Exploring Innovation Ecosystems
as Networks: Four European Cases
Jukka Huhtamäki and Neil Rubens
HICSS 2016, Kauai
 Innovation often takes place in the context of innovation
ecosystems (Adner and Kapoor 2010, Russell et al. 2011, Autio and
Thomas, 2013, Valkokari 2015)
 New data, tools, and questions are available for insights on latent
structures within innovation ecosystems (Basole et al. 2012, Still et al.
2012)
 Network analysis allows analyzing the structure and structural
dynamics of ecosystems of business and innovation (Russell et al.
2011, Basole et al. 2012)
 In this study, we present a novel approach for measuring
innovation ecosystems with socially constructed data and network
analysis
 …and contrast the results to a more traditional innovation
indicator, Innovation Union Scoreboard to investigate their
compatibility
Introduction
Quantitative metrics
La
Modest Innovator - Latvia
Moderate Innovator - Hungary
Innovation Follower - Estonia
Innovation Leader- Finland
 Network analysis of socially constructed data yields into results
that are comparable to traditional innovation indicators
 Importantly, the approach allows completely new insights into
the system-level structure of the innovation ecosystem
 In order to fully utilize the new actor-level metrics in
understanding innovation, we need equally specific output
metrics for innovation performance
 The new views allow and indeed insist new ways to conduct
decision-making in the context of innovation ecosystems
 Boundary specification has to be reconsidered – here we are
following national boundaries even though innovation does not
respect them!
Conclusions
 Developing means and methods to move beyond the
(sometimes) superficial statistical analyses and (often)
case-specific qualitative analyses
 …and to support interdisciplinary investigation of
innovation ecosystems that seek to discover mechanisms
and structures latent in innovation ecosystems, cf. critical
realism in analytics (Bygstad and Munkvold 2011)
 Imperatively, to enable true discourse between academic
research, decision-making and policy-making for
innovation (and business) ecosystems (cross-sector, cross-
border, cross-domain)
Future work
 Jukka is @jnkka
@TampereUnitech
 Neil is @activeintel
 We are part of @ien_stanford
 This research was partly
sponsored by Tekes: Finnish
Funding Agency for Innovation
Join the discussion

More Related Content

PPTX
Introduction: Jukka Huhtamäki | Dagstuhl 16141
PDF
Innovation Ecosystem Transformation – Finnish Perspective
PPTX
Relational Capital for Innovative Growth Companies: Start-ups and Relational ...
PDF
Design for Emergence – Enabling Stakeholder Liminal Transitions and Innovatio...
PPTX
Making sense of big data with the Ostinato Model
PDF
Computational Models in Systemic Design
PDF
Finding the emic in systemic design: Towards systemic ethnography
PDF
Understanding the wealth-creating potential of relationships :: Kredible.net ...
Introduction: Jukka Huhtamäki | Dagstuhl 16141
Innovation Ecosystem Transformation – Finnish Perspective
Relational Capital for Innovative Growth Companies: Start-ups and Relational ...
Design for Emergence – Enabling Stakeholder Liminal Transitions and Innovatio...
Making sense of big data with the Ostinato Model
Computational Models in Systemic Design
Finding the emic in systemic design: Towards systemic ethnography
Understanding the wealth-creating potential of relationships :: Kredible.net ...

What's hot (20)

PDF
Binocular vision of designing process for whole systems design crossing bound...
PPTX
The Early Stage Analysis of a Systemic Innovation Lab
PDF
Systemic Design Labs (SDL): Incubating systemic design skills through experie...
PPTX
Ecosystems in Management Research
PPTX
Ecosystems in Management Research
PPTX
Network Impact V5
PPTX
ABM intro talk
PPTX
Study Analytics: Or is it Learning Analytics?
PPTX
Evaluation: from reflective to deliberative practice?
PPTX
Systems thinking at the Tavistock Institute – past, present and future
PDF
Adoption, Acceptability, Acceptance
PPT
The New e-Science
PPTX
Lunchtime Talk: Evaluating design enabled innovations
PDF
Re-Defining Journalism Education: Using Systems Thinking and Design to Revolu...
PPTX
Keynote Speech: Societal transformation and Government 3.0
PPT
Applied e-democracy: the need for an information framework to support develop...
PPT
ARNOVA presentation 2013
PDF
Evolutionary Stakeholder Discovery: Requisite System Sampling for Co-Creation
PDF
Data analytics to support awareness and recommendation
Binocular vision of designing process for whole systems design crossing bound...
The Early Stage Analysis of a Systemic Innovation Lab
Systemic Design Labs (SDL): Incubating systemic design skills through experie...
Ecosystems in Management Research
Ecosystems in Management Research
Network Impact V5
ABM intro talk
Study Analytics: Or is it Learning Analytics?
Evaluation: from reflective to deliberative practice?
Systems thinking at the Tavistock Institute – past, present and future
Adoption, Acceptability, Acceptance
The New e-Science
Lunchtime Talk: Evaluating design enabled innovations
Re-Defining Journalism Education: Using Systems Thinking and Design to Revolu...
Keynote Speech: Societal transformation and Government 3.0
Applied e-democracy: the need for an information framework to support develop...
ARNOVA presentation 2013
Evolutionary Stakeholder Discovery: Requisite System Sampling for Co-Creation
Data analytics to support awareness and recommendation
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

PDF
The global API Ecosystem: A deep dive into gaming
PPT
TTY-tutuksi -seminaari: Introduction to Weak ties
PPTX
Twitter viestintänä -seminaari: Charlie Hebdo
PPTX
Visualizing Co-authorship Networks for Actionable Insights: Action Design Res...
PPTX
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan
PPTX
Visualizing the Geography of Platform Boundary Resources
PPT
How information spreads on social networks when unexpected events occur
PPT
ESRC Research Methods Festival - From Flickr to Snapchat: The challenge of an...
PPTX
Rebuilding evolution 20170106 v4
PDF
20160523 ljk tulevaisuuden verkostot_katri valkokari
PPTX
Spohrer dc trip 20160323 v2
PPTX
Spohrer icer 20150810 v1
PPT
Social media engagement
PPT
Picturing the Social: Talk for Transforming Digital Methods Winter School
PPT
Ketterämmin käytettävää
PDF
为11.2.0.2 grid infrastructure添加节点
PPT
Kutná hora
PPTX
Why do i wantg teacher to become a teacher?
PPTX
botox London
PPT
Bolum3111
The global API Ecosystem: A deep dive into gaming
TTY-tutuksi -seminaari: Introduction to Weak ties
Twitter viestintänä -seminaari: Charlie Hebdo
Visualizing Co-authorship Networks for Actionable Insights: Action Design Res...
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan
Visualizing the Geography of Platform Boundary Resources
How information spreads on social networks when unexpected events occur
ESRC Research Methods Festival - From Flickr to Snapchat: The challenge of an...
Rebuilding evolution 20170106 v4
20160523 ljk tulevaisuuden verkostot_katri valkokari
Spohrer dc trip 20160323 v2
Spohrer icer 20150810 v1
Social media engagement
Picturing the Social: Talk for Transforming Digital Methods Winter School
Ketterämmin käytettävää
为11.2.0.2 grid infrastructure添加节点
Kutná hora
Why do i wantg teacher to become a teacher?
botox London
Bolum3111
Ad

Similar to Exploring Innovation Ecosystems as Networks: Four European Cases (20)

PPTX
Markku markkula oi2.0 dublin final
PPTX
8 2-10 hkust eng
PPTX
Value Co-Creation in Innovation Ecosystems (English)
PPTX
Keynote Markku Markkula - From Smart Cities to Pioneering Regional Innovation...
PDF
Discussant: Innovation Ecosystems (AOM 2014)
PPTX
20141119 CEP lunchtime seminar
PPTX
Value Co-Creation in Innovation Ecosystems (Presentation @ Tokyo Institute of...
PPTX
05 - Une combinaison de Politiques : Au-delà de la Science
PDF
The Dynamics of Local Innovation Systems Structures Networks and Processes 1s...
PPTX
TCI 2015 Ecosystem Impact in Start-up Firms: A Comparative Analysis between S...
PDF
Open Innovation 2.0 – creating ecosystems! - European response
PDF
Handbook Of Innovation Indicators And Measurement Fred Gault
PPT
Networks of innovation relationships: multiscopic views on Finland
PDF
Towards Measuring Social Innovation: Some preliminary thoughts
PPTX
Emerging technology innovation systems: key considerations for policy making ...
PDF
The Dynamics of Local Innovation Systems Structures Networks and Processes 1s...
PPTX
Using Social Media to Leverage Triple Helix Insights in Innovation Ecosystems
PDF
Innovation And Production Ecosystems Guilhon Bernard
PDF
ASIS project - Innovation & societal challenges
PDF
Re|Imagine: Improving the Productivity of Federally Funded University Research
Markku markkula oi2.0 dublin final
8 2-10 hkust eng
Value Co-Creation in Innovation Ecosystems (English)
Keynote Markku Markkula - From Smart Cities to Pioneering Regional Innovation...
Discussant: Innovation Ecosystems (AOM 2014)
20141119 CEP lunchtime seminar
Value Co-Creation in Innovation Ecosystems (Presentation @ Tokyo Institute of...
05 - Une combinaison de Politiques : Au-delà de la Science
The Dynamics of Local Innovation Systems Structures Networks and Processes 1s...
TCI 2015 Ecosystem Impact in Start-up Firms: A Comparative Analysis between S...
Open Innovation 2.0 – creating ecosystems! - European response
Handbook Of Innovation Indicators And Measurement Fred Gault
Networks of innovation relationships: multiscopic views on Finland
Towards Measuring Social Innovation: Some preliminary thoughts
Emerging technology innovation systems: key considerations for policy making ...
The Dynamics of Local Innovation Systems Structures Networks and Processes 1s...
Using Social Media to Leverage Triple Helix Insights in Innovation Ecosystems
Innovation And Production Ecosystems Guilhon Bernard
ASIS project - Innovation & societal challenges
Re|Imagine: Improving the Productivity of Federally Funded University Research

More from Jukka Huhtamäki (20)

PPTX
Datavisualisoinnin perusteet – käytännönläheinen johdanto
PPTX
Diversity Exposure in Social Recommender Systems: A Social Capital Theory Pe...
PPTX
Sosiaalisen median analysointi ja dokumenttipohjainen tutkimus
PPTX
Kevyet lähdöt – case Twitter | Data-analytiikka liiketoiminnan kehittämisessä
PPTX
Organizational Hybridity and Fluidity: Possibilities and Challenges for Knowl...
PPTX
Mikä ekosysteemitutkimuksessa kiinnostaa juuri nyt?
PPTX
Sosiaalisen median analysointi ja dokumenttipohjainen tutkimus
PPTX
Katsaus API-talouteen | Edutech Pilviasiantuntija 2018
PPTX
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan | Edutech Pilviasiantuntija 2018
PPTX
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan: tapaus Twitter
PPTX
Five viewpoints to visualization
PPTX
Lean Startup ja datalla ohjattu kehitystyö
PPTX
Johdanto API-talouteen
PPTX
Katsaus API-talouteen 2017
PPTX
Kevyitä lähtöjä -johdanto
PPTX
Exploring platform boundary resources with a data-driven approach
PPTX
API-talous ja liiketoimintatiedon hallinta 2017
PPTX
Miten yritysverkostoja voi analysoida - ja miksi?
PPTX
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan
PPTX
Maailmankartta: API alustojen rajaresurssina
Datavisualisoinnin perusteet – käytännönläheinen johdanto
Diversity Exposure in Social Recommender Systems: A Social Capital Theory Pe...
Sosiaalisen median analysointi ja dokumenttipohjainen tutkimus
Kevyet lähdöt – case Twitter | Data-analytiikka liiketoiminnan kehittämisessä
Organizational Hybridity and Fluidity: Possibilities and Challenges for Knowl...
Mikä ekosysteemitutkimuksessa kiinnostaa juuri nyt?
Sosiaalisen median analysointi ja dokumenttipohjainen tutkimus
Katsaus API-talouteen | Edutech Pilviasiantuntija 2018
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan | Edutech Pilviasiantuntija 2018
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan: tapaus Twitter
Five viewpoints to visualization
Lean Startup ja datalla ohjattu kehitystyö
Johdanto API-talouteen
Katsaus API-talouteen 2017
Kevyitä lähtöjä -johdanto
Exploring platform boundary resources with a data-driven approach
API-talous ja liiketoimintatiedon hallinta 2017
Miten yritysverkostoja voi analysoida - ja miksi?
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan
Maailmankartta: API alustojen rajaresurssina

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Session 11 - Data Visualization Storytelling (2).pdf
PPTX
Caseware_IDEA_Detailed_Presentation.pptx
PPTX
CYBER SECURITY the Next Warefare Tactics
PPTX
CHAPTER-2-THE-ACCOUNTING-PROCESS-2-4.pptx
PPTX
retention in jsjsksksksnbsndjddjdnFPD.pptx
PPTX
Tapan_20220802057_Researchinternship_final_stage.pptx
PDF
©️ 01_Algorithm for Microsoft New Product Launch - handling web site - by Ale...
PPT
DU, AIS, Big Data and Data Analytics.ppt
PPTX
IMPACT OF LANDSLIDE.....................
PPTX
DS-40-Pre-Engagement and Kickoff deck - v8.0.pptx
PDF
Votre score augmente si vous choisissez une catégorie et que vous rédigez une...
PPT
PROJECT CYCLE MANAGEMENT FRAMEWORK (PCM).ppt
PDF
Global Data and Analytics Market Outlook Report
PPTX
sac 451hinhgsgshssjsjsjheegdggeegegdggddgeg.pptx
PPTX
SET 1 Compulsory MNH machine learning intro
PPTX
New ISO 27001_2022 standard and the changes
PPTX
Lesson-01intheselfoflifeofthekennyrogersoftheunderstandoftheunderstanded
PDF
CS3352FOUNDATION OF DATA SCIENCE _1_MAterial.pdf
PDF
Navigating the Thai Supplements Landscape.pdf
PPT
statistics analysis - topic 3 - describing data visually
Session 11 - Data Visualization Storytelling (2).pdf
Caseware_IDEA_Detailed_Presentation.pptx
CYBER SECURITY the Next Warefare Tactics
CHAPTER-2-THE-ACCOUNTING-PROCESS-2-4.pptx
retention in jsjsksksksnbsndjddjdnFPD.pptx
Tapan_20220802057_Researchinternship_final_stage.pptx
©️ 01_Algorithm for Microsoft New Product Launch - handling web site - by Ale...
DU, AIS, Big Data and Data Analytics.ppt
IMPACT OF LANDSLIDE.....................
DS-40-Pre-Engagement and Kickoff deck - v8.0.pptx
Votre score augmente si vous choisissez une catégorie et que vous rédigez une...
PROJECT CYCLE MANAGEMENT FRAMEWORK (PCM).ppt
Global Data and Analytics Market Outlook Report
sac 451hinhgsgshssjsjsjheegdggeegegdggddgeg.pptx
SET 1 Compulsory MNH machine learning intro
New ISO 27001_2022 standard and the changes
Lesson-01intheselfoflifeofthekennyrogersoftheunderstandoftheunderstanded
CS3352FOUNDATION OF DATA SCIENCE _1_MAterial.pdf
Navigating the Thai Supplements Landscape.pdf
statistics analysis - topic 3 - describing data visually

Exploring Innovation Ecosystems as Networks: Four European Cases

  • 1. Exploring Innovation Ecosystems as Networks: Four European Cases Jukka Huhtamäki and Neil Rubens HICSS 2016, Kauai
  • 2.  Innovation often takes place in the context of innovation ecosystems (Adner and Kapoor 2010, Russell et al. 2011, Autio and Thomas, 2013, Valkokari 2015)  New data, tools, and questions are available for insights on latent structures within innovation ecosystems (Basole et al. 2012, Still et al. 2012)  Network analysis allows analyzing the structure and structural dynamics of ecosystems of business and innovation (Russell et al. 2011, Basole et al. 2012)  In this study, we present a novel approach for measuring innovation ecosystems with socially constructed data and network analysis  …and contrast the results to a more traditional innovation indicator, Innovation Union Scoreboard to investigate their compatibility Introduction
  • 4. La Modest Innovator - Latvia Moderate Innovator - Hungary Innovation Follower - Estonia Innovation Leader- Finland
  • 5.  Network analysis of socially constructed data yields into results that are comparable to traditional innovation indicators  Importantly, the approach allows completely new insights into the system-level structure of the innovation ecosystem  In order to fully utilize the new actor-level metrics in understanding innovation, we need equally specific output metrics for innovation performance  The new views allow and indeed insist new ways to conduct decision-making in the context of innovation ecosystems  Boundary specification has to be reconsidered – here we are following national boundaries even though innovation does not respect them! Conclusions
  • 6.  Developing means and methods to move beyond the (sometimes) superficial statistical analyses and (often) case-specific qualitative analyses  …and to support interdisciplinary investigation of innovation ecosystems that seek to discover mechanisms and structures latent in innovation ecosystems, cf. critical realism in analytics (Bygstad and Munkvold 2011)  Imperatively, to enable true discourse between academic research, decision-making and policy-making for innovation (and business) ecosystems (cross-sector, cross- border, cross-domain) Future work
  • 7.  Jukka is @jnkka @TampereUnitech  Neil is @activeintel  We are part of @ien_stanford  This research was partly sponsored by Tekes: Finnish Funding Agency for Innovation Join the discussion