Effect of base isolation in multistoried rc irregular building using time history analysis
2 likes424 views
This study evaluates the effectiveness of base isolation techniques in multistoried irregular buildings during seismic events, specifically analyzing time period and base shear comparisons between structures with and without lead rubber bearings. The findings reveal that base isolated structures exhibit increased time periods and significantly reduced base shear forces, particularly in vertical irregular buildings, which outperform plan irregular configurations. The research underscores the advantages of using base isolation in high seismic risk areas to enhance structural resilience.
![IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology eISSN: 2319-1163 | pISSN: 2321-7308
_______________________________________________________________________________________
Volume: 04 Issue: 06 | June-2015, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 289
EFFECT OF BASE ISOLATION IN MULTISTORIED RC IRREGULAR
BUILDING USING TIME HISTORY ANALYSIS
Vinodkumar Parma1
, G.S.Hiremath2
1
Post - Graduate student, Department of Structural Engineering, Basaveshwar Engineering College, Bagalkot,
Karnataka, India
2
Asst.Prof. in Civil Engg, Department, Basaveshwar Engineering College, Bagalkot, Karnataka, India
Abstract
Base isolation (BI) is a technique that has been used around the world to protect the building structures from the damaging effects
of earthquake. The installation of isolator in building at base level significantly increases the time period of the structure, which
means it reduces the possibility of resonance of the structure giving rise to better seismic performance of the building. The study is
performed to compare the effectiveness of base isolation in plan irregular and vertical irregular multi-storied RC frame building.
For this study, 15 storied R.C frame building is considered and Time History analysis is carried out using ETABS 2013 software.
The Lead Rubber Bearing (LRB) is designed as per UBC 97 code and the same was used for analysis of base isolation system. The
results obtained from the analysis were time period and base shear. Time period for the base isolated structures are higher than
that of the fixed base structure. Due to the presence of isolator, Base shear is significantly reduced in each direction (X and Y
direction) as compared to fixed base building. It has been found that when compared to plan irregular base isolated building the
vertical irregular building gives better performance in high seismic prone area by using isolators at the base of the building.
Keywords: Base isolation, Lead rubber bearing, Time history analysis, Irregular building
-------------------------------------------------------------------***--------------------------------------------------------------------
1. INTRODUCTION
Earth quake is a shaking of the ground caused by movement
of the tectonic plates relative to each other, both in direction
and magnitude. A large part of the world people lives in area
of seismic hazard at risk from earthquake of varying
harshness and varying frequency of existence. Earthquake
cause significant loss of life and destruction to property
every year [9]. During past earthquake most of the irregular
buildings collapsed due to the non-uniform distribution of
the load compared to regular buildings.
Several seismic construction designs and technologies have
been developed over the years in efforts to reduce the effect
of earthquakes on structures, bridges and potentially
susceptible contents. Seismic isolation is relatively recent
and growing technology of this kind.
The isolation system decouples the structure from the
horizontal components of the ground motion and reduces the
possibility of resonance. This decoupling is achieved by
increasing the flexibility of the system, together with
appropriate damping by providing isolator at the basement
level of the structure [9].
Table-1: List of some significant earthquake in India
Date Location Magnitude
1819 Jun 16 Kutch, Gujarat 8.0
1897 Jun 12 Shillong plateau 8.7
1905 Apr 04 Kangra, H.P 8.0
1934 Jan 15 Bihar-Nepal border 8.3
1950 Aug 15 ArunachalPradesh-China 8.5
border
1991 Oct 20 Utterkashi,UP Hills 6.6
1993 Sep 30 Latur-Osmanabad, MH 6.3
1999 Mar 22 Chamoli Dist.UP 6.8
2001 Jan 26 Bhuj, Gujarat 7.7
The Indian subcontinent has a history of devastating earth
quakes. The shaking memories of high intensity earthquakes
of Bhuj and lathur are still alive in our minds. Even now
there are frequent occurrences of earthquakes in the
Kashmir and Himalayan region. The major reason for the
high frequency and intensity of the earthquakes is that the
Indian plate is driving into Asia at a rate of approximately
47 mm/year. Geographical data of India shows that almost
54% of the land is susceptible to earthquakes. A World
Bank & United Nations report shows estimates that around
200 million city occupiers in India will be exposed to storms
and earthquakes by 2050 [8].
1.1 Objectives of the Work
To compare the response of the building such as Time
period and Base shear for 15 storied RC plan and vertical
irregular buildings with and without base isolation by
considering the time history analysis using Bhuj earthquake
data.
2. MODELING AND ANALYSIS
This study includes modeling and analysis of the models
using standard ETABS software version 2013. Materials
properties and section properties are defined and assigned.
Reinforced concrete frame elements are modelled as beam](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/effectofbaseisolationinmultistoriedrcirregularbuildingusingtimehistoryanalysis-160906091001/85/Effect-of-base-isolation-in-multistoried-rc-irregular-building-using-time-history-analysis-1-320.jpg)
![IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology eISSN: 2319-1163 | pISSN: 2321-7308
_______________________________________________________________________________________
Volume: 04 Issue: 06 | June-2015, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 292
Fig-7: Base shear (kN) along X and Y-direction
From figure 7 is clear that, base shear in model 1B is
decreased by 45% in X direction and 31% in Y direction
compared to model 1A. Similarly in model 2B is decreased
by 60% in X direction and 34% in Y direction compared to
model 2A.
4. CONCLUSION
By the analysis it is observed that base isolation
increases the flexibility at the base level of the
building.
Time period of the structure increases by the use of
lead rubber bearing which helps in less transfer of
lateral forces at the time of earthquake.
The increase in time period of the structure is found to
be more in vertical irregular base isolated building
compared to plan irregular base isolated building.
The base isolation has high efficiency in decreasing the
base shear compared to fixed base building.
Reduction in base shear is more in vertical irregular
base isolated building compared to plan irregular base
isolated building.
From the study it shows that, the vertical irregular
building gives better performance by the use of
isolators at the base of the building as compared to
plan irregular building at higher seismic prone area.
REFERENCES
[1]. A. Abrishambaf and G. Ozay (2010), “Effects of
isolation damping and stiffness on the seismic behaviour of
structures”, ISBN: 978-960-474-251-6.
[2]. Athamnia Brahim and Ounis Abdelhafid (2011),
“Effects of seismic isolation in the reduction of the seismic
response of the structure”, International Journal of Applied
Engineering Research, Dindigul, Volume 2, No 2, 2011,
ISSN 09764259.
[3]. C.Prabha and Basil Sabu (2014) “Study of Base
Isolation in Multi-Storeyed Buildings” ISSN: 2347 1964
(Online) 2347-1875 (Print) Vol.2, Issue 8.
[4]. Farzad Naeim and James M. Kelly (1999), “Design of
seismic isolated structure”, John Wiley and Sons,
inc.Newyork.
[5]. Fu Lin ZHOU, Zheng YANG, Wen Guang LIU And
Ping TAN (2004), “ New Seismic Isolation System For
Irregular Structure With The Largest Isolation Building
Area In The World” 13th World Conference On Earthquake
Engineering Vancouver, B.C., Canada, Paper No.2349.
[6]. Hussein Shakeri Soleimanloo (2012), “A Survey study
on design procedure of Seismic Base Isolation Systems”, J.
Appl. Sci. Environ. Manage. Vol. 16 (4)299 -307.
[7]. IS 1893 (part 1):2002, Criteria for earthquake resistant
design of structures.
[8]. IS 456:2000, Code of practice for plain and reinforced
concrete.
[9]. Ivan Skinner, R., Trevor E. Kelly and Bill Robinson,
W.H. (1993) A text book on Seismic Isolation for Designers
and Structural Engineers, Robinson seismic limited, Holmes
consulting group.
[10]. S.K. Sabu, H.S.Chore, S.B.Patil (2014), “Effectiveness
of Lead Rubber Base Isolators, for seismic resistance of
Buildings, supported on different soil stratas,” ISSN
(Online): 2347-2820, Volume -2.
[11]. Saiful Islam, A.B.M., Mohammed Jameel and Mohd
Zamin Jumaat (2011), “Seismic isolation in buildings to be a
practical reality’,ISSN 2006-9790, Journal of Engineering
and Technology Research Vol. 3(4), pp. 99-117.
[12]. Shirule P. A, Jagtap. L. P, Sonawane. K. R, Patil. T.
D, Jadwanir. N and Sonar. S. K
(2012), “Time History Analysis of Base Isolated Multi-
Storyed Building”, ISSN 0974-5904, Volume 05, No. 04,
P.P. 809-816.
[13]. Syed Ahmed Kabeer K I and Sanjeev Kumar K.S
(2014), “Comparison of Two Similar Buildings with and
without Base Isolation”, International Journal of Advance
research , Ideas and Innovations in technology, volume 1,
Issue 1.
[14]. T.K. Datta (2010), “Seismic Analysis of Structures”,
Indian Institute of Technology
Delhi, India.
[15]. Trevor E Kelly, S.E. (2001), “Design Guidelines on
Base Isolation of Structures”, Holmes consulting group,
New Zealand.
[16]. W.F. Chen and Charles Scawthorn (2003),
“Earthquake Engineering Handbook”
CRC press, Boca Raton London, New York, Washington.
BIOGRAPHIES
Vinodkumar Parma, pursuing post-
graduation in Structural Engineering at
Basaveshwar Engineering College,
Bagalkot, Karnataka, India
Asst. Prof. in Civil Engg. Dept.,
Basaveshwar Engineering College,
Bagalkot, Karnataka, India
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
X-Direction Y-Direction
Baseshear(kN)
1A
1B
2A
2B](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/effectofbaseisolationinmultistoriedrcirregularbuildingusingtimehistoryanalysis-160906091001/85/Effect-of-base-isolation-in-multistoried-rc-irregular-building-using-time-history-analysis-4-320.jpg)
Effect of base isolation in multistoried rc irregular building using time history analysis
- 1. IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology eISSN: 2319-1163 | pISSN: 2321-7308 _______________________________________________________________________________________ Volume: 04 Issue: 06 | June-2015, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 289 EFFECT OF BASE ISOLATION IN MULTISTORIED RC IRREGULAR BUILDING USING TIME HISTORY ANALYSIS Vinodkumar Parma1 , G.S.Hiremath2 1 Post - Graduate student, Department of Structural Engineering, Basaveshwar Engineering College, Bagalkot, Karnataka, India 2 Asst.Prof. in Civil Engg, Department, Basaveshwar Engineering College, Bagalkot, Karnataka, India Abstract Base isolation (BI) is a technique that has been used around the world to protect the building structures from the damaging effects of earthquake. The installation of isolator in building at base level significantly increases the time period of the structure, which means it reduces the possibility of resonance of the structure giving rise to better seismic performance of the building. The study is performed to compare the effectiveness of base isolation in plan irregular and vertical irregular multi-storied RC frame building. For this study, 15 storied R.C frame building is considered and Time History analysis is carried out using ETABS 2013 software. The Lead Rubber Bearing (LRB) is designed as per UBC 97 code and the same was used for analysis of base isolation system. The results obtained from the analysis were time period and base shear. Time period for the base isolated structures are higher than that of the fixed base structure. Due to the presence of isolator, Base shear is significantly reduced in each direction (X and Y direction) as compared to fixed base building. It has been found that when compared to plan irregular base isolated building the vertical irregular building gives better performance in high seismic prone area by using isolators at the base of the building. Keywords: Base isolation, Lead rubber bearing, Time history analysis, Irregular building -------------------------------------------------------------------***-------------------------------------------------------------------- 1. INTRODUCTION Earth quake is a shaking of the ground caused by movement of the tectonic plates relative to each other, both in direction and magnitude. A large part of the world people lives in area of seismic hazard at risk from earthquake of varying harshness and varying frequency of existence. Earthquake cause significant loss of life and destruction to property every year [9]. During past earthquake most of the irregular buildings collapsed due to the non-uniform distribution of the load compared to regular buildings. Several seismic construction designs and technologies have been developed over the years in efforts to reduce the effect of earthquakes on structures, bridges and potentially susceptible contents. Seismic isolation is relatively recent and growing technology of this kind. The isolation system decouples the structure from the horizontal components of the ground motion and reduces the possibility of resonance. This decoupling is achieved by increasing the flexibility of the system, together with appropriate damping by providing isolator at the basement level of the structure [9]. Table-1: List of some significant earthquake in India Date Location Magnitude 1819 Jun 16 Kutch, Gujarat 8.0 1897 Jun 12 Shillong plateau 8.7 1905 Apr 04 Kangra, H.P 8.0 1934 Jan 15 Bihar-Nepal border 8.3 1950 Aug 15 ArunachalPradesh-China 8.5 border 1991 Oct 20 Utterkashi,UP Hills 6.6 1993 Sep 30 Latur-Osmanabad, MH 6.3 1999 Mar 22 Chamoli Dist.UP 6.8 2001 Jan 26 Bhuj, Gujarat 7.7 The Indian subcontinent has a history of devastating earth quakes. The shaking memories of high intensity earthquakes of Bhuj and lathur are still alive in our minds. Even now there are frequent occurrences of earthquakes in the Kashmir and Himalayan region. The major reason for the high frequency and intensity of the earthquakes is that the Indian plate is driving into Asia at a rate of approximately 47 mm/year. Geographical data of India shows that almost 54% of the land is susceptible to earthquakes. A World Bank & United Nations report shows estimates that around 200 million city occupiers in India will be exposed to storms and earthquakes by 2050 [8]. 1.1 Objectives of the Work To compare the response of the building such as Time period and Base shear for 15 storied RC plan and vertical irregular buildings with and without base isolation by considering the time history analysis using Bhuj earthquake data. 2. MODELING AND ANALYSIS This study includes modeling and analysis of the models using standard ETABS software version 2013. Materials properties and section properties are defined and assigned. Reinforced concrete frame elements are modelled as beam
- 2. IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology eISSN: 2319-1163 | pISSN: 2321-7308 _______________________________________________________________________________________ Volume: 04 Issue: 06 | June-2015, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 290 and column element. Slab is modelled as area element. Modal analysis and time history analysis are performed on models. 2.1 Description of Building In present work, 3D RC 15 storied plan irregular and vertical irregular buildings situated in zone V, are taken for the study. Total 4 buildings have been considered for the comparison. 2.1.1 Models Considered for Analysis G+14 storied building Model 1A: Plan irregular RC building with fixed base. Model 1B: Plan irregular RC building with Lead Rubber Bearing. Model 2A: Vertical irregular RC building with fixed base. Model 2B: Vertical irregular RC building with Lead Rubber Bearing. Fig-1: Plan view of Plan irregular building Fig-2: 3D view of plan irregular BI building Fig-3: Plan view of vertical irregular building Fig-4: Elevation of vertical irregular BI Building Table-2 Building details Grade of Concrete M25 for beam Grade of Concrete M30 for column Grade of Steel Fe500 Story height 3.2 m Beam size 300 × 450 mm Column size 400 × 700 mm Slab thickness 150 mm Wall thickness 230 mm Parapet height 1 m Live load on the floor 3 kN/m2 Live load on roof 1.5 kN/m2
- 3. IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology eISSN: 2319-1163 | pISSN: 2321-7308 _______________________________________________________________________________________ Volume: 04 Issue: 06 | June-2015, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 291 2.2 Properties of LRB used for Analysis By considering the maximum gravity service load coming on the column at the base of structure, the Lead Rubber Bearing has been designed. Table-3: Isolator properties Properties Plan irregular building Vertical irregular building Axial load on column (P) kN 7750 7810 Eff. Vertical stiffness (kv) kN/m 1660250.23 1673103.78 Damping (ᶓ) 0.10 0.10 Eff. Horizontal Stiffness (kh) kN/m 4590.82 5030.07 Pre yield stiffness (ku) kN/m 38696.08 42398.49 PYSR (Kd/Ku) 0.10 0.10 Yield force of lead plug (Qd) kN 149.30 163.59 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION In this study, the comparison of fixed and base isolated building is done. The totally four models are analyzed and the parameters like time period and base shear are compared using Bhuj earthquake data. 3.1 Time Period Fig-5: Time period for different models From fig.5 it is observed that, time period decreases with increase in mode number. As result of the increased flexibility of the system, time period of the structure is also increases. Table-4: Time period for different models in X and Y direction Model s Time period (S) X-X direction Y-Y direction 1A 2.97 3.09 1B 3.82 3.94 2A 2.49 2.83 2B 3.38 3.68 Fig-6: Mode period for different models along X and Y direction From figure 6 it is absorbed that, time period in model 1B is increased by 22% in X direction and 21% in Y direction compared to model 1A. Similarly in model 2B is increased by 27% in X direction and 23% in Y direction compared to model 2A. 3.2 Base Shear The table shows maximum base shear along X and Y direction. Table-5: Maximum base shear (kN) along X and Y direction for different models Models Base shear (kN) X-direction Y-direction 1A 3629.20 2793.13 1B 1988.94 1921.50 2A 5739.24 3596. 05 2B 2312.51 2362.89 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112 Timeperiod(S) Mode No. 1A 1B 2A 2B 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 X-Direction Y-Direction Timeperiod(S) 1A 1B 2A 2B
- 4. IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology eISSN: 2319-1163 | pISSN: 2321-7308 _______________________________________________________________________________________ Volume: 04 Issue: 06 | June-2015, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 292 Fig-7: Base shear (kN) along X and Y-direction From figure 7 is clear that, base shear in model 1B is decreased by 45% in X direction and 31% in Y direction compared to model 1A. Similarly in model 2B is decreased by 60% in X direction and 34% in Y direction compared to model 2A. 4. CONCLUSION By the analysis it is observed that base isolation increases the flexibility at the base level of the building. Time period of the structure increases by the use of lead rubber bearing which helps in less transfer of lateral forces at the time of earthquake. The increase in time period of the structure is found to be more in vertical irregular base isolated building compared to plan irregular base isolated building. The base isolation has high efficiency in decreasing the base shear compared to fixed base building. Reduction in base shear is more in vertical irregular base isolated building compared to plan irregular base isolated building. From the study it shows that, the vertical irregular building gives better performance by the use of isolators at the base of the building as compared to plan irregular building at higher seismic prone area. REFERENCES [1]. A. Abrishambaf and G. Ozay (2010), “Effects of isolation damping and stiffness on the seismic behaviour of structures”, ISBN: 978-960-474-251-6. [2]. Athamnia Brahim and Ounis Abdelhafid (2011), “Effects of seismic isolation in the reduction of the seismic response of the structure”, International Journal of Applied Engineering Research, Dindigul, Volume 2, No 2, 2011, ISSN 09764259. [3]. C.Prabha and Basil Sabu (2014) “Study of Base Isolation in Multi-Storeyed Buildings” ISSN: 2347 1964 (Online) 2347-1875 (Print) Vol.2, Issue 8. [4]. Farzad Naeim and James M. Kelly (1999), “Design of seismic isolated structure”, John Wiley and Sons, inc.Newyork. [5]. Fu Lin ZHOU, Zheng YANG, Wen Guang LIU And Ping TAN (2004), “ New Seismic Isolation System For Irregular Structure With The Largest Isolation Building Area In The World” 13th World Conference On Earthquake Engineering Vancouver, B.C., Canada, Paper No.2349. [6]. Hussein Shakeri Soleimanloo (2012), “A Survey study on design procedure of Seismic Base Isolation Systems”, J. Appl. Sci. Environ. Manage. Vol. 16 (4)299 -307. [7]. IS 1893 (part 1):2002, Criteria for earthquake resistant design of structures. [8]. IS 456:2000, Code of practice for plain and reinforced concrete. [9]. Ivan Skinner, R., Trevor E. Kelly and Bill Robinson, W.H. (1993) A text book on Seismic Isolation for Designers and Structural Engineers, Robinson seismic limited, Holmes consulting group. [10]. S.K. Sabu, H.S.Chore, S.B.Patil (2014), “Effectiveness of Lead Rubber Base Isolators, for seismic resistance of Buildings, supported on different soil stratas,” ISSN (Online): 2347-2820, Volume -2. [11]. Saiful Islam, A.B.M., Mohammed Jameel and Mohd Zamin Jumaat (2011), “Seismic isolation in buildings to be a practical reality’,ISSN 2006-9790, Journal of Engineering and Technology Research Vol. 3(4), pp. 99-117. [12]. Shirule P. A, Jagtap. L. P, Sonawane. K. R, Patil. T. D, Jadwanir. N and Sonar. S. K (2012), “Time History Analysis of Base Isolated Multi- Storyed Building”, ISSN 0974-5904, Volume 05, No. 04, P.P. 809-816. [13]. Syed Ahmed Kabeer K I and Sanjeev Kumar K.S (2014), “Comparison of Two Similar Buildings with and without Base Isolation”, International Journal of Advance research , Ideas and Innovations in technology, volume 1, Issue 1. [14]. T.K. Datta (2010), “Seismic Analysis of Structures”, Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, India. [15]. Trevor E Kelly, S.E. (2001), “Design Guidelines on Base Isolation of Structures”, Holmes consulting group, New Zealand. [16]. W.F. Chen and Charles Scawthorn (2003), “Earthquake Engineering Handbook” CRC press, Boca Raton London, New York, Washington. BIOGRAPHIES Vinodkumar Parma, pursuing post- graduation in Structural Engineering at Basaveshwar Engineering College, Bagalkot, Karnataka, India Asst. Prof. in Civil Engg. Dept., Basaveshwar Engineering College, Bagalkot, Karnataka, India 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 X-Direction Y-Direction Baseshear(kN) 1A 1B 2A 2B