP materials development
chapter9developinginstructionalmaterials-161016165607.pptx
Syllabus design copy
Syllabus%20 design%20 %20copy
Curriculum Design Chapter3 Needs Analysis.pptx
Language course design
Running head PROBLEM STATEMENT .docx
Running head PROBLEM STATEMENT .docx
RevistingABC: Beyond blended: new definitions, principles and resources
Nguyen, Phuong LIT5203 Strengthening Literacy - Module 4
ELE14-GROUP 3-Instructinal Planning Models-Lacson_Alday_De Jesus_Del Rosario_...
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
STATICS OF THE RIGID BODIES Hibbelers.pdf
PDF
Abdominal Access Techniques with Prof. Dr. R K Mishra
PDF
Saundersa Comprehensive Review for the NCLEX-RN Examination.pdf
PPTX
Introduction_to_Human_Anatomy_and_Physiology_for_B.Pharm.pptx
PDF
TR - Agricultural Crops Production NC III.pdf
PPTX
BOWEL ELIMINATION FACTORS AFFECTING AND TYPES
PPTX
The Healthy Child – Unit II | Child Health Nursing I | B.Sc Nursing 5th Semester
PDF
Microbial disease of the cardiovascular and lymphatic systems
PPTX
Introduction to Child Health Nursing – Unit I | Child Health Nursing I | B.Sc...
PPTX
Institutional Correction lecture only . . .
PDF
Insiders guide to clinical Medicine.pdf
PPTX
PPH.pptx obstetrics and gynecology in nursing
PDF
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KỸ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH 9 GLOBAL SUCCESS - CẢ NĂM - BÁM SÁT FORM Đ...
PPTX
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
PDF
grade 11-chemistry_fetena_net_5883.pdf teacher guide for all student
PPTX
Pharma ospi slides which help in ospi learning
PDF
Business Ethics Teaching Materials for college
PDF
Chapter 2 Heredity, Prenatal Development, and Birth.pdf
PDF
3rd Neelam Sanjeevareddy Memorial Lecture.pdf
PPTX
Cell Structure & Organelles in detailed.
STATICS OF THE RIGID BODIES Hibbelers.pdf
Abdominal Access Techniques with Prof. Dr. R K Mishra
Saundersa Comprehensive Review for the NCLEX-RN Examination.pdf
Introduction_to_Human_Anatomy_and_Physiology_for_B.Pharm.pptx
TR - Agricultural Crops Production NC III.pdf
BOWEL ELIMINATION FACTORS AFFECTING AND TYPES
The Healthy Child – Unit II | Child Health Nursing I | B.Sc Nursing 5th Semester
Microbial disease of the cardiovascular and lymphatic systems
Introduction to Child Health Nursing – Unit I | Child Health Nursing I | B.Sc...
Institutional Correction lecture only . . .
Insiders guide to clinical Medicine.pdf
PPH.pptx obstetrics and gynecology in nursing
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ 4 KỸ NĂNG TIẾNG ANH 9 GLOBAL SUCCESS - CẢ NĂM - BÁM SÁT FORM Đ...
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
grade 11-chemistry_fetena_net_5883.pdf teacher guide for all student
Pharma ospi slides which help in ospi learning
Business Ethics Teaching Materials for college
Chapter 2 Heredity, Prenatal Development, and Birth.pdf
3rd Neelam Sanjeevareddy Memorial Lecture.pdf
Cell Structure & Organelles in detailed.

Curriculum Developing - Material

  • 1. MATERIALS GROUP 9 ELOK ROFIQOHNUGRAHANI MAYA MASYITAH RIZKY TANTIA CESARIDHA B-B1 ENGLISHCURRICULUM
  • 2. Materials After working on needs analysis, goals and objectives, and tests, curriculum developers need to work on materials development. Materials is defined as any systematic description of the techniques and exercises to be used in classroom teaching. The key : ensure that they are described and organized well enough so that teachers can use them with no confusion.
  • 3. Framework for Materials Design Approach Syllabuses Techniques Exercises
  • 4. There must be some kind of theoritical motivation underlying any curriculum development. (Anthony 1963; Richard & Rogers 1982; McKay 1978) Such motivations is called approaches; ways of defining what the students need to learn based on assumptions and theoritical positions drawn from disciplines. e.g classical approach, grammar-translation approach, direct approach, audiolingual approach, communicative approach. Approach
  • 5. Syllabuses are concerned with the choice necessary to organize the language content of a course or a program. The information gathered from needs analysis will help to determine the direction that a particular syllabus will go. e.g structural, situational, topical, functional, notional, skills, task or activity based Syllabuses
  • 6. Techniques are ways of presenting language points to students. Presentation typically includes various combination of interaction between T&S, S&S, Cassete player&S, etc. e.g example video tape showing a native speaker describing various commonly encountered objects; analysis of models of good writing, etc. Techniques
  • 7. Exercises are ways of having the students practice the language points thay have been presented. Language can be practiced in many ways : L to L, L to T, L to group, L to class, etc. Exercises
  • 8. Types of Exercises Speaking Dialogue Teacher-Student Interaction Peer feedback sessions Pair work Free conversation Writing Brainstorming Quick writing Group writing Free composition activities
  • 9. Materials Blueprint A set of guidelines for teachers. Made by gathering teachers’s point of view and information from the previous stages (needs analysis, objectives setting, and testing stages. It can be used as a manual which describe the program and it’s curriculum for teachers. It contains definition of the program, clients to be served, delivery, intensity, content, outcome, and special considerations.
  • 10. Materials Blueprint Checklist Background information Overall curriculum description A description of a program’s needs A decription of goals and objectives Tests description Materials description Teaching description Program evaluation
  • 11. Units of Analysis Syllabus design theory has been an active area of investigation within applied linguistics for many years. The conceptions of the nature of a syllabus are related to the approaches to language and language learning processes to which the curriculum designers and program participants subscribe. Under the influence of prescriptive, grammar-based approaches to language learning, syllabuses have tended to be expressed in more communicative terms.
  • 12. Scope and Sequence Charts Closely related to syllabus design is the question of deciding what kind of organizational framework to adopt for developing materials. The syllabus should be thought out in terms of units of analysis and then in terms of curriculum scope and sequence.
  • 14. Some overall curriculum plan that specifies the techniques that will be used should be developed. Detailed Curriculum A formalized lock-step curriculum complete with lesson plan that detail every minute of classroom plan. This curriculum may be viewed as stifling / inflexible, because it is difficult to revise and change. Informal Curriculum A curriculum that a teacher plans on the spur of the moment. Highly flexible and easily respond to needs for change.
  • 15. Gantt Diagrams One useful technique for representing the different steps involved in large- scale materials development and implementation projects is the Gantt diagram. A Gantt diagram is a two-axis figure with time divisions labeled across the horizontal axis and task division down the vertical axis.
  • 16. Useful for providing an overview that can be understood at a glance. Shows all the tasks involved and the time frames in which each task must be begun and completed. Useful tool for explaining a curriculum development project to outsiders, also can help the insiders on schedule.
  • 17. WHERE DO MATERIALS COME FROM? ADOPTING DEVELOPING ADAPTING MATERIALS
  • 18. Working fromprogramgoals and objectives, the teacher must address the essential questions of what the content will be and how it will be sequenced. HOW?
  • 20. ADOPTING MATERIALS It is necessary to decide what types of materials are desirable. All available materials of these types should be located. Review or evaluation procedures must be list down to materials that should be seriously considered. Strategy for these adopted materials must be set up so they do not become irrelevant.
  • 21. TYPES OF MATERIALS BOOKS WORKBOOKS JOURNALS MAPS REALIA VIDEO TAPES TEACHER BOOKS MAGAZINES PICTURES CHARTS/GRAPHS DIAGRAMS CASSETTE TAPES COMPUTER SOFTWARE VIDEODISC COMPUTER COMBINATIONS
  • 23. PUBLISHERS’ CATALOGS Catalogs are usually free for the asking. It also produce materials for other languages. Catalogs are very well organized most of the time, and including lists of relevant publications with brief descriptions and its price.
  • 24. PUBLISHERS’ CATALOGS For this, hands-on examination is necessary. Most publishers are happy to sendus desk copies, which are textbooks, manuals, or workbooks, of their materials.
  • 25. “BOOKS RECEIVED” SECTION It is usually found in many of the well-known language teaching journals. These are listednear the back of a journal most of the time.
  • 26. THE TEACHERS’ SHELVES These shelves withinthe programmay be full of materials that could prove interesting anduseful. Teachers are more likely to have experience with materials they already own.
  • 30. FOUR COMPONENTS Occasions for use Sample of language use Lexical exploration Exploration of structural relationships
  • 31. Five perspectives for materials : Background Fit to curriculum Physical Characteristics Logistical Characteristics Teachability Can be made only with the materials physically in hand. EVALUATING MATERIALS
  • 32. STEPS First, the degree of relationship between a set of materials and a particular program can best be determined by considering the degree to which the materials fit to the curriculum. Next, focus on the degree to which the materials match the language needs of the students in a general way. EVALUATING MATERIALS
  • 33. STEPS Then, the specific language and situation needs of the students should be considered. After that, examine any materials that are still in the running for adoption in terms of their physical characteristics. EVALUATING MATERIALS
  • 34. STEPS Editorial characteristics such as the accuracy of the content, the degree to which the materials edited in a manner consistent with the program’s style, the degree to which the directions are clear and easy to follow, and the clarity or clearness of the examples should be considered. EVALUATING MATERIALS
  • 35. STEPS Logistical characteristics such as the price and number of auxiliary parts that are required, the availability of the materials, time that it will take to ship them should be considered. Last, the teachability of the materials should also be appraised. EVALUATING MATERIALS
  • 36. Teachers can keep notes on students reactions to the materials as teachers use them. This reviewmight take the formof a yearly straw count of how many teachers want to continue using the same texts, or more involved series of meetings. ONGOING REVIEWOF MATERIALS
  • 37. With the help of and ideas of a number of people within a program, especially the teachers, materials can be developed that will create the best possible match between materials and the curriculum. DEVELOPING MATERIALS
  • 38. CREATING PHASE • Find teachers who are willing to work on materials. • Identify a pool of materials developers provided with copies of all relevant documents. • Divide the labor to pull all the materials developers weight in the project. • Use peer pressure that can be a wonderful curriculum tool. • Use a modular system to enhanced the working arrangement by developing the materials modules separately by different groups.
  • 39. TEACHING PHASE •The original developers can be involved in the field testing along with one teacher who was not involved in the original development process. •Revision should be made, with input from all teachers who may ultimately use the materials.
  • 40. EVALUATING PHASE •It might be worthwhile to consider sending the materials to a publisher. • Remember that materials are never finished so provisions should be made for ongoing materials development.
  • 41. Four steps for finding and evaluating materials plus several distinctive features: Analyzing Classifying Filling the gaps Reorganizing ADAPTING MATERIALS
  • 42. ADAPTING MATERIALS ANALYZING CLASSIFYING FILL THE BLANKS REORGANIZING Use any logical classes of objectives List places in materials Leave blanks where supplemental materials are needed Complete the list Reorganize  From other materials  From created materials  Teachers as resources  Resource file  Matches to current objectives  Mismatches to current objectives  Percentage of objectives  Percent of existing matches  Decide which materials to adapt